Idea Cellular Ltd. vs. Pune Municipal Coporation

Item No. :
SECTION III­A
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 5360­63, 5364, 5365, 6737­38, 6739, 6836­6926, 6385­87,
7865­94, 2854­55, 8115, 8116, 8117 AND 8114 OF 2013
WITH
INTERLOCUTARY APPLICATION NO. 1­4 AND 183­273 IN CIVIL APPEAL
5360­63 AND 6836­6926 OF 2013
(Application for deletion the name of performa Respondents)
WITH
INTERLOCUTARY APPLICATION NO. 7­9 IN CIVIL APPEAL NO. 6385­87
AND
INTERLOCUTARY APPLICATION NO. 2 IN 8115 OF 2013
(Application for Direction)
AND
SLP (C) NOS. 362, 12567, 21521, 22653, 29803­804 & 29765 OF 2014
AHMEDABAD MUNICIPAL CORPORATION ETC ETC<br>PETITIONER

AHMEDABAD MUNICIPAL CORPORATION ETC ETC ...PETITIONER VERSUS

GTL INFRA. LTD. & ORS. ETC. ...RESPONDENT

Listed on : 18112014

REVISED OFFICE REPORT

The matters abovementioned were listed before the Hon'ble Court on 9th

October, 2014, when the Hon'ble Court was pleased to pass the following order:

"List the matters after four weeks.

In the meanwhile, learned counsel for the appellant undertakes to have all the respondents served.

Pleadings be completed in the meantime."

Case No.	Nos. of<br>respondent	Through counsel	Certificate<br>of<br>service/<br>Counter­affidavit
5360/13	3	M/s. Parekh & Co.,<br>Advocates for respondent<br>no. 1	Certificate of service is awaited<br>in r/o Resp. Nos. 2 & 3.
5361/13	5	Mr. A. P. Medh, Advocate	Certificate of service has been

Service position of each matter is placed below:

		for Resp. no. 1	received in r/o R­2.<br>Certificate of service in r/o<br>Resp. no. 3 to 5 is awaited.
5362/13	2	M/s. Parekh & Co.,<br>Advocates for respondent<br>no. 1	Certificate of service is awaited<br>in r/o Resp. Nos. 2.
5363/13	9	Mr. E. C. Agrawala,<br>Advocate for Resp. no. 1	Certificate of service in r/o<br>Resp. no. 2 to 9 is awaited.
5364/13	3	Ms. Hemantika Wahi,<br>Advocate for Resp. no. 3	Certificate of service in r/o<br>Resp. no. 1 is received and in<br>r/o Resp. no. 2 is awaited.
5365/13	5	Mr. A. P. Medh, Advocate<br>for Resp. no. 1	Certificate of service in r/o<br>Resp. no. 2 & 5 received.
6737/13	4	­	Certificate of service in r/o<br>Resp. no's. 1 and 3 awaited.
6738/13	9	Mr. E. C. Agrawala,<br>Advocate for Resp. no. 2.<br>Mr. P. J. Malkan, Advocate<br>for Resp. no. 5.<br>Ms. Hemantika wahi,<br>Advocate for Resp. no. 6.	Certificate of service in r/o<br>Resp. no's. 1, 3, 4, and 7 to 9<br>are awaited.
6739/13	10	Mr. E. C. Agrawala,<br>Advocate for resp. no. 2	Certificate of service in r/o all<br>the respondents are received<br>(Service complete)
6836/13	3	Resp. no. 1 represented<br>through counsel.	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 & 3 awaited.
6837/13	2	­Do­	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 is awaited.
6838/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service Complete.
6839/13	3	Resp. No. 1 through<br>counsel.	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no 3 is received and Resp.<br>no. 2 is awaited.
6840/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6841/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6842/13	1	Sole respondent	Service is complete.

		represented through<br>counsel
843/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6844/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6845/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6846/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6847/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6848/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6849/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6850/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6851/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6852/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6853/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6854/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6855/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.

6856/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6857/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6858/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6859/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6860/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6861/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6862/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6863/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6864/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6865/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6866/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6867/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6868/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6869/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through	Service is complete.

		counsel
6870/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6871/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6872/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6873/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6874/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6875/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6876/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6877/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel	Service is complete.
6878/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6879/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6880/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6881/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6882/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6883/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the

			name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6884/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6885/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6886/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6887/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6888/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6889/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6890/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6891/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6892/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6893/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6894/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6895/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6896/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.

6897/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6898/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6899/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6900/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6901/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6902/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6903/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6904/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6905/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6906/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6907/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6908/13	3	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6909/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 awaited.
6910/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 awaited.
6911/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Certificate of service in r/o

			resp. no. 2 awaited.
6912/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 awaited.
6913/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 awaited.
6914/13	1	Sole respondent<br>represented through<br>counsel.	Service is complete.
6915/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 awaited.
6916/13	1	Sole respondent is<br>represented through<br>counsel.	Service is complete.
6917/13	4	Resp. no. 1 is represetned	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp.<br>no.<br>2<br>is<br>received.<br>Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 3 and 4 are<br>filed.
6918/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represetned	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 awaited.
6919/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represetned	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 awaited.
6920/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represetned	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 awaited.
6921/13	1	Sole respondent is<br>represented through<br>counsel.	Service is complete.
6922/13	3	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 and 3 are<br>filed.
6923/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented.	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 is filed.
6924/13	1	Sole respondent is<br>represented through<br>counsel.	Service is complete.
6925/13	1	Sole respondent is<br>represented through<br>counsel.	Service is complete.

6926/13	3	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Application for deletion the<br>name of performa on behalf of<br>respondent No. 2 and 3 are<br>filed.
6385/13	3	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Certificate of service in r/o of 2<br>and 3 is awaited.
6386/13	1	Sole respondent is<br>represented through<br>counsel.	Certificate<br>of<br>service<br>is<br>received.<br>Original record has also been<br>received.
6387/13	3	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Certificate of service in r/o all<br>respondents.<br>Original record has also been<br>received.
7865­94/13	2<br>common<br>respondent	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Service is complete.
2854­55/13	11	Resp. no. 1,5,6 and 8 is<br>represented.	Certificate of service in r/o of<br>all<br>respondent<br>has<br>been<br>received.
8115/13	2	Respondents are<br>represented	Service is complete
8116/13	2	Respondents are<br>represented	Service is complete
8117/13	2	Respondents are<br>represented	Service is complete
8114/13	2	Resp. no. 1 is represented	Certificate of service in r/o<br>resp. no. 2 received.

SLP No. 362 of 2014

362/14	4	Resp. no. 1 to 3 is<br>represented.	Neither AD card nor unserved<br>cover containing notice has<br>been received back in r/o resp.<br>no. 4
12567/14	3	All are represented through<br>counsel.

21521/14	4	Respondent No. 1, 2 & 3 are<br>represented.	Neither AD card nor unserved<br>cover containing notice has<br>been received back in r/o resp.<br>no. 4
22653/14	2	Respondent<br>No.<br>2<br>is<br>represented.	Neither AD card nor unserved<br>cover containing notice has<br>been received back in r/o resp.<br>no. 1
29803­804/14	5	Resp. No. 1 to 5.	Counsel for the petitioner has<br>filed the four spare copies<br>instead of five hence, notice<br>could not be issued.
29765/14	3	Resp. No. 1 to 3	Notice issued on 14­11­2014,<br>neither AD card nor unserved<br>cover containing notice has<br>been received back in r/o resp.<br>no. 1 to 3

It is submitted that Ms. Hemantika wahi has on 5th November, 2014 filed an application for deletion the name of performa respondent in Civil Appeal No. 5360–63 and 68366926 of 2013. The same are registered as I.A No. 1 to 4 and 183 to 273. Copies of the same have been placed with the main paper books.

It is further submitted that Mr. Puneet Taneja, Advocate has filed vakalat and appearance on behalf of Vyom Networks Ltd.

It is further that M/s Parekh & Co., Advocates has on 5th November, 2014 filed an application for amendment of Cause title on behalf of Wireless TT Ltd. in C.A No. 6839 & 6914 of 2013 praying therein changing the name of the Respondent/Applicant along with Vakalatnama but he has not taken the no objection from erstwhile advocate Mr. Puneet Taneja.

It is lastly submitted for information of the Hon'ble Court in pursuance of various Court's Order counsel has deposited the amount as FDR in the following matters:

Case No.	Amount	Date of maturity
5360­63/13	Two FDR<br>Rs. 16,90,876/­<br>Rs. 17,28,700/­	01­09­2015
5364/13	Rs. 9,54,122/­	22­09­2015
5365/13	Rs. 80,06,434/­	22­09­2015

6386/13	Rs. 28,43,987/­	22­09­2015
6387/13	Rs. 23,64,035/­	22­09­2015
7865/13	Rs. 2,55,679/­	22­09­2015
7866/13	Rs. 2,07,395/­	22­09­2015
7867/13	Rs. 1,35,927/­	22­09­2015
7868/13	Rs. 1,33,022/­	22­09­2015
7869/13	Rs. 99,589/­	22­09­2015
7870/13	Rs. 1,52,626/­	22­09­2015
7871/13	Rs. 1,20,955/­	22­09­2015
7872/13	Rs. 2,06,952/­	22­09­2015
7873/13	Rs. 87,593/­	22­09­2015
7874/13	Rs. 1,50,699/­	22­09­2015
7875/13	Rs. 1,67,550/­	22­09­2015
7876/13	Rs. 1,39,315/­	22­09­2015
7877/13	Rs. 2,16,477/­	22­09­2015
7879/13	Rs. 67,510/­	22­09­2015
7881/13	Rs. 1,94,495/­	22­09­2015
7882/13	Rs. 1,86,788/­	22­09­2015
7883/13	Rs. 1,68,450/­	22­09­2015
7886/13	Rs. 1,51,358/­	22­09­2015
7887/13	Rs. 1,51,247/­	22­09­2015
7888/13	Rs. 1,50,659/­	22­09­2015
7889/13	Rs. 1,39,258/­	22­09­2015
7891/13	Rs. 1,86,320/­	22­09­2015
7893/13	Rs. 1,26,039/­	22­09­2015
2854­55/14	Rs. 6,68,702/­<br>Rs. 11,67,255/­<br>Rs. 4,03,070/­	15­3­2015<br>15­3­2015<br>29­4­2015

The matters abovementioned are listed before the Hon'ble Court with this office report.

DATED THIS THE 17TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2014.

ASSISTANT REGISTRAR

COPY TO:

Ms. Hemantika Wahi, Advocate Mr. Abhijat P. Medh, Advocate Mr. E. C. Agrawala, Advocate Mr. Purvish Jitendra Malkan, Advocate M/s Paresh & Co., Advocate Mr. Mohit Paul, Advocate Mrs. Sumita Ray, Advocate Mr. Puneet Taneja, Advocate Mr. Pavan Kumar, Advocate Mr. D. M. Nargolkar, Advocate Ms. Abha R. Sharma, Advocate Ms. Bindi Girish Dave, Advocate Mr. V. N. Raghupathy, Advocate

ASSISTANT REGISTRAR