Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd. Through Chairman Managing Director vs. Cellular Operators Assoc. Of India Through Its Secreatary

'#IT EM NO.2 0 Cou r t No.6 S E C T I O N XVII S U P R E ME C O U R T O F IN D IA RE C O R D OF PROC E E D I N G S CI VI L A P P E A L NO( s ) . 34 7 2 OF 20 0 9 (for prel. heari n g ) CEL L U L A R OP E R A T O R S A S S N . O F INDI A & OR S. Appell a n t (s) VER SU S UNIO N OF INDI A & OR S. Respo n d e n t ( s ) (Wit h appl n ( s ) for ex-Par t e stay,pe r m i s s i o n to file additio n a l docu m e n t s , P E R M I S S I O N TO FIL E SY N O P S I S WITH Civil Appeal NO. 34 7 7 of 20 0 9 (fo r prel. heari n g ) (Wit h appl n. for ex-par te stay a d office repo r t ) Date: 06/07/2 0 0 9 This Appeal wa s called on for heari n g toda y. COR AM : HON'B L E MR. J U S T I C E AL T A M A S K A B I R HON'B L E MR. J U S T I C E CY RI A C JO S E P H Fo r Appell a n t ( s ) Dr. Abhi s h e k Manu Sing h v i , Sr. A d v . Mr. C.S. Vaid y a n a t h a n , Sr. A d v . Mr. Manjul Bajp ai, Adv. Mr. Gopal J ai n, Ad v. Mr. As h i s h Yad a v, Ad v. Mr. A mi t Bhan d a r i, Ad v. Mr. Na vi n Cha w l a , A d v . Fo r BS N L Mr. Gopal Sub r a m a n i u m , SG Mr. Maninder Sing h, Sr. A d v . Mr. Yogin d e r Hardeo, Ad v. Mr. Gau r a v Sh a r m a , Ad v. Ms. Su r b h i Mehta, Adv. Mrs.P r a t i b h a Sing h, Adv. Mr. Abhi n a v Muk h e r j i, A d v . Fo r Respo n d e n t ( s ) Mr. Ra mj i Sri ni v a s a n , S r . A d v . Ms. Ruby Singh Ah u j a, A d v . Ms. Si m r a n Bra r, A d v . Mr. Raini Kar a n j a w a l a , A d v . Ms. Mani k Kar a n j a w a l a , A d v . for M/S. Kar a n j a w a l a & Co. Mr. Muk ul Roh t agi, S r . A d v . Mr. E.C. Agr a w a l a ,Ad v Mr.Mahes h Agar w a l , A d v . Mr. Ris hi Agr a w a l a , A d v . Mr. Gau r a v i Goel, A d v. Mr. A mi t Ku m a r Sh a r m a , A d v . Mr. A k s h y a Ringe, A d v . ..2/-

Fo r R.No.1 UOI Mr. Goola m E. Va h a n w a t i , AG Mr. Vi k a s Sing h, Sr. A d v . Mr. San j a y R. Hegde, Adv. Mr. A. Roha n Singh , Ad v. UPO N heari n g couns el the Cour t made the follo w i n g O R D E R

:2:

Civil Appeal No. 34 7 2/ 0 9 prefer r e d by Cellul a r Oper a t o r s As soci a ti o n of India and Ors. and Civil Appeal No. 34 7 7/ 0 9 filed by Bhar a t Sanc h a r Niga m Ltd. are ad mi t t e d. In Civil Appeal No. 34 7 7/ 0 9, an inter i m order has alread y been pas sed on 14 th May, 20 0 9. As far as Civil Appeal No. 34 7 2/ 0 9 is concer n e d, notice o n the applica ti o n for interi m order is wai v e d by the lear n ed coun s el appea r i n g for the par ti es. Let notice of lodge me n t of appeal s be ser ved on all the respo n d e n t s , excep t for the respo n d e n t s who are appea r i n g thro u g h lear n ed couns el. Ser vi ce by das ti as well. As far as they are concer n e d, ser vice of notice shall be deemed to be w ai v e d. The par tie s will be entitled to file additio n a l docu m e n t s if they so desire, wi t h i n fou r wee k s fro m date. The par tie s will be at liber t y to men tio n the appeal s for fixing a date of heari n g.

(G an g a Tha k u r ) ( J u g i n d e r Kau r ) P.S. to Regis t r a r Cour t Master