The State Of Maharashtra Finance Department Secretay vs. Subway System India Pvt Ltd
Court:Supreme Court of India
Judges:Hon'ble Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Hon'ble Manoj Misra
Case Type:Civil Appeal
Reg no:8348/2018
Filing no:20624/2017
CNR:SCIN010206242017
Parties & Advocates
Petitioners
1
The State Of Maharashtra Finance Department Secretay
2
Assistant Commissioner Of Sales Tax
Petitioner Advocate
1
Aaditya Aniruddha Pande
Respondents
1
Subway System India Pvt Ltd
2
Jaganath Rao, Director
3
Ravindra Pal Singh Partner Suresh Surana And Associates Llp
4
Union Of India Aaykar Bhavan Finance Secretary
5
Commissioner Of Service Tax
Respondent Advocates
1
Mukesh Kumar Maroria
2
Nikhil Jain
Case History with Orders
Pending
Final Status
Pending
Final Status
24 Aug 2023
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Hon'ble Manoj Misra
List In:Judge
Part Heard, List On (Date) [29-08-2023], List before court/bench [AT 2 PM]
24 Aug 2023
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Hon'ble Manoj Misra
List In:Judge
Part Heard, List On (Date) [29-08-2023], List before court/bench [AT 2 PM]
23 Aug 2023
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Hon'ble Manoj Misra
List In:Judge
Part Heard, List On (Date) [24-08-2023]
23 Aug 2023
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Hon'ble Manoj Misra
List In:Judge
Part Heard, List On (Date) [24-08-2023]
9 Aug 2023
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Ordinary
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Hon'ble Manoj Misra
List In:Judge
List On (Date) [23-08-2023]
9 Aug 2023
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Ordinary
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Hon'ble Manoj Misra
List In:Judge
List On (Date) [23-08-2023]
24 Nov 2022
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble M.R. Shah, Hon'ble M.M. Sundresh
List In:Judge
Not taken up/ Not Today
24 Nov 2022
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble M.R. Shah, Hon'ble M.M. Sundresh
List In:Judge
Not taken up/ Not Today
23 Nov 2022
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble M.R. Shah, Hon'ble M.M. Sundresh
List In:Judge
Not taken up/ Not Today
23 Nov 2022
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble M.R. Shah, Hon'ble M.M. Sundresh
List In:Judge
Not taken up/ Not Today
22 Nov 2022
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble M.R. Shah, Hon'ble M.M. Sundresh
List In:Judge
Not taken up/ Not Today
22 Nov 2022
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble M.R. Shah, Hon'ble M.M. Sundresh
List In:Judge
Not taken up/ Not Today
19 Apr 2022
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble A.M. Khanwilkar, Hon'ble Abhay S. Oka, Hon'ble C.T. Ravikumar
List In:Judge
List After (Weeks) [11]
19 Apr 2022
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble A.M. Khanwilkar, Hon'ble Abhay S. Oka, Hon'ble C.T. Ravikumar
List In:Judge
List After (Weeks) [11]
14 Jan 2020
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Next Week / Week Commencing / C.o.week
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble A.M. Khanwilkar, Hon'ble Dinesh Maheshwari
List In:Judge
List After (Weeks) [4], List Before Appropriate Bench
14 Jan 2020
Indirect Taxes Matters : Sales Tax Act (Central &Amp; Various States)
Purpose:Next Week / Week Commencing / C.o.week
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble A.M. Khanwilkar, Hon'ble Dinesh Maheshwari
List In:Judge
List After (Weeks) [4], List Before Appropriate Bench
14 Oct 2019
Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)
Purpose:Ordinary
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble M.R. Shah
List In:Chamber
List After (Weeks) [2]
14 Oct 2019
Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)
Purpose:Ordinary
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble M.R. Shah
List In:Chamber
List After (Weeks) [2]
29 Jul 2019
Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar
List Before Chamber
29 Jul 2019
Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar
List Before Chamber
16 Apr 2019
Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)
Purpose:Administrative Order
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar
16 Apr 2019
Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)
Purpose:Administrative Order
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar
16 Apr 2019
Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)
Purpose:Administrative Order
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar
Service/compliance-before Registrar(j)
Purpose:Administrative Order
Category:Unknown
Before:Registrar (J) - Ii
List In:Registrar
20 Aug 2018
Case Registered
Registration No: 8348/2018
20 Aug 2018
Case Registered
Registration No: 8348/2018
13 Aug 2018
After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Madan B. Lokur, Hon'ble S. Abdul Nazeer, Hon'ble Deepak Gupta
List In:Judge
Leave Granted / Rule NISI / Appeal Admitted [Leave granted]
13 Aug 2018
After Notice (For Admission) - Civil Cases
Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Madan B. Lokur, Hon'ble S. Abdul Nazeer, Hon'ble Deepak Gupta
List In:Judge
Leave Granted / Rule NISI / Appeal Admitted [Leave granted]
3 Nov 2017
First Hearing
Initial hearing scheduled
3 Nov 2017
Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)
Purpose:Fresh
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Madan B. Lokur, Hon'ble Deepak Gupta
List In:Judge
Notice Tag with
3 Nov 2017
First Hearing
Initial hearing scheduled
Orders (Incomplete Matters / Ias / Crlmps)
Purpose:Fresh
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Madan B. Lokur, Hon'ble Deepak Gupta
List In:Judge
Notice Tag with
Case Filed
12 Jul 2017
Filing No: 20624/2017
12 Jul 2017
Case Filed
12 Jul 2017
Filing No: 20624/2017
Interlocutory Applications (IA) (2)
69224/2017
Particular: CONDONATION OF DELAY IN FILING
Filed by: KUNAL CHEEMA
Filing Date: 2017-08-04
69227/2017
Particular: EXEMPTION FROM FILING C/C OF THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT
Filed by: KUNAL CHEEMA
Filing Date: 2017-08-04
Tagged Matters (17)
16963/2016(02-07-2016 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 005456 - 005459 / 2016 Registered on 02-07-2016S.L.P.(C)...CC No. 009871 - 009874 / 2016 Registered on 17-05-2016SLP(C) No. 016246 - 016249 / 2016 Registered on 02-07-2016 - CA
Petitioner: STATE OF KARNATAKA
Respondent: M/S. UNITED BREWERIES LTD.
Type: M•Status: P•Entry: 07-07-2023
23415/2023(00-00-0000 12:00 AM)SLP(C) No. - SLP_C
Petitioner: THE COMMISSIONER, COMMERCIAL TAX, U. P. LUCKNOW
Respondent: M/S KAMLAKANT AND COMPANY
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
38020/2016(21-11-2016 04:37 PM)C.A. No. 008368 / 2018 Registered on 20-08-2018SLP(C) No. 034331 / 2016 Registered on 21-11-2016 - CA
Petitioner: MAHYCO MONSANTO BIOTECH (INDIA ) PVT LTD
Respondent: UNION OF INDIA
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
3215/2017(06-02-2017 04:43 PM)SLP(C) No. 004184 - 004185 / 2017 Registered on 06-02-2017 - SLP_C
Petitioner: M/S G.D. GOENKA (P) LIMITED
Respondent: STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
4143/2017(15-02-2017 02:43 PM)C.A. No. 008416 / 2018 Registered on 13-08-2018SLP(C) No. 005829 / 2017 Registered on 15-02-2017 - CA
Petitioner: M/S DOMINOS PIZZA OVERSEAS FRANCHISING BV
Respondent: THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
4145/2017(20-02-2017 02:36 PM)C.A. No. 008417 / 2018 Registered on 13-08-2018SLP(C) No. 006344 / 2017 Registered on 20-02-2017 - CA
Petitioner: M/S DOMINOS PIZZA INTERNATIONAL FRANCHISING INC.
Respondent: STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
3427/2017(03-04-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 008347 / 2018 Registered on 20-08-2018SLP(C) No. 010333 / 2017 Registered on 03-04-2017S.L.P.(C)...CC No. 004891 / 2017 Registered on 03-03-2017 - CA
Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA
Respondent: MAHYCO MONSANTO BIOTECH (INDIA) PRIVATE LIMITED .
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
14204/2014(19-04-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 005380 - 005384 / 2017 Registered on 19-04-2017SLP(C) No. 017119 - 017123 / 2014 Registered on 01-07-2014 - CA
Petitioner: COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER,KOZHIKODE .
Respondent: MALABAR GOLD PVT.LTD. .
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
14205/2014(19-04-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 005385 - 005389 / 2017 Registered on 19-04-2017S.L.P.(C)...CC No. 009200 - 009204 / 2014 Registered on 13-06-2014SLP(C) No. 017125 - 017129 / 2014 Registered on 01-07-2014 - CA
Petitioner: COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER KOZHIKODE .
Respondent: COMMNR.OF CENT.EXCISE
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
9560/2017(27-04-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 005668 / 2017 Registered on 27-04-2017S.L.P.(C)...CC No. 008320 / 2017 Registered on 18-04-2017SLP(C) No. 013894 / 2017 Registered on 24-04-2017 - CA
Petitioner: THE COMMISSIONER, COMMERCIAL TAXES, U.P.
Respondent: S/S KAMLA KANT AND CO.
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
9562/2017(27-04-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 005641 / 2017 Registered on 27-04-2017S.L.P.(C)...CC No. 008197 / 2017 Registered on 17-04-2017SLP(C) No. 013775 / 2017 Registered on 24-04-2017 - CA
Petitioner: THE COMMISSIONER COMMERCIAL TAXES U.P.
Respondent: S/S KAMLA KANT AND CO.
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
21195/2017(25-07-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 010598 - 010599 / 2017 Registered on 16-08-2017SLP(C) No. 019093 - 019094 / 2017 Registered on 25-07-2017 - CA
Petitioner: COMMISSIONER OF TRADE AND TAXES NEW DELHI
Respondent: M/S MCDONALD'S INDIA PVT. LTD
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
23324/2017(23-08-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 011185 - 011186 / 2017 Registered on 01-09-2017SLP(C) No. 021732 - 021733 / 2017 Registered on 23-08-2017 - CA
Petitioner: VALUE ADDED TAX OFFICER (WARD 205) DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND TAXES
Respondent: SAGAR RATNA RESTAURANTS PVT LTD
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
23661/2017(30-08-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 019579 / 2017 Registered on 20-11-2017SLP(C) No. 022636 - / 2017 Registered on 30-08-2017 - CA
Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA
Respondent: M/S BIKANERWALA FOODS PVT LTD
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
23662/2017(07-09-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 015307 / 2017 Registered on 15-09-2017SLP(C) No. 023508 - / 2017 Registered on 07-09-2017 - CA
Petitioner: ASSESSING AUTHORITY SPECIAL ZONE TRADE AND TAX DEPARTMENT
Respondent: GLAXO SMITH KLINE ASIA P LTD
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
20624/2017(03-11-2017 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 008348 / 2018 Registered on 20-08-2018SLP(C) No. 031054 - / 2017 Registered on 03-11-2017 - CA
Petitioner: THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
Respondent: SUBWAY SYSTEM INDIA PVT LTD
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
14300/2017(18-09-2023 12:36 PM)SLP(C) No. 020871 - 020942 / 2023 Registered on 18-09-2023 - SLP_C
Petitioner: STATE OF KARNATAKA
Respondent: M/S UNITED BREWERIES LTD
Type: L•Status: P•Entry: 03-11-2023
Earlier Court Details (4)
Court:
High Court
State:
MAHARASHTRA
Case No:
WP-497-2015
Order Date:
2016-08-11
Judgment Challenged:
Yes
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
MAHARASHTRA
Case No:
WP-9175-2015
Order Date:
2016-08-11
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
MAHARASHTRA
Case No:
WP-2818-2012
Order Date:
2015-10-20
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
MAHARASHTRA
Case No:
NOML-214-2013
Order Date:
2015-10-20
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Notices (22)
S.No. 1
264538/2019-10-17
Notice Type: Letter to advocate Regarding Valuation
Name:Mr. N. R. Katneshwarkar, Advocate
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:17 Oct 2019
Return Date:11 Apr 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 2
264537/2019-10-17
Notice Type: NLPA
Name:Mr. B. K. Prasad, Advocate
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:17 Oct 2019
Return Date:11 Apr 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 3
264536/2019-10-17
Notice Type: NLPA
Name:M/S. Khaitan &Amp; Co., Advocates
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:17 Oct 2019
Return Date:11 Apr 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 4
264535/2019-10-17
Notice Type: NLPA (Letter)
Name:The Registrar
Location:MAHARASHTRA, MUMBAI, Station: Mumbai
Issue Date:17 Oct 2019
Return Date:11 Apr 2019
Dispatch Date:31 Oct 2019
S.No. 5
264535/2019-10-17
Notice Type: NLPA (Letter)
Name:Khaitan &Amp; Co.-1509copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:17 Oct 2019
Return Date:11 Apr 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 6
264535/2019-10-17
Notice Type: NLPA (Letter)
Name:Nishant Ramakantrao Katneshwarkar-1729copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:17 Oct 2019
Return Date:11 Apr 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 7
264535/2019-10-17
Notice Type: NLPA (Letter)
Name:B. Krishna Prasad-117copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:17 Oct 2019
Return Date:11 Apr 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 8
264534/2019-10-17
Notice Type: NLPA
Name:Ravindra Pal Singh Partner Suresh Surana And Associates Llp
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:17 Oct 2019
Return Date:11 Apr 2019
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 9
49063/2024-02-27
Notice Type: Letter for curing the defects in documents
Name:Mr. Nikhil Jain, Advocate
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI
Issue Date:27 Feb 2024
Return Date:N/A
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 10
41915/2017-11-16
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Through High Court Of Judicature At Bombay Maharashtra
Location:MUMBAI, MAHARASHTRA
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 11
41915/2017-11-16
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Khaitan &Amp; Co.-1509copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 12
41915/2017-11-16
Notice Type: letter for certified copy
Name:Kunal Cheema-2250copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 13
41914/2017-11-16
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Commissioner Of Service Tax
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI, Station: New Delhi
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:28 Nov 2017
S.No. 14
41914/2017-11-16
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Kunal Cheema-2250copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 15
41913/2017-11-16
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Union Of India Aaykar Bhavan Finance Secretary
Location:MAHARASHTRA, MUMBAI, Station: Mumbai
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:28 Nov 2017
S.No. 16
41913/2017-11-16
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Kunal Cheema-2250copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 17
41912/2017-11-16
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Ravindra Pal Singh Partner Suresh Surana And Associates Llp
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI, Station: New Delhi
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:28 Nov 2017
S.No. 18
41912/2017-11-16
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Kunal Cheema-2250copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 19
41911/2017-11-16
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Jaganath Rao, Directorthrough Khaitan &Amp; Co.-1509
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI, Station: New Delhi
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:28 Nov 2017
S.No. 20
41911/2017-11-16
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Kunal Cheema-2250copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
S.No. 21
41910/2017-11-16
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Subway System India Pvt Ltd Managing Director
Location:DELHI, NEW DELHI, Station: New Delhi
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:28 Nov 2017
S.No. 22
41910/2017-11-16
Notice Type: Returnable Notice
Name:Kunal Cheema-2250copy
Location:NEW DELHI, DELHI
Issue Date:16 Nov 2017
Return Date:1 Apr 2018
Dispatch Date:Pending
Share This Case
Similar Case Search
Same Parties
The State Of Maharashtra Finance Department Secretay vs Subway System India Pvt LtdThe State Of Maharashtra Finance Department SecretayAssistant Commissioner Of Sales TaxSubway System India Pvt LtdJaganath Rao, DirectorRavindra Pal Singh Partner Suresh Surana And Associates LlpUnion Of India Aaykar Bhavan Finance SecretaryCommissioner Of Service Tax
Search in District Courts Data
The State Of Maharashtra Finance Department SecretayAssistant Commissioner Of Sales TaxSubway System India Pvt LtdJaganath Rao, DirectorRavindra Pal Singh Partner Suresh Surana And Associates LlpUnion Of India Aaykar Bhavan Finance SecretaryCommissioner Of Service TaxAdvocate Aaditya Aniruddha PandeAdvocate Mukesh Kumar MaroriaAdvocate Nikhil Jain
Case Content Last Updated22 Aug 2025, 11:36 am IST