eCourtsIndiaBeta

Mahanagar Telecom Nigam Ltd vs. Telecom Regulatory Authority Of India

Court:Supreme Court of India
Judges:Hon'ble Indira Banerjee, Hon'ble Surya Kant, Hon'ble M.M. Sundresh
Case Type:Civil Appeal
Reg no:11374/2013
Filing no:28298/2010
CNR:SCIN010282982010

Parties & Advocates

Petitioner

1
Mahanagar Telecom Nigam Ltd

Petitioner Advocate

1
Rashmi Malhotra

Respondents

1
Telecom Regulatory Authority Of India
2
Association Of Unified Telecom Service Providers Of India (auspi)
3
Tata Teleservices Ltd
4
Hfcl Infotel Ltd
5
Reliance Communications Ltd
6
Cellular Operators Association Of India
7
Aircel Digilink India Ltd
8
Bharti Airtel Ltd. (now Bharti Televentures Ltd. )
9
Bpl Mobile Communications Ltd
10
Fascel Ltd
11
Hutchison Essar Limited
12
Hutchison Essar Cellular Limited
13
Hutchison Essar Mobile Services Limited
14
Hutchison Essar South Limited
15
Hutchison Telecom East Limited
16
Spice Communications Ltd
17
Bsnl

Respondent Advocates

1
Bina Gupta
2
Sanjay Kapur
3
Abhinav Mukerji
4
Gagan Gupta
5
Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar

Case History with Orders

Pending

Final Status

5 Mar 2025

Order(110) - 5 Mar 2025

ROP - of Main Case

29 Feb 2024

Order(109) - 29 Feb 2024

ROP - of Main Case

13 Feb 2023

Order(108) - 13 Feb 2023

ROP - of Main Case

13 Sept 2022

Order(107) - 13 Sept 2022

ROP - of Main Case

Three Judges Bench Matter

Purpose:Ordinary
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Indira Banerjee, Hon'ble Surya Kant, Hon'ble M.M. Sundresh
List In:Judge

List on fixed month [11]

14 Feb 2022

Order(106) - 14 Feb 2022

ROP - of Main Case

25 Feb 2021

Order(105) - 25 Feb 2021

ROP - of Main Case

25 Feb 2020

Order(104) - 25 Feb 2020

ROP - of Main Case

13 Jan 2020

Order(103) - 13 Jan 2020

ROP - of Main Case

12 Feb 2019

Order(102) - 12 Feb 2019

ROP - of Main Case

1 Feb 2019

Order(101) - 1 Feb 2019

ROP - of Main Case

8 Mar 2018

Order(100) - 8 Mar 2018

ROP - of Main Case

2 May 2017

Order(99) - 2 May 2017

ROP

Order(98) - 2 May 2017

ROP

24 Apr 2017

Order(97) - 24 Apr 2017

ROP

Order(96) - 24 Apr 2017

ROP

8 Mar 2017

Order(95) - 8 Mar 2017

ROP

Order(94) - 8 Mar 2017

ROP

15 Jul 2016

Order(93) - 15 Jul 2016

ROP

Order(92) - 15 Jul 2016

ROP

10 May 2016

Order(91) - 10 May 2016

ROP

Order(90) - 10 May 2016

ROP

29 Feb 2016

Order(89) - 29 Feb 2016

ROP - of Main Case

Order(88) - 29 Feb 2016

ROP - of Main Case

9 Mar 2015

Order(87) - 9 Mar 2015

ROP

Order(86) - 9 Mar 2015

ROP

27 Feb 2015

Order(85) - 27 Feb 2015

ROP

26 Feb 2015

Order(84) - 26 Feb 2015

ROP

Order(83) - 26 Feb 2015

ROP

11 Nov 2014

Order(82) - 11 Nov 2014

ROP

Order(81) - 11 Nov 2014

ROP

15 Oct 2014

Order(80) - 15 Oct 2014

ROP

Order(79) - 15 Oct 2014

ROP

21 Aug 2014

Order(78) - 21 Aug 2014

ROP

13 Aug 2014

Order(77) - 13 Aug 2014

ROP - of Main Case

27 Mar 2014

Order(76) - 27 Mar 2014

ROP

26 Mar 2014

Order(75) - 26 Mar 2014

ROP

5 Mar 2014

Order(74) - 5 Mar 2014

ROP

26 Feb 2014

Order(73) - 26 Feb 2014

ROP

6 Dec 2013

Order(72) - 6 Dec 2013

ROP

Order(71) - 6 Dec 2013

Judgment

Case Registered

Registration No: 11374/2013

22 Nov 2012

Order(70) - 22 Nov 2012

ROP

20 Nov 2012

Order(69) - 20 Nov 2012

ROP

9 Oct 2012

Order(68) - 9 Oct 2012

ROP

5 Sept 2012

Order(67) - 5 Sept 2012

ROP

17 Jul 2012

Order(66) - 17 Jul 2012

ROP

10 Jul 2012

Order(65) - 10 Jul 2012

ROP

27 Apr 2012

Order(64) - 27 Apr 2012

ROP

13 Apr 2012

Order(63) - 13 Apr 2012

ROP

30 Mar 2012

Order(62) - 30 Mar 2012

ROP

21 Mar 2012

Order(61) - 21 Mar 2012

ROP

2 Feb 2012

Order(60) - 2 Feb 2012

ROP

28 Nov 2011

Order(59) - 28 Nov 2011

ROP

2 Nov 2011

Order(58) - 2 Nov 2011

ROP

19 Oct 2011

Order(57) - 19 Oct 2011

ROP

13 Oct 2011

Order(56) - 13 Oct 2011

ROP

10 Aug 2011

Order(55) - 10 Aug 2011

ROP

29 Jul 2011

Order(54) - 29 Jul 2011

ROP

15 Jul 2011

Order(53) - 15 Jul 2011

ROP

4 Feb 2011

Order(52) - 4 Feb 2011

ROP

15 Dec 2010

Order(51) - 15 Dec 2010

ROP

14 Dec 2010

Order(50) - 14 Dec 2010

ROP

9 Dec 2010

Order(49) - 9 Dec 2010

ROP

25 Nov 2010

Order(48) - 25 Nov 2010

ROP

11 Nov 2010

Order(47) - 11 Nov 2010

ROP

26 Oct 2010

Order(46) - 26 Oct 2010

ROP

Order(45) - 26 Oct 2010

ROP

21 Oct 2010

Order(44) - 21 Oct 2010

ROP

7 Sept 2010

Case Filed

7 Sept 2010 Filing No: 28298/2010

13 Jul 2010

Order(43) - 13 Jul 2010

ROP

19 Apr 2010

Order(42) - 19 Apr 2010

ROP - of Main Case

20 Jan 2010

Order(41) - 20 Jan 2010

ROP - of Main Case

7 Sept 2009

Order(40) - 7 Sept 2009

ROP - of Main Case

23 Jul 2009

Order(39) - 23 Jul 2009

ROP - of Main Case

15 Jul 2009

Order(38) - 15 Jul 2009

ROP

14 May 2009

Order(37) - 14 May 2009

ROP - of Main Case

13 May 2009

Order(36) - 13 May 2009

ROP - of Main Case

Order(35) - 13 May 2009

ROP - of Main Case

24 Feb 2009

Order(34) - 24 Feb 2009

ROP

18 Feb 2009

Order(33) - 18 Feb 2009

ROP - of Main Case

9 Feb 2009

Order(32) - 9 Feb 2009

ROP

30 Jan 2009

Order(31) - 30 Jan 2009

ROP

16 Jan 2009

Order(30) - 16 Jan 2009

ROP

7 Jan 2009

Order(29) - 7 Jan 2009

ROP

25 Nov 2008

Order(28) - 25 Nov 2008

ROP

20 Nov 2008

Order(27) - 20 Nov 2008

ROP

17 Oct 2008

Order(26) - 17 Oct 2008

ROP

11 Sept 2008

Order(25) - 11 Sept 2008

ROP

22 Aug 2008

Order(24) - 22 Aug 2008

ROP

13 Aug 2008

Order(23) - 13 Aug 2008

ROP

17 Jul 2008

Order(22) - 17 Jul 2008

ROP

28 Apr 2008

Order(21) - 28 Apr 2008

ROP

28 Mar 2008

Order(20) - 28 Mar 2008

ROP

Order(19) - 28 Mar 2008

ROP

21 Jan 2008

Order(18) - 21 Jan 2008

ROP

3 Dec 2007

Order(17) - 3 Dec 2007

ROP - of Main Case

12 Nov 2007

Order(16) - 12 Nov 2007

ROP

25 Apr 2007

Order(15) - 25 Apr 2007

ROP

13 Dec 2006

Order(14) - 13 Dec 2006

ROP - of Main Case

14 Nov 2006

Order(13) - 14 Nov 2006

ROP - of Main Case

4 Sept 2006

Order(12) - 4 Sept 2006

ROP - of Main Case

17 Jul 2006

Order(11) - 17 Jul 2006

ROP

10 Feb 2006

Order(10) - 10 Feb 2006

ROP

5 Dec 2005

Order(9) - 5 Dec 2005

ROP - of Main Case

21 Oct 2005

Order(8) - 21 Oct 2005

ROP

18 Oct 2005

Order(7) - 18 Oct 2005

ROP

3 Oct 2005

Order(6) - 3 Oct 2005

ROP

8 Aug 2005

Order(5) - 8 Aug 2005

ROP

18 Jul 2005

Order(4) - 18 Jul 2005

ROP - of Main Case

19 May 2005

Order(3) - 19 May 2005

ROP - of Main Case

12 May 2005

Order(2) - 12 May 2005

ROP - of Main Case

Order(1) - 12 May 2005

ROP

Interlocutory Applications (IA) (1)

1/2010
Particular: PERMISSION TO FILE APPEAL

Tagged Matters (22)

10512/2005(11-05-2005 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 003298 / 2005 Registered on 11-05-2005 - CA

Petitioner: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
Respondent: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED
Type: M•Status: P•Entry: 03-03-2017

304/2005(04-02-2005 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000951 - 000952 / 2005 Registered on 04-02-2005D No. 000304 / 2005 Registered on 04-02-2005 - CA

Petitioner: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN
Respondent: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD. AND ANR.
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

10476/2005(12-05-2005 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 003299 / 2005 Registered on 12-05-2005 - CA

Petitioner: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTH. OF INDIA THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN
Respondent: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD. THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

14312/2005(27-07-2005 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 004529 / 2005 Registered on 27-07-2005 - CA

Petitioner: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN
Respondent: MAHANAGAR TELEPHONE NIGAM LIMITED THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

15406/2005(20-09-2005 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 005834 - 005836 / 2005 Registered on 20-09-2005 - CA

Petitioner: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD. THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
Respondent: ASSOCIATION OF BASIC TELECOM OPERATORS(NOW ASSOCIATION OF UNIFIED SERVICE PROVIDERS OF INDIA). THROU
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

15408/2005(20-09-2005 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 005837 / 2005 Registered on 20-09-2005 - CA

Petitioner: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD., NEW DELHI THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
Respondent: CELLULAR OPERATORS ASSOCIATION OF INDIA THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

16147/2005(21-10-2005 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 006049 / 2005 Registered on 21-10-2005 - CA

Petitioner: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD. THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
Respondent: CELLULAR OPERATORS ASSN.INDIA . THROUGH ITS SECRETARY
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

24497/2005(23-01-2006 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000802 / 2006 Registered on 23-01-2006D No. 024497 / 2005 Registered on 23-01-2006 - CA

Petitioner: CELLULAR OPERATORS ASSOCN OF INDIA THROUGH DIRECTOR GENERAL
Respondent: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD. . THROUGH SECRETARY
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

14183/2006(06-06-2006 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 002731 / 2006 Registered on 06-06-2006 - CA

Petitioner: TATA TELESERVICES LIMITED
Respondent: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

12833/2006(05-07-2006 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 002794 / 2006 Registered on 05-07-2006 - CA

Petitioner: RELIANCE INFOCOMM LTD. THROUGH ITS PRESIDENT
Respondent: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

18927/2006(11-08-2006 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 003504 / 2006 Registered on 11-08-2006D No. 018927 / 2006 Registered on 11-08-2006 - CA

Petitioner: BHARTI TELEVENTURES LTD. THROUGH ITS VICE PRESIDENT LEGAL
Respondent: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA THROUGH ITS SECRETARY
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

30462/2007(24-10-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 004965 - 004966 / 2007 Registered on 24-10-2007 - CA

Petitioner: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD.
Respondent: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

256/2008(09-01-2008 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000177 / 2008 Registered on 09-01-2008 - CA

Petitioner: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD.
Respondent: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTH. OF INDIA
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

60195/2007(15-01-2008 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000598 - 000599 / 2008 Registered on 15-01-2008D No. 036778 / 2007 Registered on 15-01-2008 - CA

Petitioner: CELLULLAR OPERATORS ASSOC. OF INDIA
Respondent: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTH. OF INDIA
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

20672/2010(09-07-2010 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 005184 / 2010 Registered on 09-07-2010 - CA

Petitioner: CELLULAR OPERATORS ASSN.OF INDIA .
Respondent: B.S.N.L.
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 04-02-2023

21167/2010(12-07-2010 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 005253 / 2010 Registered on 12-07-2010 - CA

Petitioner: B.S.N.L.
Respondent: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTH.OF INDIA AND ORS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

22296/2010(22-07-2010 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 005873 / 2010 Registered on 22-07-2010 - CA

Petitioner: ASSOCIATION OF UNI.TELE.SERVICE PROVIDER OF INDIA
Respondent: B.S.N.L
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

23681/2010(29-07-2010 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 006068 / 2010 Registered on 29-07-2010 - CA

Petitioner: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
Respondent: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

23660/2010(31-07-2010 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 006255 / 2010 Registered on 31-07-2010D No. 023660 / 2010 Registered on 31-07-2010 - CA

Petitioner: M/S.SISTEMA SHYAM TELESERVICES LTD.
Respondent: B.S.N.L..AND ORS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

60164/2010(13-12-2010 12:00 AM)T.C.(C) No. 000039 / 2010 Registered on 13-12-2010 - UNKNOWN

Petitioner: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHY OF INDIA
Respondent: TELECOM DISPUTE SETTLMT. APP.TRIBUNAL
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

39378/2010(10-01-2011 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000271 - 000281 / 2011 Registered on 10-01-2011 - CA

Petitioner: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTH.OF INDIA
Respondent: BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD.
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

28298/2010(06-12-2013 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 011374 / 2013 Registered on 06-12-2013D No. 028298 / 2010 Registered on 06-12-2013 - CA

Petitioner: MAHANAGAR TELECOM NIGAM LTD.
Respondent: TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 19-03-2025

Earlier Court Details (1)

Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
AN-4-2007
Order Date:
2010-05-28
Judgment Challenged:
Yes
Judgment Type:
Final

Share This Case

Similar Case Search
Case Content Last Updated22 Aug 2025, 9:10 am IST