eCourtsIndiaBeta

Commissioner Of Value Added Tax Commissioner vs. Prime Papers And Packers Proprietor Shri Rahul Arora

Court:Supreme Court of India
Judges:Hon'ble Rohinton Fali Nariman, Hon'ble Indu Malhotra
Case Type:Civil Appeal
Reg no:241/2018
Filing no:33634/2016
CNR:SCIN010336342016

Parties & Advocates

Petitioners

1
Commissioner Of Value Added Tax Commissioner
2
Assistant Commissioner Of Vat Assistant Commissioner

Petitioner Advocate

1
Gurmeet Singh Makker

Respondent

1
Prime Papers And Packers Proprietor Shri Rahul Arora

Respondent Advocate

1
Avinash Kr. Lakhanpal

Case History with Orders

Pending

Final Status

9 Jan 2023

Order(56) - 9 Jan 2023

ROP

16 Apr 2019

Order(55) - 16 Apr 2019

ROP

31 Jul 2018

Order(54) - 31 Jul 2018

ROP - of Main Case

Disposal/final Disposal At Admission Stage - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Rohinton Fali Nariman, Hon'ble Indu Malhotra
List In:Judge

Adjourned for [D:0,W:2,M:0]

26 Jul 2018

Disposal/final Disposal At Admission Stage - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Rohinton Fali Nariman, Hon'ble Indu Malhotra
List In:Judge

Not taken up/ Not Today

19 Jul 2018

Disposal/final Disposal At Admission Stage - Civil Cases

Purpose:Not Reached / Adjourned
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Rohinton Fali Nariman, Hon'ble Indu Malhotra
List In:Judge

Not taken up/ Not Today

18 Jul 2018

Disposal/final Disposal At Admission Stage - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Rohinton Fali Nariman, Hon'ble Indu Malhotra
List In:Judge

Not taken up/ Not Today [to retain its position]

13 Jul 2018

Order(53) - 13 Jul 2018

ROP

23 Apr 2018

Order(52) - 23 Apr 2018

ROP

2 Apr 2018

Order(51) - 2 Apr 2018

ROP

5 Mar 2018

Order(50) - 5 Mar 2018

ROP

25 Jan 2018

Order(49) - 25 Jan 2018

ROP

9 Jan 2018

Order(48) - 9 Jan 2018

ROP - of Main Case

Case Registered

Registration No: 241/2018

First Hearing

Initial hearing scheduled

Disposal/final Disposal At Admission Stage - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Rohinton Fali Nariman, Hon'ble Navin Sinha
List In:Judge

Leave Granted / Rule NISI / Appeal Admitted, List On (Date) [18-07-2018]

8 Jan 2018

Order(47) - 8 Jan 2018

ROP

1 Dec 2017

Order(46) - 1 Dec 2017

ROP - of Main Case

15 Nov 2017

Order(45) - 15 Nov 2017

ROP

15 Sept 2017

Order(44) - 15 Sept 2017

ROP

4 Sept 2017

Order(43) - 4 Sept 2017

ROP

28 Aug 2017

Order(42) - 28 Aug 2017

ROP

25 Aug 2017

Order(41) - 25 Aug 2017

ROP

21 Aug 2017

Order(40) - 21 Aug 2017

ROP

Order(39) - 21 Aug 2017

ROP

28 Jul 2017

Order(38) - 28 Jul 2017

ROP

Order(37) - 28 Jul 2017

ROP

Order(36) - 28 Jul 2017

ROP

17 Jul 2017

Order(35) - 17 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

4 May 2017

Order(34) - 4 May 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Order(33) - 4 May 2017

Office Report

Order(32) - 4 May 2017

Office Report - of Main Case

Order(31) - 4 May 2017

ROP - of Main Case

24 Apr 2017

Order(30) - 24 Apr 2017

ROP

Order(29) - 24 Apr 2017

ROP

7 Apr 2017

Order(28) - 7 Apr 2017

ROP

Order(27) - 7 Apr 2017

Office Report

Order(26) - 7 Apr 2017

ROP

20 Feb 2017

Order(25) - 20 Feb 2017

ROP

Order(24) - 20 Feb 2017

ROP

Order(23) - 20 Feb 2017

ROP

Order(22) - 20 Feb 2017

Office Report

Order(21) - 20 Feb 2017

ROP

Order(20) - 20 Feb 2017

ROP

Order(19) - 20 Feb 2017

ROP

1 Feb 2017

Order(18) - 1 Feb 2017

ROP

Order(17) - 1 Feb 2017

Office Report

Order(16) - 1 Feb 2017

ROP

31 Jan 2017

Order(15) - 31 Jan 2017

ROP

Order(14) - 31 Jan 2017

ROP

18 Nov 2016

Order(13) - 18 Nov 2016

ROP

Order(12) - 18 Nov 2016

Office Report

Order(11) - 18 Nov 2016

ROP

8 Nov 2016

Order(10) - 8 Nov 2016

ROP - of Main Case

Order(9) - 8 Nov 2016

ROP - of Main Case

26 Oct 2016

Order(8) - 26 Oct 2016

ROP

Order(7) - 26 Oct 2016

Office Report

Order(6) - 26 Oct 2016

ROP

18 Oct 2016

Order(5) - 18 Oct 2016

ROP - of Main Case

Order(4) - 18 Oct 2016

Office Report - of Main Case

Order(3) - 18 Oct 2016

ROP - of Main Case

3 Oct 2016

Case Filed

3 Oct 2016 Filing No: 33634/2016

26 Aug 2016

Order(2) - 26 Aug 2016

ROP - of Main Case

Order(1) - 26 Aug 2016

ROP - of Main Case

Interlocutory Applications (IA) (5)

1/2016
Particular: EXEMPTION FROM FILING C/C OF THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT
Filed by: MR. D. S. MAHRA
Filing Date: 2016-11-10
24483/2017
Particular: I A FOR DE TAG
Filing Date: 2017-03-22
2/2017
Particular: DELINKING THE PETITION
Filed by: MR. D. S. MAHRA
Filing Date: 2017-03-23
26230/2017
Particular: IA FOR EXPARTE STAY
Filing Date: 2017-03-28
3/2017
Particular: EX-PARTE STAY
Filed by: MR. D. S. MAHRA
Filing Date: 2017-03-30

Tagged Matters (19)

24183/2016(03-08-2016 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000235 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 022867 / 2016 Registered on 03-08-2016 - CA

Petitioner: GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI
Respondent: DISH TV INDIA LIMITED
Type: M•Status: P•Entry: 25-05-2018

33637/2016(17-10-2016 02:17 PM)C.A. No. 000236 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 030525 / 2016 Registered on 17-10-2016 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX
Respondent: PRIME PAPERS AND PACKERS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

33638/2016(22-10-2016 10:13 AM)C.A. No. 000237 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 031084 / 2016 Registered on 22-10-2016 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX
Respondent: PRIME PAPERS AND PACKERS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

33639/2016(07-11-2016 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000238 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 032548 / 2016 Registered on 07-11-2016 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX
Respondent: PRIME PAPERS AND PACKERS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

33635/2016(08-11-2016 10:31 AM)C.A. No. 000239 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 032663 / 2016 Registered on 08-11-2016 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX
Respondent: PRIME PAPERS AND PACKERS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

33636/2016(10-11-2016 11:09 AM)C.A. No. 000240 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 033118 / 2016 Registered on 10-11-2016 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX
Respondent: PRIME PAPERS AND PACKERS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

33634/2016(10-11-2016 03:39 PM)C.A. No. 000241 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 033217 / 2016 Registered on 10-11-2016 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX
Respondent: PRIME PAPERS AND PACKERS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

3273/2017(31-01-2017 11:03 AM)C.A. No. 000242 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 003496 / 2017 Registered on 31-01-2017 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER TRADE AND TAXES
Respondent: VIZIEN ORGANICS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

4522/2017(14-02-2017 03:57 PM)C.A. No. 000243 - 000351 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 005636 - 005744 / 2017 Registered on 14-02-2017 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF DELHI VALUE ADDED TAX DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND TAXES
Respondent: M/S MUNSHI RAM RAM PRAKASH
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

17869/2017(10-07-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000352 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 017480 - / 2017 Registered on 10-07-2017 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX
Respondent: SHAILA ENTERPRISES
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

18681/2017(17-07-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 009900 / 2017 Registered on 28-07-2017SLP(C) No. 017687 - / 2017 Registered on 17-07-2017 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX
Respondent: M/S I SMART MOBILE TECHNOLOGY PVT. LTD
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

18506/2017(20-07-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000353 / 2018 Registered on 09-01-2018SLP(C) No. 018470 - / 2017 Registered on 20-07-2017 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF TRADE AND TAXES
Respondent: M/S M.S. ELECTRICALS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

18291/2017(21-07-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 004014 / 2019 Registered on 20-04-2019SLP(C) No. 018603 - / 2017 Registered on 21-07-2017 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF TRADE AND TAXES
Respondent: M/S ASIAN POLYMERS
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

22580/2017(09-08-2017 12:00 AM)SLP(C) No. 020129 - / 2017 Registered on 09-08-2017 - SLP_C

Petitioner: COMISSIONER OF DELHI VALUE ADDED TAX DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND TAXES
Respondent: M/S. S K ENGG. WORKS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

22583/2017(23-08-2017 02:32 PM)C.A. No. 000354 / 2018 Registered on 12-01-2018SLP(C) No. 021942 - / 2017 Registered on 23-08-2017 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF TRADE AND TAXES DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND TAXES
Respondent: M/S INDUSTRIAL DISTRIBUTORS
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

41012/2017(25-01-2018 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 001489 - 001490 / 2018 Registered on 25-01-2018SLP(C) No. 003612 - 003613 / 2018 Registered on 25-01-2018 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF TRADE AND TAXES
Respondent: M/S VANSH ELECTROMECHANICAL DEVICES (P) LTD.
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

9718/2018(24-03-2018 12:00 AM)SLP(C) No. 007796 - / 2018 Registered on 24-03-2018 - SLP_C

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF TRADE AND TAXES
Respondent: M/S VANSH ELECTROMECHANICAL DEVICES (P) LTD
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

21055/2018(13-07-2018 12:00 AM)SLP(C) No. 018320 - 018321 / 2018 Registered on 13-07-2018 - SLP_C

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF TRADE AND TAXES
Respondent: SHIV SHAKTI METALS PVT. LTD.
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

39200/2022(12-01-2023 04:50 PM)C.A. No. 000299 - 000302 / 2023 Registered on 12-01-2023SLP(C) No. 001200 - 001203 / 2023 Registered on 12-01-2023 - CA

Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF DELHI GOODS AND SERVICES TAX
Respondent: SHREE KRIPA AGRO
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 29-04-2025

Earlier Court Details (21)

Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-5944-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
Yes
Judgment Type:
Final
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
CM-24776-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
CM-24777-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
CM-24778-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
CM-24783-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
CM-24784-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
CM-24785-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
CM-24786-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
CM-24787-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6013-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6014-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6015-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6016-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6017-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6018-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6019-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6020-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6021-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6022-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6023-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
DELHI
Case No:
WPC-6024-2016
Order Date:
2016-07-28
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-

Notices (4)

S.No. 1
76313/2022-06-03
Notice Type: Letter to advocate for defects
Name:Commissioner Of Value Added Tax Commissionerthrough B. V. Balaram Das-1201
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:6 Mar 2022
Return Date:18 Jul 2022
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 2
22926/2018-02-06
Notice Type: NLPA (Letter)
Name:B. V. Balaram Das-1201copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:2 Jun 2018
Return Date:18 Jul 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 3
22926/2018-02-06
Notice Type: NLPA (Letter)
Name:Commissioner Of Value Added Tax Commissionerthrough High Court Of Delhi At New Delhi Delhi
Location:DELHI
Issue Date:2 Jun 2018
Return Date:18 Jul 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 4
22926/2018-02-06
Notice Type: NLPA (Letter)
Name:Avinash Kr. Lakhanpal-1883copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:2 Jun 2018
Return Date:18 Jul 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending

Share This Case

Similar Case Search
Case Content Last Updated22 Aug 2025, 9:17 am IST