The State Of Goa State Of Goa Secretary vs. Narayan V. Gaonkar

Court:Supreme Court of India
Judges:Hon'ble Ashok Bhushan, Hon'ble Navin Sinha
Case Type:Civil Appeal
Reg no:1866/2020
Filing no:16763/2012
CNR:SCIN010167632012

Parties & Advocates

Petitioner

1
The State Of Goa State Of Goa Secretary

Petitioner Advocate

1
Surjendu Sankar Das

Respondents

1
Narayan V. Gaonkar
2
Tulsi S. Gaonkar (dead) Lrs
3
1 Shri Vishnu Shivram Gaonkar
4
2 Smt. Sushma Vishnu Gaonkar
5
Shri Vishnu S. Gaonkar
6
Shri Krishna S. Gaonkar (dead) Thr Lrs
7
1 Shri Jiva Krishna Gaonkar
8
2 Smt. Tanisha Jiva Gaonkar
9
3 Shri Sarvesh Krishna Gaonkar
10
Shriram Vasant Sawant
11
Gulabi Kushali Fal Desai (dead) Thr. Lrs
12
1 Shri Vasudev Kushali Fal Dessai
13
2 Smt. Vishranti Vasudev Fal Dessai
14
3 Shri Rajesh Kushali Fal Dessai
15
4 Shri Pravin Kushali Fal Dessai
16
Sushma Vishnu Gaonkar
17
Kalpana Krishna Gaonkar
18
Shri Rama S. F. Desai (dead) Thr. Lrs
19
1 Shaba R. R. Dessai
20
1. 1 Smt. Sampada Shaba Dessai
21
1. 2 Smt. Asmita Shaba Phadto Dessai
22
1. 3 Smt. Apurva Shaba Phadto Dessai
23
1. 4 Shri Vijay Shaba Fatto Dessai
24
2 Shri Anand Ram F. Dessai
25
3 Baby @ Suchita Shashikant Prabhu Dessai (dead) Thr. Lrs
26
3. 1 Pravin Shashikant Prabhu Dessai
27
3. 2 Chandrashekhar S. Prabhu
28
3. 3 Paratibha Niwas Phal Dessai
29
3. 4 Mr. Niwas Faldessai
30
4 Shalini Prakash Phal Dessai
31
5 Meghan Maruti Sawant Dessai
32
The Collector
33
The Director Of Survey And Settlement Officer
34
The Chief Secretary

Respondent Advocate

1
A. Subhashini

Case History with Orders

4 Mar 2020

Disposed - 4 Mar 2020

Final Status

4 Mar 2020

For Judgement

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Ashok Bhushan, Hon'ble Navin Sinha
List In:Judge

Appeals(s) allowed

28 Feb 2020

Case Registered

Registration No: 1866/2020

26 Feb 2020

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Ashok Bhushan, Hon'ble Navin Sinha
List In:Judge

Leave Granted / Rule NISI / Appeal Admitted, Heard & Reserved

28 Jan 2020

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Ashok Bhushan, Hon'ble Navin Sinha
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [26-02-2020]

10 Dec 2019

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Ashok Bhushan, Hon'ble Navin Sinha
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [28-01-2020]

20 Nov 2019

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Ashok Bhushan, Hon'ble Navin Sinha
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [10-12-2019]

24 Sept 2019

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Navin Sinha, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [20-11-2019]

12 Sept 2019

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Navin Sinha, Hon'ble Indira Banerjee
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [24-09-2019]

11 Sept 2019

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Administrative Order
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Navin Sinha, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [12-09-2019]

3 Jul 2019

Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar

25 Feb 2019

Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar

List before court/bench

22 Jan 2019

Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar

List On (Date) [25-02-2019]

3 Dec 2018

Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar

28 Sept 2018

Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar

List On (Date) [03-12-2018]

8 Aug 2018

Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)

Purpose:Ordinary
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar

List On (Date) [28-09-2018]

11 Sept 2017

Default / Other Matters

Purpose:Next Week / Week Commencing / C.o.week
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Sanjay Kishan Kaul
List In:Chamber

Other [IAs allowed]

30 Aug 2017

First Hearing

Initial hearing scheduled

Default / Other Matters

Purpose:Ordinary
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble L. Nageswara Rao
List In:Chamber

10 May 2012

Case Filed

10 May 2012 Filing No: 16763/2012

Interlocutory Applications (IA) (11)

2/2013
Particular: APPLICATION FOR TRANSPOSITION
217/2013
Filing Date: 2013-01-02
105683/2013
Filing Date: 2013-11-21
40983/2016
Filing Date: 2016-05-24
3/2016
Particular: APPLICATION FOR SUBSTITUTION
Filed by: MR. T. MAHIPAL
Filing Date: 2016-06-14
4/2016
Particular: CONDONATION OF DELAY IN FILING SUBSTITUTION APPLN.
Filed by: MR. T. MAHIPAL
Filing Date: 2016-06-14
5/2016
Particular: PERMISSION TO FILE ANNEXURES
Filed by: MR. T. MAHIPAL
Filing Date: 2016-06-16
74471/2016
Particular: SUBSTITUTION, C/D
Filing Date: 2016-09-30
6/2016
Particular: APPLICATION FOR SUBSTITUTION
Filed by: MR. T. MAHIPAL
Filing Date: 2016-10-19
7/2016
Particular: CONDONATION OF DELAY IN FILING SUBSTITUTION APPLN.
Filed by: MR. T. MAHIPAL
Filing Date: 2016-10-19
187381/2019
Particular: PERMISSION TO FILE ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS/FACTS/ANNEXURES
Filed by: SURJENDU SANKAR DAS
Filing Date: 2019-12-05

Earlier Court Details (1)

Court:
High Court
State:
MAHARASHTRA
Case No:
FA-115-2001
Order Date:
2011-06-30
Judgment Challenged:
Yes
Judgment Type:
Final

Notices (57)

S.No. 1
333942/2019-12-12
Notice Type: Original Record Letter in continuation (new)
Name:The
Location:
Issue Date:12 Dec 2019
Return Date:28 Jan 2020
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 2
333941/2019-12-12
Notice Type: Original Record Letter in continuation (new)
Name:Surjendu Sankar Das-2455copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:12 Dec 2019
Return Date:28 Jan 2020
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 3
333941/2019-12-12
Notice Type: Original Record Letter in continuation (new)
Name:A. Subhashini-15copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:12 Dec 2019
Return Date:28 Jan 2020
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 4
333941/2019-12-12
Notice Type: Original Record Letter in continuation (new)
Name:Through High Court Of Judicature At Bombay At Goa Maharashtra
Location:MUMBAI, MAHARASHTRA
Issue Date:12 Dec 2019
Return Date:28 Jan 2020
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 5
91684/2019-03-25
Notice Type: letter to advocate with order quote
Name:Through A. Subhashini-15
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:25 Mar 2019
Return Date:4 Nov 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 6
62942/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Mr. Niwas Faldessai S/O Late Shashikant Prabhu Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 7
62942/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 8
62941/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 9
62941/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Paratibha Niwas Phal Dessai D/O Late Shashikant Prabhu Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 10
62941/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:A. Subhashini-15copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 11
62940/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 12
62940/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Chandrashekhar S. Prabhu S/O Late Shashikant Prabhu Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 13
62939/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Pravin Shashikant Prabhu Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 14
62938/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Shri Vijay Shaba Fatto Dessai S/O Late Shaba Fatto Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 15
62938/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 16
62937/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Smt. Apurva Shaba Phadto Dessai D/O Late Shaba F. Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 17
62937/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 18
62936/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Smt. Asmita Shaba Phadto Dessai D/O Late Shaba F. Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 19
62936/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 20
62935/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 21
62935/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Smt. Sampada Shaba Dessai W/O Late Shaba R.R. Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 22
62935/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:A. Subhashini-15copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 23
62934/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 24
62934/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Meghan Maruti Sawant Dessai D/O Late Rama S.F. Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 25
62933/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 26
62933/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Shalini Prakash Phal Dessai D/O Late Rama S.F. Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 27
62932/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Baby @ Suchita Shashikant Prabhu Dessai (Dead) Thr. Lrs. D/O D/O Late Rama S.F. Dessai,W/O Shashikant Prabhu Dessai (Dead) Thr. Lrs.
Location:GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 28
62932/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:A. Subhashini-15copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 29
62932/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 30
62931/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 31
62931/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Shri Anand Ram F. Dessai S/O Late Rama S.F. Dessai
Location:GOA, SOUTH GOA
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 32
62931/2018-04-24
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:A. Subhashini-15copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:24 Apr 2018
Return Date:7 Feb 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 33
52603/2020-03-16
Notice Type: Civil Appeal Dismissal Letter
Name:The Civil Judge,
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:16 Mar 2020
Return Date:N/A
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 34
52602/2020-03-16
Notice Type: Civil Appeal Dismissal Letter
Name:The Registrar,
Location:MAHARASHTRA, MUMBAI
Issue Date:16 Mar 2020
Return Date:N/A
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 35
48644/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 36
48644/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Shri Pravin Kushali Fal Dessai S/O Smt. Gulabi Kushali Fal Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 37
48643/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 38
48643/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Shri Rajesh Kushali Fal Dessai S/O Smt. Gulabi Kushali Fal Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 39
48642/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 40
48642/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Smt. Vishranti Vasudev Fal Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 41
48641/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 42
48641/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Shri Vasudev Kushali Fal Dessai S/O Smt. Gulabi Kushali Fal Dessai
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 43
48640/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Shri Sarvesh Krishna Gaonkar
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 44
48639/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Smt. Tanisha Jiva Gaonkar
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 45
48638/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Shri Jiva Krishna Gaonkar S/O Shri Krishna S. Gaonkar
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 46
48637/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Smt. Sushma Vishnu Gaonkar D/O Smt. Tulsi S. Gaonkar
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 47
48636/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Shri Vishnu Shivram Gaonkar S/O Smt. Tulsi S. Gaonkar
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 48
48636/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:A. Subhashini-15copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 49
48636/2017-11-29
Notice Type: due course notice in SLP
Name:Merusagar Samantaray-1694copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:29 Nov 2017
Return Date:15 Jan 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 50
14630/2020-01-22
Notice Type: Letter Acknowledging the receipt of the Original Record
Name:Surjendu Sankar Das-2455copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:22 Jan 2020
Return Date:28 Jan 2020
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 51
14630/2020-01-22
Notice Type: Letter Acknowledging the receipt of the Original Record
Name:
Location:
Issue Date:22 Jan 2020
Return Date:28 Jan 2020
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 52
14629/2020-01-22
Notice Type: Letter Acknowledging the receipt of the Original Record
Name:Surjendu Sankar Das-2455copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:22 Jan 2020
Return Date:28 Jan 2020
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 53
14629/2020-01-22
Notice Type: Letter Acknowledging the receipt of the Original Record
Name:
Location:
Issue Date:22 Jan 2020
Return Date:28 Jan 2020
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 54
11459/2021-01-27
Notice Type: letter to High Court for Original Records
Name:Civil Judge,
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:27 Jan 2021
Return Date:N/A
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 55
11451/2021-01-27
Notice Type: letter to High Court for Original Records
Name:The Registrar
Location:GOA, NORTH GOA
Issue Date:27 Jan 2021
Return Date:N/A
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 56
10221/2020-01-16
Notice Type: Letter Acknowledging the receipt of the Original Record
Name:Surjendu Sankar Das-2455copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:16 Jan 2020
Return Date:28 Jan 2020
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 57
10221/2020-01-16
Notice Type: Letter Acknowledging the receipt of the Original Record
Name:
Location:
Issue Date:16 Jan 2020
Return Date:28 Jan 2020
Dispatch Date:Pending

Share This Case

Similar Case Search

Same Parties

Search in District Courts Data

Case Content Last Updated22 Aug 2025, 11:39 am IST