eCourtsIndiaBeta

Kailash Narayan Venkatraman vs. The State Of Maharashtra State Excise Department Secretary

Court:Supreme Court of India
Judges:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, Hon'ble Deepak Gupta, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
Case Type:Special Leave Petition (Civil)
Filing no:24810/2017
CNR:SCIN010248102017

Parties & Advocates

Petitioners

1
Kailash Narayan Venkatraman
2
Hotel Panchali Proprietor
3
Lilawati Chandrashekhar Venkatraman Country Liquor Shop Proprietor
4
Shaikh Nadan Shaikh Lal Country Liquor Shop
5
Hotel Archana Proprietor

Petitioner Advocate

1
F. I. Choudhury

Respondents

1
The State Of Maharashtra State Excise Department Secretary
2
The Commissioner For Excise
3
The District Collector/superintendent Of Excise
4
Hotel Surya Proprietor Ramesh Haribhau Jagtap
5
Hotel Nimantran Proprietor Ranganath Abaji Abale
6
Hotrl Vijay Proprietor Sanjay Narayan Hase
7
Hotel Roop Sangam Proprietor Nandkumar Dhondiram Gujar
8
Hotel Laxmivilas Proprietor Suman Ambadas Naikwadi
9
Hotel Satara Garden Proprietor Sanjay Dadabhau Bhujbal
10
Hotel Atithi Proproetor Ashok Sakharam Dumbare
11
Hotel Sanjivani Proprietor Kashinath Babanrao Ghodake
12
Hotel New Akash Proprietor Chandrabhaga Nivrutti Bandavane
13
Hotel Pratik Proprietor Rohan Balaji Yelmane
14
Hotel Madhur Proprietor
15
Hotel Pawan Proprietor
16
Hotel Sanket Proprietor Karbhari Tukaram Gaikwad
17
Hotel Pathik Proprietor Sanjay Annasaheb Deshmukh
18
Hotel Vrundawan Proprietor Nanasaheb Sarjerao Jondhale
19
Hotel Golden Charriate Partners Mahesh Venunath Navale And Anil Venunath Navale
20
Hotel Sujit Proprietor Sunil Champala Mutha
21
Rajendra And Ravindra Keshav Gore Country Liquor Shop Partners Ranendra Keshav Gore And Ravindra Keshav Gore
22
Malikchand Govindram Sahani Country Liquor Shop
23
P. K. Beer Shopee Proprietor Mahendra Jankinath Kapoor
24
Vijay Wine And Beer Shopee Proprietor Shankar Shivaji Adhav
25
Hotel Sanap (nilayam) Proprietor Dilip Pundalik Sanap
26
Alka Ramdas Darade Country Liquor Shop
27
Hotel Amber Proprietor Mahendra Amarnath Gupta
28
Hotel Uday Palace Proprietor Sambhaji Shahurao Kambale
29
Hotel Poonam Proprietor Rajesh Hariram Alagh
30
Wine Center Proprietor Prashant Hariram Alagh
31
Raviraj Harbanslal Talwar Country Liquor And Beer Talwar Country Liquor And Beer Shoppe
32
C. K. Wines Proprietor Anil Chandraprakash Gupta
33
Hotel Punjab Restaurant And Beer Bar Proprietor Smt. Ninadevi Chandraprakash Gupta
34
Hotel Varad Proprietor Himanshu Rajendra Girme
35
Hotel Ashoka Proprietor Balasaheb Dadasaheb Tuwar
36
Hotel Vishwa Palace Proprietor Abasaheb Babasaheb Gaware
37
Hotel Sethij Garden And Restaurant Proprietor Sau Baljitkaur Ratansingh Sethi
38
Hotel President Proprietor Ratansingh Triloksingh Sethi
39
Maharashtra Wines Proprietor Memkaur Trilok Sethi
40
Nitin Wines Proprietor Suryakant Tulsiram Sagam
41
Hotel Sanjyot Proprietor Sanjay Rambhau Shinde
42
Hotel Panchsheel Proprietor Pramod Bhausaheb Labade
43
Hotel Prashant (jagdamba) Proprietor Prashant Bajirao Deshmukh
44
Hotel Nisarga Proprietor Pravin Bajirao Deshmukh
45
Hotel New Sidharth Proprietor Kedarnath A Fargade
46
Hotel Gazal Proprietor Daljitsingh Kartarsingh Batra
47
Navanath Laxman Kapse, Country Liquor Shopee
48
Hotel Enjoy Partner Laxman R Ghatkar And Kedarnath A Fargade
49
Hotel Ruchira Proprietor Shriram Narayan Vainkatraman
50
Hotel Kailash Proprietor Laxmibai Narayan Venkataman
51
Beer Shopee Proprietor Laxmibai Narayan Venkatraman
52
Vanita Sanjay Venkatraman Country Liquor Shop
53
Changdev Narayan Vetal Country Liquor Shop
54
Sanjay Narayan Venkatraman Country Liquor Shop
55
Chandrasekhar Narayan Venkatraman Country Liquor Shop
56
Parashuram Dubaiya And Hirabai Babanrao Gaikwad Partners Country Liquor Shop Partner Parashuram Dubaiya
57
Satyam Wines Proprietor Mohan Paramanand Chug
58
Garwa Beer Shopee Gat No. 842/2/2 Proprietor Dattatray Abu Shelar
59
Hotel Ranwara Partner Shantaram Ambadas Khedkar
60
Hotel New Lokseva Proprietor Shahaji Dada Mote
61
Hotel Pritej Proprietor Anil Damodhar Deshmukh
62
Hotel Chetan Proprietor Madhukar B. Deshmukh
63
Hotel Sarthak Partner Sanjay Pandurang Deshmukh
64
Shivaji T. Deshmukh Country Liquor Shop Divisional Engineer
65
Hotel Gulmohar Proprietor Kunal Anil Kamble

Respondent Advocate

1
Nishant Ramakantrao Katneshwarkar

Case History with Orders

26 Mar 2019

Disposed - 26 Mar 2019

Final Status

26 Mar 2019

Order(1) - 26 Mar 2019

ROP - of Main Case

Default / Other Matters

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, Hon'ble Deepak Gupta, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

Default / Other Matters

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, Hon'ble Deepak Gupta, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

29 Nov 2017

Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble A.M. Khanwilkar, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

List After (Weeks) [1]

27 Oct 2017

Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble A.M. Khanwilkar, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

List On (Date) [20-11-2017]

11 Sept 2017

Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble A.M. Khanwilkar, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

Other [LIST ON 23.10.2017]

4 Sept 2017

First Hearing

Initial hearing scheduled

Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)

Purpose:Mention Memo
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble A.M. Khanwilkar, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

14 Aug 2017

Case Filed

14 Aug 2017 Filing No: 24810/2017

Earlier Court Details (3)

Court:
High Court
State:
MAHARASHTRA
Case No:
WP-6879-2017
Order Date:
2017-07-10
Judgment Challenged:
Yes
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
MAHARASHTRA
Case No:
WP-5733-2017
Order Date:
2017-06-12
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
PUNJAB
Case No:
CWP-5594-2017
Order Date:
2017-03-29
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-

Share This Case

Similar Case Search

Same Parties

Kailash Narayan Venkatraman vs The State Of Maharashtra State Excise Department SecretaryKailash Narayan VenkatramanHotel Panchali ProprietorLilawati Chandrashekhar Venkatraman Country Liquor Shop ProprietorShaikh Nadan Shaikh Lal Country Liquor ShopHotel Archana ProprietorThe State Of Maharashtra State Excise Department SecretaryThe Commissioner For ExciseThe District Collector/Superintendent Of ExciseHotel Surya Proprietor Ramesh Haribhau JagtapHotel Nimantran Proprietor Ranganath Abaji AbaleHotrl Vijay Proprietor Sanjay Narayan HaseHotel Roop Sangam Proprietor Nandkumar Dhondiram GujarHotel Laxmivilas Proprietor Suman Ambadas NaikwadiHotel Satara Garden Proprietor Sanjay Dadabhau BhujbalHotel Atithi Proproetor Ashok Sakharam DumbareHotel Sanjivani Proprietor Kashinath Babanrao GhodakeHotel New Akash Proprietor Chandrabhaga Nivrutti BandavaneHotel Pratik Proprietor Rohan Balaji YelmaneHotel Madhur ProprietorHotel Pawan ProprietorHotel Sanket Proprietor Karbhari Tukaram GaikwadHotel Pathik Proprietor Sanjay Annasaheb DeshmukhHotel Vrundawan Proprietor Nanasaheb Sarjerao JondhaleHotel Golden Charriate Partners Mahesh Venunath Navale And Anil Venunath NavaleHotel Sujit Proprietor Sunil Champala MuthaRajendra And Ravindra Keshav Gore Country Liquor Shop Partners Ranendra Keshav Gore And Ravindra Keshav GoreMalikchand Govindram Sahani Country Liquor ShopP. K. Beer Shopee Proprietor Mahendra Jankinath KapoorVijay Wine And Beer Shopee Proprietor Shankar Shivaji AdhavHotel Sanap (Nilayam) Proprietor Dilip Pundalik SanapAlka Ramdas Darade Country Liquor ShopHotel Amber Proprietor Mahendra Amarnath GuptaHotel Uday Palace Proprietor Sambhaji Shahurao KambaleHotel Poonam Proprietor Rajesh Hariram AlaghWine Center Proprietor Prashant Hariram AlaghRaviraj Harbanslal Talwar Country Liquor And Beer Talwar Country Liquor And Beer ShoppeC. K. Wines Proprietor Anil Chandraprakash GuptaHotel Punjab Restaurant And Beer Bar Proprietor Smt. Ninadevi Chandraprakash GuptaHotel Varad Proprietor Himanshu Rajendra GirmeHotel Ashoka Proprietor Balasaheb Dadasaheb TuwarHotel Vishwa Palace Proprietor Abasaheb Babasaheb GawareHotel Sethij Garden And Restaurant Proprietor Sau Baljitkaur Ratansingh SethiHotel President Proprietor Ratansingh Triloksingh SethiMaharashtra Wines Proprietor Memkaur Trilok SethiNitin Wines Proprietor Suryakant Tulsiram SagamHotel Sanjyot Proprietor Sanjay Rambhau ShindeHotel Panchsheel Proprietor Pramod Bhausaheb LabadeHotel Prashant (Jagdamba) Proprietor Prashant Bajirao DeshmukhHotel Nisarga Proprietor Pravin Bajirao DeshmukhHotel New Sidharth Proprietor Kedarnath A FargadeHotel Gazal Proprietor Daljitsingh Kartarsingh BatraNavanath Laxman Kapse, Country Liquor ShopeeHotel Enjoy Partner Laxman R Ghatkar And Kedarnath A FargadeHotel Ruchira Proprietor Shriram Narayan VainkatramanHotel Kailash Proprietor Laxmibai Narayan VenkatamanBeer Shopee Proprietor Laxmibai Narayan VenkatramanVanita Sanjay Venkatraman Country Liquor ShopChangdev Narayan Vetal Country Liquor ShopSanjay Narayan Venkatraman Country Liquor ShopChandrasekhar Narayan Venkatraman Country Liquor ShopParashuram Dubaiya And Hirabai Babanrao Gaikwad Partners Country Liquor Shop Partner Parashuram DubaiyaSatyam Wines Proprietor Mohan Paramanand ChugGarwa Beer Shopee Gat No. 842/2/2 Proprietor Dattatray Abu ShelarHotel Ranwara Partner Shantaram Ambadas KhedkarHotel New Lokseva Proprietor Shahaji Dada MoteHotel Pritej Proprietor Anil Damodhar DeshmukhHotel Chetan Proprietor Madhukar B. DeshmukhHotel Sarthak Partner Sanjay Pandurang DeshmukhShivaji T. Deshmukh Country Liquor Shop Divisional EngineerHotel Gulmohar Proprietor Kunal Anil Kamble

Search in District Courts Data

Kailash Narayan VenkatramanHotel Panchali ProprietorLilawati Chandrashekhar Venkatraman Country Liquor Shop ProprietorShaikh Nadan Shaikh Lal Country Liquor ShopHotel Archana ProprietorThe State Of Maharashtra State Excise Department SecretaryThe Commissioner For ExciseThe District Collector/Superintendent Of ExciseHotel Surya Proprietor Ramesh Haribhau JagtapHotel Nimantran Proprietor Ranganath Abaji AbaleHotrl Vijay Proprietor Sanjay Narayan HaseHotel Roop Sangam Proprietor Nandkumar Dhondiram GujarHotel Laxmivilas Proprietor Suman Ambadas NaikwadiHotel Satara Garden Proprietor Sanjay Dadabhau BhujbalHotel Atithi Proproetor Ashok Sakharam DumbareHotel Sanjivani Proprietor Kashinath Babanrao GhodakeHotel New Akash Proprietor Chandrabhaga Nivrutti BandavaneHotel Pratik Proprietor Rohan Balaji YelmaneHotel Madhur ProprietorHotel Pawan ProprietorHotel Sanket Proprietor Karbhari Tukaram GaikwadHotel Pathik Proprietor Sanjay Annasaheb DeshmukhHotel Vrundawan Proprietor Nanasaheb Sarjerao JondhaleHotel Golden Charriate Partners Mahesh Venunath Navale And Anil Venunath NavaleHotel Sujit Proprietor Sunil Champala MuthaRajendra And Ravindra Keshav Gore Country Liquor Shop Partners Ranendra Keshav Gore And Ravindra Keshav GoreMalikchand Govindram Sahani Country Liquor ShopP. K. Beer Shopee Proprietor Mahendra Jankinath KapoorVijay Wine And Beer Shopee Proprietor Shankar Shivaji AdhavHotel Sanap (Nilayam) Proprietor Dilip Pundalik SanapAlka Ramdas Darade Country Liquor ShopHotel Amber Proprietor Mahendra Amarnath GuptaHotel Uday Palace Proprietor Sambhaji Shahurao KambaleHotel Poonam Proprietor Rajesh Hariram AlaghWine Center Proprietor Prashant Hariram AlaghRaviraj Harbanslal Talwar Country Liquor And Beer Talwar Country Liquor And Beer ShoppeC. K. Wines Proprietor Anil Chandraprakash GuptaHotel Punjab Restaurant And Beer Bar Proprietor Smt. Ninadevi Chandraprakash GuptaHotel Varad Proprietor Himanshu Rajendra GirmeHotel Ashoka Proprietor Balasaheb Dadasaheb TuwarHotel Vishwa Palace Proprietor Abasaheb Babasaheb GawareHotel Sethij Garden And Restaurant Proprietor Sau Baljitkaur Ratansingh SethiHotel President Proprietor Ratansingh Triloksingh SethiMaharashtra Wines Proprietor Memkaur Trilok SethiNitin Wines Proprietor Suryakant Tulsiram SagamHotel Sanjyot Proprietor Sanjay Rambhau ShindeHotel Panchsheel Proprietor Pramod Bhausaheb LabadeHotel Prashant (Jagdamba) Proprietor Prashant Bajirao DeshmukhHotel Nisarga Proprietor Pravin Bajirao DeshmukhHotel New Sidharth Proprietor Kedarnath A FargadeHotel Gazal Proprietor Daljitsingh Kartarsingh BatraNavanath Laxman Kapse, Country Liquor ShopeeHotel Enjoy Partner Laxman R Ghatkar And Kedarnath A FargadeHotel Ruchira Proprietor Shriram Narayan VainkatramanHotel Kailash Proprietor Laxmibai Narayan VenkatamanBeer Shopee Proprietor Laxmibai Narayan VenkatramanVanita Sanjay Venkatraman Country Liquor ShopChangdev Narayan Vetal Country Liquor ShopSanjay Narayan Venkatraman Country Liquor ShopChandrasekhar Narayan Venkatraman Country Liquor ShopParashuram Dubaiya And Hirabai Babanrao Gaikwad Partners Country Liquor Shop Partner Parashuram DubaiyaSatyam Wines Proprietor Mohan Paramanand ChugGarwa Beer Shopee Gat No. 842/2/2 Proprietor Dattatray Abu ShelarHotel Ranwara Partner Shantaram Ambadas KhedkarHotel New Lokseva Proprietor Shahaji Dada MoteHotel Pritej Proprietor Anil Damodhar DeshmukhHotel Chetan Proprietor Madhukar B. DeshmukhHotel Sarthak Partner Sanjay Pandurang DeshmukhShivaji T. Deshmukh Country Liquor Shop Divisional EngineerHotel Gulmohar Proprietor Kunal Anil KambleAdvocate F. I. ChoudhuryAdvocate Nishant Ramakantrao Katneshwarkar
Case Content Last Updated22 Aug 2025, 8:14 am IST