Union Of India Ministry Of Home Affairs Secretary vs. Rfn/Gd P K Shahi
Court:Supreme Court of India
Judges:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble L. Nageswara Rao
Case Type:Civil Appeal
Filing no:13720/2013
CNR:SCIN010137202013
Parties & Advocates
Petitioners
1
Union Of India Ministry Of Home Affairs Secretary
2
Secretary
3
The Director General
4
The Brigadier (pers)
Petitioner Advocate
1
B. Krishna Prasad
Respondents
1
Rfn/gd P K Shahi
2
Sarvendra Singh Chauhan
3
Sub Maj Faujdar Ram
4
Sub/orl Shiv Shanker
5
Sub/orl K N Prasad
6
Sub/orl R P Singh
7
Sub/ciph S K Das
8
Sub/ciph D B Biswas
9
Sub/efs Madhusudan Ka
10
Nb Sb (clk) Amrit Singh
11
Wo/rm Kn Thakur
12
Wo/rm Harish Kumar
13
Hav/orl Ashok Kr Prasad
14
Hav/orl Shaji S
15
Hav/orl Bhag Chand
16
Hav/orl Anil Kumar A
17
Hav/orl Hr Prasad
18
Hav/orl Sudarsanan N
19
Hav/orl Sudarsen G
20
Hav/orl Ramesh Thakur
21
Hav/orl S K Singh
22
Hav/orl Subhash Chandra
23
Hav/orl Ramanand Upreti
24
Hav/orl Basant Ballabh
25
Hav/orl U D Bhatt
26
Hav/orl S K Shani
27
Hav/orl Girish Singh
28
Hav/orl Ajay Bali
29
Hav/orl Lalit Singh
30
Hav/orl Rajendra Singh
31
Hav/efs Jyothi G
32
Hav/efs O P Rai
33
Rfn/lmn Kailash Chandra
34
Rfn/orln S Rathi
35
Rfn/ Orl S Terrsaim Lal
36
Rfn/orl P K Roy
37
Rfn/orl Dimple Kumar
38
Rfn/orl Binu P Pillai
39
Rfn/orl Jai Pal Singh
40
Rfn/orl Sajeev V G
41
Hav/ciph Vijay Kumar K
42
Hav/ciph Sanjay Kumar
43
Hav/ciph Mathew Joseph
44
Hav/ciph M P Yadav
45
Hav/ciph Trilok Singh
46
Hav/ciph Prakash Singh
47
Hav/ciph R A Yadav
48
Hav/gd Madan Pal
49
Rfn/gd Jantu Das
50
Rfn/gd S D Barman
51
Rfn/gd Imtisesen Ao
52
Rfn/gd B L Bangra
53
Rfn/gd W Ranjit Singh
54
Rfn/satei Ram Sewak
55
Hev/gd Md Esad Khan
56
Wo/rm Basu Ranjan Das
57
Wo/rm S P Choudhary
58
Hav/orl S N Roy
59
Hav/orl Benudhar Baruah 3
60
Hav/orl Dev Nath Prasad
61
Hav/orl Samer Singh
62
Hav/orl Uttam Singh
63
Hav/orl H S Sonowal
64
Hav/orl Kuldeep Singh
65
Hav/orl Vijay Nair
66
Hav/orl Thomas M C
67
Hav/orl Mathew Joshph
68
Hav/orl R K Yadav
69
Hav/orl Suresh J
70
Hav/orl B Singh
71
Hav/orl Cherian K C
72
Hav/orl Subhash Chander
73
Hav/orl Ajith Singh Loar
74
Hav/orl Velu Nair R
75
Hav/orl Dayanand Yadav
76
Hav/orl D D Bhatt
77
Hav/orl M S Rana
78
Hav/orl T N Tripathi
79
Hav/orl Dharam Pal
80
Hav/orl Maohar Das
81
Hav/ciph Suraj Chhetri
82
Hav/ciph B S Rawat
83
Hav/ciph Shio Pujan Prasad
84
Hav/ciph Jhantu Barik
85
Hav/ciph Satr Ughan Singh
86
Hav/ciph Kedar Nath Singh
87
Hav/ciph Jiten Kumar Singha
88
Hav/ciph Bir Bahadur Singh
89
Hav/ciph B S Negi
90
Hav/ciph H S Mishra
91
Hav/efs P G Shaji
92
Rfn/orl Krishna Kumar
93
Rfn/orl Ombir Singh
94
Rfn/orl Suresh Kumar
95
Rfn/orl Santosh Rawat
96
Rfn/orl Prabhansh Yadav
97
Rfn/orl Ishwar Singh
98
Rfn/orl Veerpal Singh
99
Rfn/orl Mohan Singh
100
Rfn/orl Surjeet Lama
101
Rfn/orl Sunil Kumar G
102
Rfn/orl Narayan Ray
103
Rfn/orl M K Rawat
104
Rfn/orl Laxman Singh
105
Rfn/orl U K Thakur
106
Rfn/orl P S Negi
107
Rfn/orl L Lunkim
108
Rfn/orl S S Bharti
109
Rfn/orl Inder Kumar
110
Rfn/orl Sunil Semwal
111
Rfn/orl Zameer Ahmed
112
Rfn/orl D S Rathore
113
Rfn/orl Raghuvir Singh
114
Rfn/orl Sachidanand
115
Rfn/orl Jagmohan Singh
116
Rfn/orl M S Rawat
117
Rfn/orl Birender
118
Rfn/orl Kalyan Ram
119
Rfn/orl S S Rawat
120
Rfn/orl H S Rawat
121
Rfn/orl Ombeer
122
Rfn/orl Ramesh Chand
123
Rfn/orl Sudir Singh
124
Rfn/orl Devendra Singh
125
Rfn/orl Birendra Prasad
126
Rfn/orl Md. Rafique
127
Rfn/orl S K Singh
128
Rfn/orl Ekbal Mahendi
129
Rfn/orl Yaspal Sngh
130
Rfn/orl O B Singha
131
Rfn/orl Dipak Saikia
132
Rfn/orl Lakhya Gogoi
133
Rfn/orl Shashi Bhushan
134
Rfn/orl Rajesh Kumar
135
Rfn/orl Man Singh
136
Rfn/orl Surjeet Singh
137
Rfnorl Lal Singh
138
Rfn/orl Ksh Sanamacha Singh
139
Rfn/orl Arjun Singh
140
Rfn/orl Harish Bisht
141
Rfn/orl B Kharkhonger
142
Rfn/orl Satyendra Prasad
143
Rfn/orl D B Gurung
144
Rfn/orl M Khonglam
145
Rfn/oir B C Rabha
146
Rfn/orl Sunil Raj R
147
Rfn/orl Biju Babu
148
Rfn/orl A K Singh
149
Rfn/orl R R Ravi
150
Rfn/orl Bijay Kumar
151
Rfn/orl Riyaz Khan
152
Rfn/orl Bijay Kumar Ojha
153
Rfn/orl Tarsem Lal
154
Rfn/orl Raghudev Singh
155
Rfn/orl Satpal Sharma
156
Rfn/orl Suresh Rai
157
Rfn/orl Rajesh Kumar Yadav
158
Rfn/orl Dharmender Kumar
159
Rfn/orl Tulshi Chhetri
160
Rfn/orl K W H Hossain
161
Rfn/orl Syed Ali Akmal
162
Rfn/orl Sashi Kant Mishra
163
Rfn/orl Sunil Singh
164
Rfn/orl Abul Kalam
165
Rfn/orl Rajesh Basnet
166
Rfn/orl Jitu Deuri
167
Rfn/orl Ram Singh Sarmant
168
Rfn/orl Ashsish Mohan Sharma
169
Rfn/orl S S Chouhan
170
Rfn/orl V J Reddy
171
Rfn/orl P K Barik
172
Rfn/orl J R Pradhan
173
Rfn/orl Hrusikesh Palai
174
Rfn/orl Japan Kumar Deb Barman
175
Rfn/orl Kalyan Dey
176
Rfn/orl Majul Islam
177
Rfn/orl Ras Mohan Das
178
Rfn/orl Subrata Debnath
179
Rfn/fir S B Karki
180
Hav/gd B L Tamata
181
Nb Sub(elect) S B Sashi
182
Hav/gd Lalit Singh
183
Hav/gd C Nath
184
Hav/gd G Anthony
185
Hav/gd T Prasad
186
Rfn D C Yadav
187
Rfn M Joshi
188
Rfn Sanjeev Kumar
189
Rfn Rajesh Kumar
190
Rfn B B Thapa
191
Rfn T S Kuki
192
Rfn Rajesh Tr
193
Rfn B L Gujar
194
Nb/sub (clk) Shri Radha Krishnan Nair K. M
195
Sub Maj Pashupathi Jaishi
196
Sub/gd Babujan Maiya
197
Nb/sub (gd) Pratap Singh
198
Nb/sub (gd) Madan Singh
199
Mb/sub(clk) Surendra Sharma
200
Hav/skt Rajendra Singh
201
Rfn/gd Mahesh Kumar
202
Sub A K Rai
203
Sub Lt Lusai
204
Nb/sub Kundan Singh
205
Nb/sub K S Rawat
206
Hav Harpal Singh
207
Hav V Ravi
208
L/hav Sanjeev Kumar
209
L/hav P B Biswakarma
210
Sub B K Jha
211
Chm P N Kimni
212
Hav Suraj Tamang
213
Hav S B Singh
214
Hav Rakesh Kumar
215
L/hav Jagdish Singh
216
L/hav J Tamang
217
Rfn Amit Tomar
218
Nb/sub B B Yadav
219
Bhm T B Chhetri
220
Chm Sukhbinder Singh
221
Hav T B Chhetri
222
Hav Dinesh Singh
223
Rfn Ramesh Chand
224
Rfn/gd W K Kanak
225
Rfn/gd R K Akela
226
Rfn/gd B. S. Dhami
227
Rfn/gd T H Koireng Singh
228
Rfn/gd Karanbir
229
Rfn/bb Jagad Barah
230
Rfn/safai Ashok Pal
231
Rfn/tir Satish Kumar
232
Rfn/safai Basumatari
233
Nb/sub(gd) Mangat Ram
234
Hav/gd Birender Sabar
235
Hav Anand Singh Rawat
236
L/hav Sarbjit Singh
237
L/hav D D Barman
238
Rfn/gd Raj Kumar Singh
239
Nb/sub(gd) C B Gharti
240
Hav/gd Debojit Norah
241
Hav/gd Y B Yhapa
242
Hav/gd K C Roy
243
L/hav(gd) Kamal Singh
244
L/hav(gd) G B Gurung
245
L/hav(bb) Salim Ahmed
246
Uhav(gd) Jeewan Gurung
247
L/hav(gd) Biku Raj
248
L/hav Hari Das Kc
249
Hav/gd B K Darjee
250
L/hav S K Chauhan
251
Hav/gd B K Rai
252
Hav/gd S C Rajak
Respondent Advocate
1
Sarla Chandra
Case History with Orders
Unknown
Final Status
Unknown
Final Status
17 Aug 2017
Case Registered
17 Aug 2017
For Judgement
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble L. Nageswara Rao
List In:Judge
Leave Granted / Rule NISI / Appeal Admitted, Other [ALLOWED]
17 Aug 2017
Case Registered
For Judgement
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble L. Nageswara Rao
List In:Judge
Leave Granted / Rule NISI / Appeal Admitted, Other [ALLOWED]
31 Jul 2017
Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble L. Nageswara Rao
List In:Judge
List On (Date) [09-08-2017]
31 Jul 2017
Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble L. Nageswara Rao
List In:Judge
List On (Date) [09-08-2017]
10 Jul 2017
First Hearing
Initial hearing scheduled
10 Jul 2017
Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)
Purpose:Not Reached / Adjourned
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble L. Nageswara Rao
List In:Judge
List On (Date) [31-07-2017]
10 Jul 2017
First Hearing
Initial hearing scheduled
Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)
Purpose:Not Reached / Adjourned
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble L. Nageswara Rao
List In:Judge
List On (Date) [31-07-2017]
Case Filed
27 Apr 2013
Filing No: 13720/2013
27 Apr 2013
Case Filed
27 Apr 2013
Filing No: 13720/2013
Interlocutory Applications (IA) (9)
5243/2014
Filing Date: 2014-01-10
29640/2014
Filing Date: 2014-02-14
29640/2014
Filing Date: 2014-02-14
/2014
Filing Date: 2014-05-02
3/2014
Particular: application for directions in slp 23205/13
Filed by: MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD
Filing Date: 2014-06-02
136431/2014
Filing Date: 2014-11-21
4/2014
Particular: PERMISSION TO FILE ANNEXURES
Filed by: MRS SARLA CHANDRA
Filing Date: 2014-11-25
86242/2015
Filing Date: 2015-10-27
5/2015
Filed by: MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD
Filing Date: 2015-10-28
Earlier Court Details (5)
Court:
High Court
State:
ASSAM
Case No:
WA-33-2012
Order Date:
2012-11-19
Judgment Challenged:
Yes
Judgment Type:
Final
Court:
High Court
State:
ASSAM
Case No:
WA-34-2012
Order Date:
2012-11-19
Judgment Challenged:
Yes
Judgment Type:
Final
Court:
High Court
State:
ASSAM
Case No:
WPC-133-2011
Order Date:
2012-06-29
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
ASSAM
Case No:
WPC-147-2011
Order Date:
2012-06-29
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
ASSAM
Case No:
WPC-147-2011
Order Date:
2012-06-29
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Share This Case
Similar Case Search
Same Parties
Union Of India Ministry Of Home Affairs Secretary vs Rfn/Gd P K ShahiUnion Of India Ministry Of Home Affairs SecretarySecretaryThe Director GeneralThe Brigadier (Pers)Rfn/Gd P K ShahiSarvendra Singh ChauhanSub Maj Faujdar RamSub/Orl Shiv ShankerSub/Orl K N PrasadSub/Orl R P SinghSub/Ciph S K DasSub/Ciph D B BiswasSub/Efs Madhusudan KaNb Sb (Clk) Amrit SinghWo/Rm Kn ThakurWo/Rm Harish KumarHav/Orl Ashok Kr PrasadHav/Orl Shaji SHav/Orl Bhag ChandHav/Orl Anil Kumar AHav/Orl Hr PrasadHav/Orl Sudarsanan NHav/Orl Sudarsen GHav/Orl Ramesh ThakurHav/Orl S K SinghHav/Orl Subhash ChandraHav/Orl Ramanand UpretiHav/Orl Basant BallabhHav/Orl U D BhattHav/Orl S K ShaniHav/Orl Girish SinghHav/Orl Ajay BaliHav/Orl Lalit SinghHav/Orl Rajendra SinghHav/Efs Jyothi GHav/Efs O P RaiRfn/Lmn Kailash ChandraRfn/Orln S RathiRfn/ Orl S Terrsaim LalRfn/Orl P K RoyRfn/Orl Dimple KumarRfn/Orl Binu P PillaiRfn/Orl Jai Pal SinghRfn/Orl Sajeev V GHav/Ciph Vijay Kumar KHav/Ciph Sanjay KumarHav/Ciph Mathew JosephHav/Ciph M P YadavHav/Ciph Trilok SinghHav/Ciph Prakash SinghHav/Ciph R A YadavHav/Gd Madan PalRfn/Gd Jantu DasRfn/Gd S D BarmanRfn/Gd Imtisesen AoRfn/Gd B L BangraRfn/Gd W Ranjit SinghRfn/Satei Ram SewakHev/Gd Md Esad KhanWo/Rm Basu Ranjan DasWo/Rm S P ChoudharyHav/Orl S N RoyHav/Orl Benudhar Baruah 3Hav/Orl Dev Nath PrasadHav/Orl Samer SinghHav/Orl Uttam SinghHav/Orl H S SonowalHav/Orl Kuldeep SinghHav/Orl Vijay NairHav/Orl Thomas M CHav/Orl Mathew JoshphHav/Orl R K YadavHav/Orl Suresh JHav/Orl B SinghHav/Orl Cherian K CHav/Orl Subhash ChanderHav/Orl Ajith Singh LoarHav/Orl Velu Nair RHav/Orl Dayanand YadavHav/Orl D D BhattHav/Orl M S RanaHav/Orl T N TripathiHav/Orl Dharam PalHav/Orl Maohar DasHav/Ciph Suraj ChhetriHav/Ciph B S RawatHav/Ciph Shio Pujan PrasadHav/Ciph Jhantu BarikHav/Ciph Satr Ughan SinghHav/Ciph Kedar Nath SinghHav/Ciph Jiten Kumar SinghaHav/Ciph Bir Bahadur SinghHav/Ciph B S NegiHav/Ciph H S MishraHav/Efs P G ShajiRfn/Orl Krishna KumarRfn/Orl Ombir SinghRfn/Orl Suresh KumarRfn/Orl Santosh RawatRfn/Orl Prabhansh YadavRfn/Orl Ishwar SinghRfn/Orl Veerpal SinghRfn/Orl Mohan SinghRfn/Orl Surjeet LamaRfn/Orl Sunil Kumar GRfn/Orl Narayan RayRfn/Orl M K RawatRfn/Orl Laxman SinghRfn/Orl U K ThakurRfn/Orl P S NegiRfn/Orl L LunkimRfn/Orl S S BhartiRfn/Orl Inder KumarRfn/Orl Sunil SemwalRfn/Orl Zameer AhmedRfn/Orl D S RathoreRfn/Orl Raghuvir SinghRfn/Orl SachidanandRfn/Orl Jagmohan SinghRfn/Orl M S RawatRfn/Orl BirenderRfn/Orl Kalyan RamRfn/Orl S S RawatRfn/Orl H S RawatRfn/Orl OmbeerRfn/Orl Ramesh ChandRfn/Orl Sudir SinghRfn/Orl Devendra SinghRfn/Orl Birendra PrasadRfn/Orl Md. RafiqueRfn/Orl S K SinghRfn/Orl Ekbal MahendiRfn/Orl Yaspal SnghRfn/Orl O B SinghaRfn/Orl Dipak SaikiaRfn/Orl Lakhya GogoiRfn/Orl Shashi BhushanRfn/Orl Rajesh KumarRfn/Orl Man SinghRfn/Orl Surjeet SinghRfnorl Lal SinghRfn/Orl Ksh Sanamacha SinghRfn/Orl Arjun SinghRfn/Orl Harish BishtRfn/Orl B KharkhongerRfn/Orl Satyendra PrasadRfn/Orl D B GurungRfn/Orl M KhonglamRfn/Oir B C RabhaRfn/Orl Sunil Raj RRfn/Orl Biju BabuRfn/Orl A K SinghRfn/Orl R R RaviRfn/Orl Bijay KumarRfn/Orl Riyaz KhanRfn/Orl Bijay Kumar OjhaRfn/Orl Tarsem LalRfn/Orl Raghudev SinghRfn/Orl Satpal SharmaRfn/Orl Suresh RaiRfn/Orl Rajesh Kumar YadavRfn/Orl Dharmender KumarRfn/Orl Tulshi ChhetriRfn/Orl K W H HossainRfn/Orl Syed Ali AkmalRfn/Orl Sashi Kant MishraRfn/Orl Sunil SinghRfn/Orl Abul KalamRfn/Orl Rajesh BasnetRfn/Orl Jitu DeuriRfn/Orl Ram Singh SarmantRfn/Orl Ashsish Mohan SharmaRfn/Orl S S ChouhanRfn/Orl V J ReddyRfn/Orl P K BarikRfn/Orl J R PradhanRfn/Orl Hrusikesh PalaiRfn/Orl Japan Kumar Deb BarmanRfn/Orl Kalyan DeyRfn/Orl Majul IslamRfn/Orl Ras Mohan DasRfn/Orl Subrata DebnathRfn/Fir S B KarkiHav/Gd B L TamataNb Sub(Elect) S B SashiHav/Gd Lalit SinghHav/Gd C NathHav/Gd G AnthonyHav/Gd T PrasadRfn D C YadavRfn M JoshiRfn Sanjeev KumarRfn Rajesh KumarRfn B B ThapaRfn T S KukiRfn Rajesh TrRfn B L GujarNb/Sub (Clk) Shri Radha Krishnan Nair K. MSub Maj Pashupathi JaishiSub/Gd Babujan MaiyaNb/Sub (Gd) Pratap SinghNb/Sub (Gd) Madan SinghMb/Sub(Clk) Surendra SharmaHav/Skt Rajendra SinghRfn/Gd Mahesh KumarSub A K RaiSub Lt LusaiNb/Sub Kundan SinghNb/Sub K S RawatHav Harpal SinghHav V RaviL/Hav Sanjeev KumarL/Hav P B BiswakarmaSub B K JhaChm P N KimniHav Suraj TamangHav S B SinghHav Rakesh KumarL/Hav Jagdish SinghL/Hav J TamangRfn Amit TomarNb/Sub B B YadavBhm T B ChhetriChm Sukhbinder SinghHav T B ChhetriHav Dinesh SinghRfn Ramesh ChandRfn/Gd W K KanakRfn/Gd R K AkelaRfn/Gd B. S. DhamiRfn/Gd T H Koireng SinghRfn/Gd KaranbirRfn/Bb Jagad BarahRfn/Safai Ashok PalRfn/Tir Satish KumarRfn/Safai BasumatariNb/Sub(Gd) Mangat RamHav/Gd Birender SabarHav Anand Singh RawatL/Hav Sarbjit SinghL/Hav D D BarmanRfn/Gd Raj Kumar SinghNb/Sub(Gd) C B GhartiHav/Gd Debojit NorahHav/Gd Y B YhapaHav/Gd K C RoyL/Hav(Gd) Kamal SinghL/Hav(Gd) G B GurungL/Hav(Bb) Salim AhmedUhav(Gd) Jeewan GurungL/Hav(Gd) Biku RajL/Hav Hari Das KcHav/Gd B K DarjeeL/Hav S K ChauhanHav/Gd B K RaiHav/Gd S C Rajak
Case Content Last Updated21 Oct 2025, 4:29 am IST