eCourtsIndia

Col. Pradeep Mathur vs. Union Of India

Court:Supreme Court of India
Judges:Hon'ble Abhay S. Oka, Hon'ble Ahsanuddin Amanullah, Hon'ble Augustine George Masih
Case Type:Writ Petition (Civil)
Act & Section:1605-Direct Taxation : Matters Challenging Validity Of The Direct Tax Statutes, Circulars, Orders, Notifications, Rules
Reg no:953/2019
Filing no:25862/2019
CNR:SCIN010258622019

Parties & Advocates

Petitioners

1
Col. Pradeep Mathur
2
Ic-46410p Lt Col Sada S Peter (retd. )
3
Ic-51016n Lt Col Shailesh Kumar Rai (retd. )
4
Ic- 46091n Lt Col Gian Prakash Yadav (retd. )
5
Ic-41749y Col Girish Hiralal Bhavsar (retd. )
6
Ic-49755f Lt Col M Anand (retd. )
7
Ic-55485n Lt Col Sanjay Joshi (retd. )
8
Sl-03661l Col Ranvir Singh Malik (retd. )
9
Ic-44113h Col Kabir Chaudhary (retd. )
10
No. 02227k Cdr Rajesh Shrimal (retd. )
11
Ic-40148f Col Tv Arun Kumar (retd. )
12
Ic-41737k Col Rajan Talwar (retd. )
13
Ic-31485p Col Yudhisthira Singh Gahlaut (retd. )
14
Ic-46373m Lt Col Ms Shankar (retd. )
15
No. 51100k Cdr K Chandrasekar (retd. )
16
Ic-45405x Col Vimal Mallick (retd. )
17
Ic-48225a Col Raj Kumar Singh (retd. )
18
Ic-40848p Col Aps Johal (retd. )
19
Ic-41446k Col Ram Kumar Dubey (retd. )
20
No-02228n Cdr Parag Saxena (retd. )
21
Ic-45204y Col Sanjay Bawa (retd. )
22
Ic-56811x Lt Col Chandrashekar Prabath Shankar (retd. )
23
Ic-39932h Col Vishnu Kumar Mishra (retd. )
24
Ic-47942f Col Krishna Prasad Ng (retd. )
25
Ic-33251k Lt Col Ravi Kant Talwar (retd. )-33251k Lt Col Ravi Kant Talwar (retd. )
26
Ic-54227f Lt Col Sarang Prakash Pande (retd. )
27
Ic-30281w Maj Gen Srinivasan Arun (retd. )
28
Ic-31293x Col Basudev Banerjee (retd. )
29
Ic-42530w Col Munindra Kishore Sharma (retd. )
30
Ic-35442x Lt Col L D Shiggaon (retd. )
31
No-23589b Wg Cdr Satish Kumar (retd. )
32
Ic-33390n Lt Col Kv Chandrasekharan (retd. )
33
Ic-33041k Lt Col Joginder Singh Ahlawat (retd. )
34
Ic-36609h Col Dilip Dinanath Kulkarni (retd. )
35
No. 18147t Gp Capt Anshlesh Saxena (retd. )
36
Ic-44184k Col H Shankar (retd. )
37
No. 23610t Wg Cdr Joy Jacob N (retd. )
38
No. 23926h Wg Cdr George Horace Jones (retd. )
39
Ic-35447w Col Harish Chandra Pandey (retd. )
40
Ic-40183k Col Rs Panwar (retd. )
41
No. 23583a Wg Cdr B Gopikrishan (retd. )
42
Ic-34273p Brig Pratap Narayan Awasthi (retd. )
43
Ic-29389f Maj. Gurbachan Singh (retd. )
44
Ic-25546l Col Arun Dattaji Patole (retd. )
45
Ic-23417m Lt Col Vijaysingh Jaisingh Jadhav (retd. )
46
Ic-37196w Col Anil D Palande (retd. )
47
No. 41011f Cdr Jacob Isaac (retd. )
48
Ic-25588x Col Suresh Ramtri (retd. )
49
Ic-25455f Col Moti Chandra Pradhan (retd. )
50
Ic-39706l Lt Col Om Prakash Tripathi (retd. )
51
Ic40. Ic-36610x Col Dilip Prabhakarrao Sudame (retd. )
52
Ic-40117f Col Arunjeet Singh (retd. )
53
Ic-40345k Col Laxmi Narayan (retd. )
54
Ic-35437l Col Shree Krishan Singhal (retd. )
55
Ic-39285n Col Surendra Singh Shekhawat (retd. )
56
Jc-569582y Sub Maj (hony Lt) Santbir Singh (retd)
57
Jc-570535h-sub Ram Ratan Yadav (retd. )
58
Jc-439252w Sub M Yogalingam (retd. )
59
No751119a Sgt Rajavardha Reddy (retd. )
60
Jc-110700w Sub (hony Capt) Udai Bir Singh (retd. )
61
Jc-640028a Sub (hony Sm) Ashok Kumar (retd. )
62
No. 058350r Mcpo-1 (hony Sub Lt) Lakshman Ram
63
No 770739n Sgt Chandrashekar Rao S (retd. )
64
No 15356969l Hav Surendra Kumar (retd. )

Petitioner Advocate

1
Sarvesh Singh

Respondents

1
Union Of India
2
Chairperson Central Board Of Direct Taxes
3
Chief Of The Army Staff
4
Chief Of The Air Staff
5
Chief Of The Naval Staff

Respondent Advocates

1
Raj Bahadur Yadav
2
N. Visakamurthy

Case History with Orders

Unknown

Final Status

22 Aug 2024

Order(16) - 22 Aug 2024

ROP - of Main Case

Direct Taxes Matter : Cbdt Circular

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Abhay S. Oka, Hon'ble Ahsanuddin Amanullah, Hon'ble Augustine George Masih
List In:Judge

Not taken up/ Not Today, List On (Date) [18-12-2024]

7 May 2024

Order(15) - 7 May 2024

ROP - of Main Case

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Abhay S. Oka, Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal
List In:Judge

List for Final Hearing/Disposal At Misc. Stage, List On (Date) [22-08-2024], List before court/bench [appeal(s) admitted for hearing ]

6 Feb 2024

Order(14) - 6 Feb 2024

ROP - of Main Case

Direction Matters (Old After Notice)

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Abhay S. Oka, Hon'ble Ujjal Bhuyan
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [07-05-2024]

10 Oct 2023

Order(13) - 10 Oct 2023

ROP - of Main Case

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Abhay S. Oka, Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal
List In:Judge

Week Commencing [15-01-2024], List On NMD [TUESDAY]

18 Aug 2023

Order(12) - 18 Aug 2023

ROP

8 Aug 2023

Order(11) - 8 Aug 2023

ROP - of Main Case

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Abhay S. Oka, Hon'ble Sanjay Karol
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [10-10-2023]

5 Jul 2023

Order(10) - 5 Jul 2023

ROP - of Main Case

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Next Week / Week Commencing / C.o.week
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Abhay S. Oka, Hon'ble Sanjay Karol
List In:Judge

IA Allowed [78573/2023], List On (Date) [08-08-2023], IA Withdrawn [57470/2020]

18 Nov 2022

Order(9) - 18 Nov 2022

ROP - of Main Case

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble K.M. Joseph, Hon'ble Hrishikesh Roy
List In:Judge

Notice, Week Commencing [01-02-2023]

22 Aug 2022

Order(8) - 22 Aug 2022

ROP - of Main Case

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble S. Ravindra Bhat, Hon'ble Sudhanshu Dhulia
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [30-09-2022], List Before Appropriate Bench

25 Jul 2022

Order(7) - 25 Jul 2022

ROP

6 Mar 2020

Order(6) - 6 Mar 2020

ROP - of Main Case

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Mention Memo
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Vineet Saran
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [23-03-2020]

2 Mar 2020

Order(5) - 2 Mar 2020

ROP - of Main Case

22 Nov 2019

Order(4) - 22 Nov 2019

ROP - of Main Case

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Vineet Saran
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [06-12-2019]

13 Nov 2019

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Vineet Saran
List In:Judge

18 Oct 2019

Order(3) - 18 Oct 2019

ROP - of Main Case

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Aniruddha Bose
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [13-11-2019]

30 Aug 2019

Order(2) - 30 Aug 2019

ROP - of Main Case

After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Vineet Saran
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [18-10-2019]

2 Aug 2019

Order(1) - 2 Aug 2019

ROP - of Main Case

First Hearing

Initial hearing scheduled

Fresh (For Admission) - Civil Cases

Purpose:Fresh
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Vineet Saran
List In:Judge

Notice, List On (Date) [30-08-2019]

26 Jul 2019

Case Registered

Registration No: 953/2019

23 Jul 2019

Case Filed

23 Jul 2019 Filing No: 25862/2019

Interlocutory Applications (IA) (12)

109918/2019
Particular: EX-PARTE STAY
Filed by: SARVESH SINGH
Filing Date: 2019-07-26
129158/2019
Particular: INTERVENTION/IMPLEADMENT
Filed by: SARVESH SINGH
Filing Date: 2019-08-26
Remark: I/A FOR IMPLEADMENT
175718/2019
Particular: INTERVENTION/IMPLEADMENT
Filed by: VIVEK KISHORE
Filing Date: 2019-11-18
Remark: IMPLEADMENT APPLICATION
34724/2020
Particular: INTERVENTION/IMPLEADMENT
Filed by: SARVESH SINGH
Filing Date: 2020-02-24
Remark: I/A FOR IMPLEADMENT U/O 1 RULE 10(2) R/W ORDER LV RULE 6 OF THE SCR 2013
34990/2020
Particular: APPROPRIATE ORDERS/DIRECTIONS
Filed by: SARVESH SINGH
Filing Date: 2020-02-25
57470/2020
Particular: INTERVENTION/IMPLEADMENT
Filed by: ARCHANA PATHAK DAVE
Filing Date: 2020-06-25
Remark: AN APPLICATION FOR IMPLEADMENT
57471/2020
Particular: EXEMPTION FROM FILING AFFIDAVIT
Filed by: ARCHANA PATHAK DAVE
Filing Date: 2020-06-25
Remark: I A FOR EXEMPTION FROM ATTESTED AFFIDAVIT AND COURT FEE
91930/2020
Particular: INTERVENTION/IMPLEADMENT
Filed by: SARVESH SINGH
Filing Date: 2020-09-15
Remark: APPLICATION FOR IMPLEADEMENT ACCEPTED AS PER DIRECTION OF DEALING
78573/2023
Particular: WITHDRAWAL OF CASE / APPLICATION
Filed by: ARCHANA PATHAK DAVE
Filing Date: 2023-04-17
109042/2024
Particular: PERMISSION TO FILE ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS/FACTS/ANNEXURES
Filed by: SARVESH SINGH
Filing Date: 2024-05-03
Remark: -EDSCIN01479252024
109043/2024
Particular: CONDONATION OF DELAY IN FILING
Filed by: SARVESH SINGH
Filing Date: 2024-05-03
Remark: -EDSCIN01479252024
171857/2024
Particular: INTERVENTION/IMPLEADMENT
Filed by: RAJESH KUMAR
Filing Date: 2024-08-05
Remark: -EASCIN01117722024

Tagged Matters (3)

25862/2019(26-07-2019 11:15 AM)W.P.(C) No. 000953 - / 2019 Registered on 26-07-2019 - UNKNOWN

Petitioner: COL. PRADEEP MATHUR
Respondent: UNION OF INDIA
Type: M•Status: P

6601/2022(01-06-2022 02:45 PM)W.P.(C) No. 000420 - / 2022 Registered on 01-06-2022 - UNKNOWN

Petitioner: ANIL KUMAR BHALLA
Respondent: UNION OF INDIA
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 14-08-2024

30930/2023(07-08-2023 04:39 PM)W.P.(C) No. 000806 - / 2023 Registered on 07-08-2023 - UNKNOWN

Petitioner: DISABLED WAR VETERANS (INDIA)
Respondent: UNION OF INDIA
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 14-08-2024

Notices (24)

S.No. 1
239262/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Chief Of The Naval Staff
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 2
239262/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 3
239261/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Chief Of The Air Staff
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 4
239261/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 5
239260/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Chief Of The Army Staff
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 6
239260/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 7
239259/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Union Of India
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 8
239259/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 9
239258/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Chairperson Central Board Of Direct Taxes
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 10
239258/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 11
239257/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Union Of India
Location:DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 12
239257/2019-09-04
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:9 Apr 2019
Return Date:18 Oct 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 13
216479/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Chief Of The Naval Staff
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 14
216479/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 15
216478/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Chief Of The Air Staff
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 16
216478/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 17
216477/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Chief Of The Army Staff
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 18
216477/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 19
216476/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Union Of India
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 20
216476/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 21
216475/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Chairperson Central Board Of Direct Taxes
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 22
216475/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 23
216474/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Union Of India
Location:DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 24
216474/2019-08-05
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Sarvesh Singh-2094copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:8 May 2019
Return Date:30 Aug 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending

Share This Case

Similar Case Search

Same Parties

Col. Pradeep Mathur vs Union Of IndiaCol. Pradeep MathurIc-46410p Lt Col Sada S Peter (Retd. )Ic-51016n Lt Col Shailesh Kumar Rai (Retd. )Ic- 46091n Lt Col Gian Prakash Yadav (Retd. )Ic-41749y Col Girish Hiralal Bhavsar (Retd. )Ic-49755f Lt Col M Anand (Retd. )Ic-55485n Lt Col Sanjay Joshi (Retd. )Sl-03661l Col Ranvir Singh Malik (Retd. )Ic-44113h Col Kabir Chaudhary (Retd. )No. 02227k Cdr Rajesh Shrimal (Retd. )Ic-40148f Col Tv Arun Kumar (Retd. )Ic-41737k Col Rajan Talwar (Retd. )Ic-31485p Col Yudhisthira Singh Gahlaut (Retd. )Ic-46373m Lt Col Ms Shankar (Retd. )No. 51100k Cdr K Chandrasekar (Retd. )Ic-45405x Col Vimal Mallick (Retd. )Ic-48225a Col Raj Kumar Singh (Retd. )Ic-40848p Col Aps Johal (Retd. )Ic-41446k Col Ram Kumar Dubey (Retd. )No-02228n Cdr Parag Saxena (Retd. )Ic-45204y Col Sanjay Bawa (Retd. )Ic-56811x Lt Col Chandrashekar Prabath Shankar (Retd. )Ic-39932h Col Vishnu Kumar Mishra (Retd. )Ic-47942f Col Krishna Prasad Ng (Retd. )Ic-33251k Lt Col Ravi Kant Talwar (Retd. )-33251k Lt Col Ravi Kant Talwar (Retd. )Ic-54227f Lt Col Sarang Prakash Pande (Retd. )Ic-30281w Maj Gen Srinivasan Arun (Retd. )Ic-31293x Col Basudev Banerjee (Retd. )Ic-42530w Col Munindra Kishore Sharma (Retd. )Ic-35442x Lt Col L D Shiggaon (Retd. )No-23589b Wg Cdr Satish Kumar (Retd. )Ic-33390n Lt Col Kv Chandrasekharan (Retd. )Ic-33041k Lt Col Joginder Singh Ahlawat (Retd. )Ic-36609h Col Dilip Dinanath Kulkarni (Retd. )No. 18147t Gp Capt Anshlesh Saxena (Retd. )Ic-44184k Col H Shankar (Retd. )No. 23610t Wg Cdr Joy Jacob N (Retd. )No. 23926h Wg Cdr George Horace Jones (Retd. )Ic-35447w Col Harish Chandra Pandey (Retd. )Ic-40183k Col Rs Panwar (Retd. )No. 23583a Wg Cdr B Gopikrishan (Retd. )Ic-34273p Brig Pratap Narayan Awasthi (Retd. )Ic-29389f Maj. Gurbachan Singh (Retd. )Ic-25546l Col Arun Dattaji Patole (Retd. )Ic-23417m Lt Col Vijaysingh Jaisingh Jadhav (Retd. )Ic-37196w Col Anil D Palande (Retd. )No. 41011f Cdr Jacob Isaac (Retd. )Ic-25588x Col Suresh Ramtri (Retd. )Ic-25455f Col Moti Chandra Pradhan (Retd. )Ic-39706l Lt Col Om Prakash Tripathi (Retd. )Ic40. Ic-36610x Col Dilip Prabhakarrao Sudame (Retd. )Ic-40117f Col Arunjeet Singh (Retd. )Ic-40345k Col Laxmi Narayan (Retd. )Ic-35437l Col Shree Krishan Singhal (Retd. )Ic-39285n Col Surendra Singh Shekhawat (Retd. )Jc-569582y Sub Maj (Hony Lt) Santbir Singh (Retd)Jc-570535h-Sub Ram Ratan Yadav (Retd. )Jc-439252w Sub M Yogalingam (Retd. )No751119a Sgt Rajavardha Reddy (Retd. )Jc-110700w Sub (Hony Capt) Udai Bir Singh (Retd. )Jc-640028a Sub (Hony Sm) Ashok Kumar (Retd. )No. 058350r Mcpo-1 (Hony Sub Lt) Lakshman RamNo 770739n Sgt Chandrashekar Rao S (Retd. )No 15356969l Hav Surendra Kumar (Retd. )Union Of IndiaChairperson Central Board Of Direct TaxesChief Of The Army StaffChief Of The Air StaffChief Of The Naval Staff
Case Content Last Updated21 Oct 2025, 3:52 am IST