Finance Department Government Of India Secretary Union Of India vs. Piyushbhai Chaturbhai Patel
AI Summary
Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order
Original Order Copy
Get a certified copy of this order
Order Text
Listed on. 12.04.2016 R. Court No. 1 Item No. 15
SECTION IIIA IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL APPEALATE JURISDICTION
PETITION FOR SPECIAL LEAVE TO APEAL (C) NO. 2436263 OF 2013, 18274, 19974, 22282, 24748, 24749, 24750, 14698, 24879, 24747, 26781, 26649, 26780, 29246, 30611, 30639, 36797, 34200, 36421 OF 2014, 12098, 2377, 3512, 12099, 12101, 7156, 7583, 9747, 10432, 12097, 12079, 14580, 9904, 19169, 19305, 28514, 28447 AND 35170 OF 2015 WITH PRAYER FOR INTERIM RELIEF
COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX ....PETITIONER
VERSUS
M/S CALCUTTA EXPORT CO. & ORS ETC. ....RESPONDENTS
OFFICE REPORT
The matters above mentioned were listed before the Ld. Registrar's Court on 29th January, 2016, when the following order was passed:
"SLP(C) NO.18274/2014
Last opportunity of four weeks is granted for filing counter affidavit.
SLP(C) NO.24362-63/2013
Ld. Counsel for the petitioner to take fresh steps to effect service on the sole respondent within four weeks time. Notice thereafter be issued.
SLP(C) NO.12079/2015
Service is complete on the sole respondent but none has entered appearance.
SLP(C) NOS. 24749, 30611, 34200 of 2014, 12098, 19169 of 2015
Counter affidavit has been filed.
Matters stand complete. However, to be listed before the Hon'ble Court alongwith connected matters.
SLP(C) NO. 28447, 35170 of 2015
Fresh matters.
SLP(C) NOS. 24747, 24750, 29246, 24748 of 2014
Opportunity to file counter affidavit has already been declined.
Matters stand complete. However, to be listed before the Hon'ble Court alongwith connected matters.
SLP(C) NO.24879/2014
Despite last opportunity having been granted, counter affidavit has not been filed by the sole respondent. As such further opportunity is declinded.
Matter stands complete. However, to be listed before the Hon'ble Court alongwith connected matters.
SLP(C) NO. 2377, 12097, 12099, 12101 of 2015
Last opportunity of four weeks is granted for filing counter affidavit.
SLP(C) NOS. 19974, 22282, 14698, 26781, 26649, 26780, 30639, 36797, 36421 OF 2014, 3512, 7156, 7583, 9747, 10432, 14580, 9904, 19305, 28514 OF 2015
Ld. Counsel for the pettioner to take fresh steps to effect service on the sole respondent within four weeks time as last opportunity. Notice thereafter be issued.
List again on 12.4.2016."
SLP(C) NO. 2436224363 OF 2013
It is submitted that Show Cause Notice was issued to the sole respondent on 25th February, 2015. Counsel for the petitioner has on 30th March, 2016 filed latest and correct address of the sole respondent but he has not filed spare copy, hence, notice could not be issued.
Service of notice is not complete.
The matters above mentioned were listed before the Hon'ble Court on various dates when the Hon'ble Court has directed to issue notice.
S.No. SLP Nos. Total Resp. Vakalatnama filed on behalf of R. Nos. Neither A.D. Card nor unserved cover received from R. Nos. Remarks/ service of notice 1. 18274/14 sole Respresented Complete. Counteraffidavit not filed. 2. 19974/14 sole Incomplete. 3. 22282/14 sole Incomplete.
Service position of SLP of 2014 are given below:
| 4. | 24748/14 | sole | Respresented | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit not<br>filed. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5. | 24749/14 | sole | Respresented | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit and<br>rejoinder affidavit<br>filed. |
| 6. | 24750/14 | sole | Respresented | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit not<br>filed. |
| 7. | 14698/14 | sole | | | Incomplete. |
| 8. | 24879/14 | sole | Respresented | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit not<br>filed. |
| 9. | 24747/14 | sole | Respresented | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit not<br>filed. |
| 10. | 26781/14 | sole | | | Incomplete. |
| 11. | 26649/14 | sole | | | Incomplete. |
| 12. | 26780/14 | sole | | AD Card received | Complete |
| 13. | 29246/14 | sole | Respresented | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit not<br>filed. |
| 14. | 30611/14 | sole | Respresented | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit and<br>Rejoinder Affiavit<br>filed. |
| 15. | 30639/14 | sole | | | Incomplete. |
| 16. | 36797/14 | sole | | | Incomplete. |
| 17. | 34200/14 | sole | Represented | | Complete. |
| Counteraffidavit and<br>rejoinder affidavit<br>filed. | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18.<br>36421/14 | sole | | | Incomplete. |
Service position of SLP of 2015 are given below:
| S.No. | SLP Nos. | Total<br>Resp. | Vakalatnama<br>filed on behalf of<br>R. Nos. | Neither A.D. Card<br>nor unserved cover<br>received from R.<br>Nos. | Remarks/ service of<br>notice |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | 12098/15 | sole | Mr. Abhijit<br>Sengupta | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit<br>filed. |
| 2. | 2377/15 | sole | Mr. K. V. Mohan | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit not<br>filed. |
| 3. | 3512/15 | Sole | | AD Card received | Complete |
| 4. | 12099/15 | sole | Mr. K. V. Mohan | | Complete. Counter<br>Affidavit not filed. |
| 5. | 12101/15 | sole | Ms. Priya Aristotle | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit not<br>filed. |
| 6. | 7156/15 | sole | | | Address filed by the<br>advocate but spare<br>copy<br>not filed.<br>Hence, notice could<br>not<br>be<br>issued.<br>Incomlete |
| 7. | 7583/15 | sole | | | Incomplete |
| 8. | 9747/15 | sole | | | Address filed by the<br>advocate but spare<br>copy<br>not filed.<br>Hence, notice could<br>not<br>be<br>issued.<br>Incomlete |
| 9. | 10432/15 | sole | | | Address filed by the<br>advocate but spare<br>copy<br>not filed.<br>Hence, notice could<br>not<br>be<br>issued.<br>Incomlete |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10. | 12097/15 | sole | Mr. K. V. Mohan | | Complete. Counter<br>Affidavit not filed. |
| 11. | 12079/15 | sole | | | Delivered on 1st May,<br>2015 |
| 12. | 14580/15 | sole | | | Incomplete |
| 13. | 9904/15 | sole | | AD Card duly signed<br>by Ms. Preeti Ahuja<br>received. | Complete. |
| 14. | 19169/15 | sole | Mr. Gautam<br>Narayan | | Complete.<br>Counteraffidavit &<br>Rejoinder affidavit<br>filed. |
| 15. | 19305/15 | sole | | | Address filed by the<br>advocate but spare<br>copy<br>not filed.<br>Hence, notice could<br>not<br>be<br>issued.<br>Incomlete |
| 16. | 28514/15 | sole | | AD Card received | Complete |
| 17. | 28447/15 | sole | | | Fresh matter. Only<br>tag with SLP No<br>26781 of 2014. |
| 18. | 35170/15 | sole | | | Delay condoned. Tag<br>with SLP Nos. 11139<br>of 2014. |
It is submitted that pursuant to the above Court's Order dated 29th January, 2016, Counter affidavit have not filed in SLP Nos. 18274 and 24879 of 2014, 2377, 12097, 12099, 12101 of 2015 and Counteraffidavit filed in SLP Nos. 24749, 34200 and 30611 of 2014.
It is further submitted that service for notice is not complete in SLP Nos. 19974, 22282, 14698, 26781, 26649, 30639, 36797 & 36421 of 2014 and 7156, 7583, 9747, 10432, 14580 & 19305 of 2015.
The matters abovementioned are listed before the Ld. Registrar's Court for orders.
DATED THIS THE 11TH DAY OF APRIL, 2016.
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
Copy to:
Mrs. Anil Katiyar, Advocate Mr Praveen Swarup, Advocate Ms. Manisha T. Karia, Advocate Mr. Jay Savla, Advocate Mr. Ambhoj Kr. Sinha, Advocate Mr. K. V. Mohan, Advocate Mr. Abhijit Sengupta, Advocate
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
ac3