Hardev Singh vs. The State Of Punjab

REGISTRAR COURT. 2 SECTION IV-B

S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

BEFORE THE REGISTRAR SH. RAJIV KALRA

Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s). 9657/2018

PUNJAB URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (NOW BATHINDA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY) Petitioner(s)

VERSUS

DR. K.K. NOHRIA & ORS. Respondent(s)

WITH

Digitally signed by Rajiv Kalra

• SLP(C) No. 14164/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9896/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9935/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11390/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11512/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11619/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11612/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11513/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11578/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 10906/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11450/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9907/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11174/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11313/2018 (IV-B) Signature Not Verified

• SLP(C) No. 11523/2018 (IV-B) Date: 2020.02.05 18:12:41 IST Reason:

  • SLP(C) No. 9916/2018 (IV-B)
  • SLP(C) No. 10636/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11435/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 14165/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11437/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11442/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11431/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 14074/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11490/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 14167/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12124/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11395/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11389/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11385/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11372/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9894/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11381/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11212/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11387/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11310/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11443/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11283/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 10914/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 14172/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11391/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9859/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 10958/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9856/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11408/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11181/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 10908/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 10214/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9830/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11441/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11168/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9820/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 10905/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9924/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9919/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11518/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 14178/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11396/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 10899/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11192/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11278/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11617/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9884/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12475/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11388/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9938/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11394/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11384/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11339/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11562/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11012/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11216/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11274/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9882/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 10909/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9897/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9963/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11432/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11311/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9890/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11446/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9870/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9648/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9899/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11622/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9932/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11543/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 9877/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 10902/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11386/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 11514/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12364/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13165/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12755/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13223/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12225/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12358/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12450/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12664/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13054/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12337/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12368/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12658/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13128/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12447/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12659/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12771/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12656/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12657/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12261/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13382/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12297/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13121/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13309/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13387/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13367/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13177/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12772/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13170/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13174/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12824/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12825/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12746/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12758/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13401/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13423/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12722/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13310/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13087/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12716/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13142/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12696/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13096/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13140/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13232/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13088/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13371/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12781/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13126/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13369/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13180/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13150/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12757/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12654/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12906/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12652/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13127/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13181/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12908/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12729/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13928/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13308/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13297/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12692/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13182/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12735/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13153/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13389/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13301/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12907/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13302/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13148/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13247/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13120/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 13112/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 12708/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 14102/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 23221-23222/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 17450-17467/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 17095-17096/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 20501/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 20500/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 23421/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 22479-22481/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 24664/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 23603-23604/2018 (IV-B)

• SLP(C) No. 259/2019 (IV-B)

SLP(C) No. 261/2019 (IV-B)

SLP(C) No. 2352/2019 (IV-B)

Date : 05-02-2020 These petitions were called on for hearing today.

For Petitioner(s) Mr. Akshay Verma, AOR Mr. Amrendra Kumar Mehta, AOR Mr. Gagan Gupta, AOR Mr. Umang Shankar, AOR Mr. Rajat Sharma,Adv. Mr. Subhasish Bhowmick, AOR Mrs. Rachana Joshi Issar, AOR Ms. Prerana Chaturvedi,Adv. Mr. Shantanu Jugdawat,Adv. Mr. Mohit Kaushik,Adv. M/S. Mukesh Kumar Singh And Co., AOR Mr. T. V. S. Raghavendra Sreyas, AOR Mr. Ram Naresh Yadav, AOR For Respondent(s) Mr. T. V. S. Raghavendra Sreyas, AOR Mr. Sridhar Potaraju, AOR Ms. Shweta Parihar,Adv. Ms. Shiwani Tushir,Adv. Ms. G. Ushasri,Adv. M/S. Mukesh Kumar Singh And Co., AOR Mr. Ajay Kumar Singh, AOR Mr. Kunwar Vikramaditya Shah,Adv. Mr. S. K. Verma, AOR Mr. Himanshu Sharma,Adv. Ms. Aditi Sharma,Adv. Mr. Vinay Kumar,Adv.

Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, AOR Mr. Akshay Verma, AOR Mr. Akashdeep Verma,Adv. Mr. Saurav Arora,Adv. Mr. Amrendra Kumar Mehta, AOR Mr. Umang Shankar, AOR Shri. Gaichangpou Gangmei, AOR Mr. Ajay Marwah, AOR Mr. C. Mukesh Sangwan,Adv. Mrs. Rachana Joshi Issar, AOR Ms. Prerana Chaturvedi,Adv.

Ms. Uttara Babbar, AOR

UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following O R D E R

Ms. Prerana Chaturvedi, Ld. Counsel for the petitioner submits that Mrs. Rachana Joshi Issar, Ld. Advocate-on-Record has left the panel of Punjab Urban Development Authority (NOW Bathinda Development Authority) in all the matters numbered above. She further submits that the said Ld. AOR has already provided the "NOC" and requisite documents to the concerned party.

Since Mrs. Rachana Joshi Issar, Ld. Advocate-on-Record has left the panel and handed over the NOC, the Punjab Urban Development Authority (NOW Bathinda Development Authority) has to appoint a new Counsel in her place. Let the Registry to issue notice for making alternative arrangement with utmost dispatch.

The office report indicates that in SLP(C) No. 10958/2018 vakalatnama filed by learned counsel for respondent No.1 is defective. Learned counsel shall within a period of two weeks cure the defects whatever have been found in the said vakalatnama.

Service of notice is complete qua respondent Nos.2 and 3 but no one has entered appearance on their behalf.

The office report further indicates that Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, Ld. Counsel has filed IA for permission to file counter affidavit in SLP(C) No. 13401/2018. The same cannot be taken on record as counter affidavit filed by her is defective. Ld. Counsel shall within a period of two weeks cure the same.

Learned counsel has also filed an application for substitution to bring on record the Lrs. of deceased respondent No.2. Registry has pointed out defects in the said application. Learned counsel for petitioners shall, within a period of four weeks, rectify all such defects.

Service is complete on the remaining respondents. The respondents, who have already appeared but have not filed counter affidavit, shall file the same within a period of four weeks as a last chance.

In all other matters the appearing respondents who have not filed counter affidavit so far, shall within a period of four weeks as a last chance file the same.

Filing of the spare copies of the petitions be dispensed with in respect of unserved respondents. Registry to issue notice with utmost dispatch.

List these matters again on 07.4.2020.

RAJIV KALRA Registrar

MG