Abhinav Thapar vs. Union Of India

Court:Supreme Court of India
Judge:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
Case Status:Pending
Order Date:22 Apr 2021
CNR:SCIN010173302021

AI Summary

Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order

Original Order Copy

Get a certified copy of this order

Download True Copy

Order Text

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (C) NO.3/2021

IN RE : DISTRIBUTION OF ESSENTIAL SUPPLIES AND SERVICES DURING PANDEMIC

O R D E R

The situation in various parts of the country is grim. There seems to be a sudden surge in the number of covid patients and mortality. Other than vaccination which is prophylactic in nature, covid can be treated only be some drugs such as Remdesivir. Oxygen to the patients is also said to be an essential part of the treatment.

Drugs, oxygen and vaccination availability and distribution are being carried out by Governments including the Central government according to protocols established by the health authorities.

Nonetheless, it seems that a certain amount of panic has been generated and people have invoked the jurisdiction of several High Courts in the country seeking various reliefs such as Delhi, Bombay, Sikkim, M.P., Calcutta, Allahabad and Gujarat. The High Courts have passed certain orders which may have the effect of accelerating and prioritising the services to a certain set of people and slowing down the availability of these resources to certain other groups whether the groups are Signature Not Verified

Digitally signed by Sanjay Kumar Date: 2021.04.22 19:04:43 IST Reason:

local, regional or otherwise.

Prima facie**, we are inclined to take the view that the distribution of these essential services and supplies must be done in an even handed manner according to the advice of the health authorities which undoubtedly take into account relevant factors like severity, susceptibility, the number of people affected and the local availability of resources.**

We expect the Central Government to place before this Court a national plan for dealing with the above services and supplies during Pandemic.

In these circumstances, we direct that notices be issued to the Union Government, the State Governments/Union Territories and the parties, who appeared to have approached the High Courts to show cause why uniform orders be not passed by this Court in relation to

a) Supply of oxygen;

b) Supply of essential drugs;

c) Method and manner of vaccination; and

d) Declaration of lockdown.

Prima facie, we are also of the opinion that the Central government should respond on the following -

1. Report on the existence or otherwise and requirement of setting up of a coordinating body that would consider allocation of the above resources in a consultative manner (with the involvement of concerned States and Union

2

Territories).

2. Considering declaration of essential medicines and medical equipment including the above articles as essential commodities in relation to COVID.

3. In respect of coordination of logistical support for inter-State and Intra-State transportation and distribution of the above resources.

The notice shall be made returnable tomorrow. Shri Harish Salve, learned Senior Counsel is appointed as Amicus Curiae to assist the Court in the matter. He shall be assisted by Ms. Anuradha Dutt, learned Advocate.

List the matter tomorrow at 11 am.

....................CJI [S.A. BOBDE]

.....................J [L. NAGESWARA RAO]

.....................J [S. RAVINDRA BHAT]

NEW DELHI; APRIL 22, 2021. ITEM NO.302 Court No.1 (Video Conferencing) SECTION PIL-W

S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (C) NO.3/2021

IN RE : DISTRIBUTION OF ESSENTIAL SUPPLIES AND SERVICES DURING PANDEMIC

(FOR ADMISSION)

Date : 22-04-2021 This petition was taken up suo moto for hearing today.

CORAM :

HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE L. NAGESWARA RAO HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT

By Courts Motion

Counsel for the parties

  • Mr. Tushar Mehta, Ld. SG Mr. Rajat Mehta, Adv. Mr. Kanu Agrawal, Adv. Mr. B.V. Balaram Das, AOR
  • Mr. Harish Salve, Sr. Adv.
  • Ms. Anuradha Dutt, Adv.

UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following O R D E R

Let notices be issued to the Union Government, the State Governments/Union Territories and the parties, who appeared to have approached the High Courts to show cause why uniform orders be not passed by this Court, in terms of the signed order.

List the matter tomorrow i.e. 23.04.2021 at 11 am.

(SANJAY KUMAR-II) (PRADEEP KUMAR) ASTT. REGISTRAR-cum-PS BRANCH OFFICER (Signed Order is placed on the file)

Share This Order

Case History of Orders

Order(57) - 5 Jan 2022

ROP

Click to view

Order(56) - 10 Dec 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(55) - 8 Nov 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(54) - 8 Oct 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(53) - 9 Aug 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(52) - 23 Jul 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(27) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(28) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(29) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(30) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(31) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(32) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(33) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(34) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(35) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(36) - 31 May 2021

Judgement - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(37) - 31 May 2021

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(38) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(39) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(40) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(41) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(42) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(43) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(44) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(45) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(46) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(47) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(48) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(49) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(50) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(51) - 31 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(26) - 6 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(25) - 5 May 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(19) - 30 Apr 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(20) - 30 Apr 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(21) - 30 Apr 2021

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(22) - 30 Apr 2021

Judgement - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(23) - 30 Apr 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(24) - 30 Apr 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(18) - 27 Apr 2021

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(17) - 23 Apr 2021

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(16) - 22 Apr 2021

ROP - of Main Case

Viewing

Order(15) - 15 Feb 2021

ROP

Click to view

Order(14) - 26 Nov 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(13) - 24 Nov 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(12) - 26 Oct 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(11) - 31 Aug 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(10) - 5 Aug 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(9) - 27 Jul 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(8) - 23 Jul 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(7) - 20 Jul 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(6) - 14 Jul 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(5) - 17 Jun 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(3) - 5 Jun 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(4) - 5 Jun 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(2) - 27 May 2020

ROP

Click to view

Order(1) - 30 Apr 2020

ROP

Click to view
Similar Case Search

Same Parties

Abhinav Thapar vs Union Of IndiaAbhinav ThaparUnion Of IndiaUnion Of India Ministry Of Health And Family Welfare Govt. Of IndiaThe State Of Andhra Pradesh Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Arunachal Pradesh Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryAssam Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryBihar Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Chhattisgarh Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Goa Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Gujarat Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Haryana Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Himachal Pradesh Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Jharkhand Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Karnataka Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Kerala Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Madhya Pradesh Health And Family Welfare Department Additional Chief SecrettaryThe State Of Maharashtra Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Manipur Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Meghalaya Health And Family Welfare Department Additional Chief SecrettaryThe State Of Mizoram Health And Family Welfare Department Commissioner And SecretaryThe State Of Nagaland Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Odisha Health And Family Welfare Department Commissioner Cum SecretaryThe State Of Punjab Health And Family Welfare Department Additional Chief SecrettaryThe State Of Rajasthan Health And Family Welfare Department Additional Chief SecrettaryThe State Of Sikkim Health And Family Welfare Department Commissioner Cum SecretaryThe State Of Tamil Nadu Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Telangana Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Tripura Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Uttar Pradesh Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Uttarakhand Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of West Bengal Health And Family Welfare Department Additional Chief SecrettaryThe Union Territory Of Andaman Nicobar Island Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe Union Territory Of Chandigarh Health And Family Welfare Department Home And Principal SecretaryUt Of Delhi Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryU. T. Of Jammu And Kashmir Medical, Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryU. T. Of Ladakh Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe Union Territory Of Lakshadweep Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe Union Territory Of Puducherry Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryUt Of Dadra And Nagar Haveli And Daman And Diu Public Health And Family Welfare Department Secretary

Search in District Courts Data

Abhinav ThaparUnion Of IndiaUnion Of India Ministry Of Health And Family Welfare Govt. Of IndiaThe State Of Andhra Pradesh Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Arunachal Pradesh Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryAssam Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryBihar Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Chhattisgarh Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Goa Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Gujarat Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Haryana Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Himachal Pradesh Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Jharkhand Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Karnataka Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Kerala Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Madhya Pradesh Health And Family Welfare Department Additional Chief SecrettaryThe State Of Maharashtra Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Manipur Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Meghalaya Health And Family Welfare Department Additional Chief SecrettaryThe State Of Mizoram Health And Family Welfare Department Commissioner And SecretaryThe State Of Nagaland Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Odisha Health And Family Welfare Department Commissioner Cum SecretaryThe State Of Punjab Health And Family Welfare Department Additional Chief SecrettaryThe State Of Rajasthan Health And Family Welfare Department Additional Chief SecrettaryThe State Of Sikkim Health And Family Welfare Department Commissioner Cum SecretaryThe State Of Tamil Nadu Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Telangana Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Tripura Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of Uttar Pradesh Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe State Of Uttarakhand Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe State Of West Bengal Health And Family Welfare Department Additional Chief SecrettaryThe Union Territory Of Andaman Nicobar Island Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe Union Territory Of Chandigarh Health And Family Welfare Department Home And Principal SecretaryUt Of Delhi Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryU. T. Of Jammu And Kashmir Medical, Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryU. T. Of Ladakh Health And Family Welfare Department Principal SecretaryThe Union Territory Of Lakshadweep Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryThe Union Territory Of Puducherry Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryUt Of Dadra And Nagar Haveli And Daman And Diu Public Health And Family Welfare Department SecretaryAdvocate Srisatya MohantyAdvocate Joseph Aristotle S.Advocate Deepanwita PriyankaAdvocate Pukhrambam Ramesh KumarAdvocate Sandeep Kumar JhaAdvocate Gurmeet Singh MakkerAdvocate Shreekant Neelappa TerdalAdvocate Anil NagAdvocate D. L. ChidanandaAdvocate Ankita SharmaAdvocate Amrish KumarAdvocate Anando MukherjeeAdvocate Misha RohatgiAdvocate Avijit Mani TripathiAdvocate Chanchal Kumar GanguliAdvocate Aravindh S.Advocate Mahfooz Ahsan NazkiAdvocate Diksha RaiAdvocate Niranjana SinghAdvocate Surjendu Sankar DasAdvocate Pallavi LangarAdvocate Harshad V. HameedAdvocate Inal Gopal ElkerAdvocate Sachin PatilAdvocate Shovan MishraAdvocate Sameer AbhyankarAdvocate S.. Udaya Kumar SagarAdvocate Vanshaja ShuklaAdvocate Disha Singh