eCourtsIndiaBeta

Secondary Teachers And Employees Association (Stea) vs. The State Of West Bengal

Court:Supreme Court of India
Judge:Hon'ble Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Sudhanshu Dhulia
Case Status:Disposed
Order Date:6 Sept 2023
CNR:SCIN010330892023

AI Summary

Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order

Order Issued After Hearing

Purpose:

First Hearing

Listed On:

6 Sept 2023

Original Order Copy

Get a certified copy of this order

Download True Copy

Order Text

ITEM NO.27 COURT NO.2 SECTION XVI

S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

Petitions for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s). 18894-18918/2023

(Arising out of impugned final judgment and order dated 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 13085/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 12016/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11337/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11751/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11981/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11195/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11642/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11202/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11714/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11638/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11586/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 10887/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11293/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 12193/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11212/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11527/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 10505/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11215/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11189/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11522/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 10396/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11183/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11221/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 10810/2023 27-07-2023 in WPA No. 11383/2023 passed by the High Court At Calcutta)

SECONDARY TEACHERS AND EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION (STEA) & ANR. ETC. Petitioner(s)

VERSUS

THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS. ETC. Respondent(s)

( IA No.172346/2023-EXEMPTION FROM FILING C/C OF THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT, IA NO. 176479/2023-APPROPRIATE ORDERS/DIRECTIONS, IA NO. 178254/2023-IMPLEADMENT)

Date : 06-09-2023 These petitions were called on for hearing today.

CORAM :

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KISHAN KAUL HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHANSHU DHULIA

For Petitioner(s)Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Pratik Dhar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Sarad Kumar Singhania, AOR
Mr. Kartik Kumar Ray, Adv.
Mr. Gouranga Debnath, Adv.
Ms. Rashmi Singhania, Adv.
Mr. Yash Singhania, Adv.

For Respondent(s)

UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following O R D E R

Application for exemption from filing C/C of the impugned judgment is allowed.

Learned senior counsel for the petitioners contends that Section 10C of the West Bengal School Service Commission Act, 1997 was introduced on 17.04.2017 and in terms of the impugned judgment , it is sought to be made retrospectively applicable to the existing teachers as exigency of Administration. It is his submission that these terms and conditions of service cannot be changed prejudicially.

We put to the learned senior counsel that on account of paucity of students, it may require shifting of teachers in neighboring schools in the same District considering the student-teacher ratio but learned senior counsel submits that there is no such Scheme and they can be shifted to any other School within the State.

Issue notice on the special leave petitions and on the prayer for interim relief to respondent Nos. 1 to 4 only, at the request of the learned senior counsel, returnable on 09.10.2023.

[CHARANJEET KAUR][POONAM VAID]
ASTT. REGISTRAR-cum-PSCOURT MASTER (NSH)

2

Share This Order

Case History of Orders

Order(8) - 26 Sept 2024

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(7) - 22 Aug 2024

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(6) - 3 Apr 2024

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(5) - 23 Jan 2024

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(4) - 5 Dec 2023

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(3) - 9 Oct 2023

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(2) - 3 Oct 2023

ROP

Click to view

Order(1) - 6 Sept 2023

ROP - of Main Case

Viewing
Similar Case Search

Same Parties

Secondary Teachers And Employees Association (Stea) vs The State Of West BengalSecondary Teachers And Employees Association (Stea)Nilkanta GhoseSahana Neogi, (Saha)Shampa RayMaumita DasArpita PathakSudeshna Lahiri ChakrabortiMahendra BiswasArpita DuttaPranita SardarMalabi SarkarDola Guha KhasnabisAparajita BanerjeeAnusua SahooKrishna RoyMousumi DasDebojyoti ChoudhuryAditi PurohitPriyanka JanaDurba BandyopadhyaySupratim PramanikKabita MurmuSreyasi RoyMoumita MitraPrainamita NathSounak MukherjeeThe State Of West BengalThe Commissioner Of School EducationWest Bengal Board Of Secondary EducationWest Bengal Central School Service Commission (Western Region)The ChairpersonThe DirectorThe SecretaryThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), KolkataThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), South 24 ParganasThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), North 24 ParganasThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), BarrackpurThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), HowrahThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), HooghlyThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), NadiaThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), MurshidabadThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Purba BurdwanThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Paschim BardhamanThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), BankuraThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), BirbhumThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Paschim MedinipurThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Purba MedinipurThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), JhargramThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), PuruliaThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), MaldaThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Dakshin DinajpurThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Uttar DinajpurThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), DarjeelingThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), KalimpongThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), SiliguriThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), JalpaiguriThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. )The District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Alipurduar. The Principal SecretaryThe Commissioner Of EducationThe District Inspector Of SchoolsThe West Bengal Central SchoolThe West Bengal Board Of Secondary EducationThe PresidentHaltu Arya Balika Vidyalaya (Hs) KolkataThe HeadmistressThe ChairmanThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E)The Head Of The InstitutionThe Managing CommitteePurandarpur Hhd High School (H. S. ) Of PurandarpurMaharaja Cossinbazar PolytechThe Secretary West Bengal Central SchoolDesh Bandhu Sishu Sikhalaya (Hs)Nari Siksha Mandir (Hs)Paschim Putiary Sukharanjan Vidyamandir (Hs)The HeadmasterJoint SecretaryManaging Committee Of Bally Banga Sishu Balika Vidyalay (Hs)The Head MasterManaging Committee Of DongariaKuernuri Hirarnba Gopalpur S. M. Vidyapith HighNayachak High SchoolThe Head Of The Institution, Smt. Jahar Nandi Viyapith Girls H. S. SchoolThe Managing Committee, Smt. Jahar Nandi Viyapith Girls H. S. School8. Ramchandranagarsrihari, Smriti High School (H. S. )The Head Of The Institution, Mukul Bose Memorial InstitutionThe Managing Committee, Mukul Bose Memorial InstitutionRajnagar Srinathgrarn Basil Vidyapith (H. S . )Ram Mohan Vidyamandir For Girls (H. S. )The Headmistress Ram Mohan Vidyamandir For Girls (H. S. )Kalighat Mahakali Pathsala (Hs)The Headmaster, Kalighat Mahakali Pathsala (Hs)The Headmistress, Nari Siksha Mandir (Hs)The Head Of The Institution, Rani Bhabani SchoolThe Managing Committee, Rani Bhabani SchoolKaikhaligopalganjThe West Bengal Regional School Service CommissionThe West Bengal Board Of Secondary Education, Service Through The PresidentThe Secretary Of The Managing Committee / Administrator/ Headmaster Of Metropolitan Institution (Bowbazar Branch)The Secretary Of The Managing Committee Administrator/ Headmaster Of Krishnanagar High SchoolDakshineswar Sri Sri Saroda Devi Balika Vidyalaya (Hs)The Headmaster, Dakshineswar Sri Sri Saroda Devi Balika Vidyalaya (Hs)The Head Of The Institution, Titagarh High SchoolThe Managing Committee, Titagarh High SchoolSatyacharan Pal Balika VidyalayaBidyadharpur High School For Girls (Hs)The Teacher-In-ChargeM. P. Gurguria Adarsha Vidyapith (H. S. )

Search in District Courts Data

Secondary Teachers And Employees Association (Stea)Nilkanta GhoseSahana Neogi, (Saha)Shampa RayMaumita DasArpita PathakSudeshna Lahiri ChakrabortiMahendra BiswasArpita DuttaPranita SardarMalabi SarkarDola Guha KhasnabisAparajita BanerjeeAnusua SahooKrishna RoyMousumi DasDebojyoti ChoudhuryAditi PurohitPriyanka JanaDurba BandyopadhyaySupratim PramanikKabita MurmuSreyasi RoyMoumita MitraPrainamita NathSounak MukherjeeThe State Of West BengalThe Commissioner Of School EducationWest Bengal Board Of Secondary EducationWest Bengal Central School Service Commission (Western Region)The ChairpersonThe DirectorThe SecretaryThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), KolkataThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), South 24 ParganasThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), North 24 ParganasThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), BarrackpurThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), HowrahThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), HooghlyThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), NadiaThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), MurshidabadThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Purba BurdwanThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Paschim BardhamanThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), BankuraThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), BirbhumThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Paschim MedinipurThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Purba MedinipurThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), JhargramThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), PuruliaThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), MaldaThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Dakshin DinajpurThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Uttar DinajpurThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), DarjeelingThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), KalimpongThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), SiliguriThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), JalpaiguriThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. )The District Inspector Of Schools (S. E. ), Alipurduar. The Principal SecretaryThe Commissioner Of EducationThe District Inspector Of SchoolsThe West Bengal Central SchoolThe West Bengal Board Of Secondary EducationThe PresidentHaltu Arya Balika Vidyalaya (Hs) KolkataThe HeadmistressThe ChairmanThe District Inspector Of Schools (S. E)The Head Of The InstitutionThe Managing CommitteePurandarpur Hhd High School (H. S. ) Of PurandarpurMaharaja Cossinbazar PolytechThe Secretary West Bengal Central SchoolDesh Bandhu Sishu Sikhalaya (Hs)Nari Siksha Mandir (Hs)Paschim Putiary Sukharanjan Vidyamandir (Hs)The HeadmasterJoint SecretaryManaging Committee Of Bally Banga Sishu Balika Vidyalay (Hs)The Head MasterManaging Committee Of DongariaKuernuri Hirarnba Gopalpur S. M. Vidyapith HighNayachak High SchoolThe Head Of The Institution, Smt. Jahar Nandi Viyapith Girls H. S. SchoolThe Managing Committee, Smt. Jahar Nandi Viyapith Girls H. S. School8. Ramchandranagarsrihari, Smriti High School (H. S. )The Head Of The Institution, Mukul Bose Memorial InstitutionThe Managing Committee, Mukul Bose Memorial InstitutionRajnagar Srinathgrarn Basil Vidyapith (H. S . )Ram Mohan Vidyamandir For Girls (H. S. )The Headmistress Ram Mohan Vidyamandir For Girls (H. S. )Kalighat Mahakali Pathsala (Hs)The Headmaster, Kalighat Mahakali Pathsala (Hs)The Headmistress, Nari Siksha Mandir (Hs)The Head Of The Institution, Rani Bhabani SchoolThe Managing Committee, Rani Bhabani SchoolKaikhaligopalganjThe West Bengal Regional School Service CommissionThe West Bengal Board Of Secondary Education, Service Through The PresidentThe Secretary Of The Managing Committee / Administrator/ Headmaster Of Metropolitan Institution (Bowbazar Branch)The Secretary Of The Managing Committee Administrator/ Headmaster Of Krishnanagar High SchoolDakshineswar Sri Sri Saroda Devi Balika Vidyalaya (Hs)The Headmaster, Dakshineswar Sri Sri Saroda Devi Balika Vidyalaya (Hs)The Head Of The Institution, Titagarh High SchoolThe Managing Committee, Titagarh High SchoolSatyacharan Pal Balika VidyalayaBidyadharpur High School For Girls (Hs)The Teacher-In-ChargeM. P. Gurguria Adarsha Vidyapith (H. S. )Advocate Sarad Kumar SinghaniaAdvocate Kunal ChatterjiAdvocate Shyam D. NandanAdvocate Hima Lawrence