Mohansinh Laxmamsinh Solanki vs. Union Of India Ministry Of Home Affairs Secretary
Court:Supreme Court of India
Judge:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Ajay Rastogi
Case Status:Pending
Order Date:20 May 2022
CNR:SCIN010166302005
AI Summary
Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order
Order Issued After Hearing
Purpose:
Fixed Date by Court
Before:
Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Ajay Rastogi
Stage:
Land Laws And Agricultural Tenancies : Others
Remarks:
List On (Date) [18-03-2020]
Listed On:
13 Feb 2020
In:
Judge
Category:
UNKNOWN
Original Order Copy
Get a certified copy of this order
Order Text
ITEM NO.53 COURT NO.4 SECTION IX
S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
I.A. No.170382/2021 In Civil Appeal No.1479/2006
DIVYAGNAKUMARI HARISINH PARMAR (DEAD) & ORS. Appellant(s)
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ORS. Respondent(s)
(With IA No.170382/2021 - MODIFICATION)
Date : 20-05-2022 These matters were called on for hearing today.
CORAM :
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE D.Y. CHANDRACHUD HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA
| For Appellant(s) | Mr. Anish R. Shah, Adv.<br>Mr. Shivaji M. Jadhav, AOR<br>Mr. Brij Kishor Sah, Adv. |
|---|---|
| For Respondent(s) | Mr. Tushar Mehta, SG<br>Mr. Vikramjit Banerjee, ASG<br>Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, Adv.<br>Ms. Shradha Deshmukh, Adv.<br>Ms. Deepanwita Priyanka, Adv.<br>Mr. Anirudh Bakhru, Adv.<br>Mr. Ankur Talwar, Adv.<br>Mr. Siddhartha Sinha, Adv.<br>Mr. Arun Kumar Yadav, Adv.<br>Ms. Visaka Murty, Adv.<br>Mr. Harish Pandey, Adv.<br>Mr. Amrish Kumar, AOR<br>Mr. Arvind Kumar Sharma, AOR |
1
Mr. Tushar Mehta, SG Mr. Pavan Kr. Chaturvedi, Adv. Mr. Nitish Kr. Singh, Adv. Mr. Smarhar Singh, AOR
UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following O R D E R
- 1 Mr Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General states that the acquisition has been completed for the stretch of land comprised in the Delhi – Mumbai Expressway. There is a dispute between the appellant and the Government over the ownership of the land and the resolution of the dispute will in turn determine who is entitled to the compensation payable for acquisition of the land.
- 2 At this stage, National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) has sought modification of the interim orders dated 12 September 2005 and 24 September 2006 to the extent that the orders of status quo should not come in the way of NHAI taking over of possession of the land in question, which is described as follows:
| Sl.<br>No. | Village | Survey No | Name | Class of<br>Land | Total Area | Area<br>Acquired |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Naroli | 940/1 | Shri Sarkar<br>Premabhai<br>Bavabhai | Agri. | 01-41-00 | 11339 |
| 2 | Naroli | 966 | Shri Sarkar<br>Jivanbhai<br>Dahyabhai | Agri. | 01-06-00 | 8925 |
| 3 | Naroli | 1010/2 | Shri Sarkar<br>Dalpatsinh<br>Bhanabhai<br>Chauhan and<br>Others | Agri. | 01-17-00 | 1889 |
CA 1479/2006
| 4 | Naroli | 1027/P1 | Jashwantsinh<br>Mohansinh<br>Parmar | Agri. | 01-29-00 | 3091 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | Naroli | 1028 | Ranchhodsinh<br>Govansinh<br>Parmar<br>Thakorsinh<br>Govansinh<br>Parmar<br>Dalpat Govan<br>Parmar<br>Bhaniben<br>Bhagwansinh<br>Parmar &<br>Others | Agri. | 01-24-00 | 2337 |
| 6 | Naroli | 1029 | Laxmanbhai<br>Morarbhai<br>Valiben<br>Harisinh<br>Parmar and<br>Others | Agri. | 01-17-00 | 1815 |
| 7 | Athal | 335/1/1P1 | Shree Sarkar<br>Lalitaben<br>Chunilal Shah<br>Mahendra<br>Kumar<br>Chunilal Shah<br>Prafulchandra<br>Chunilal Shah<br>and Others | Agri. | 08-67-00 | 25729 |
| 8 | Kharadpada | 238/1P (Plot<br>No 24) | Malji Bhima | Agri. | 01-23-00 | 3343 |
| 9 | Kharadpada | 238/1P (Plot<br>No 25) | Bhadia Mariya | Agri. | 01-00-00 | 4928 |
| 10 | Kharadpada | 240/P (Plot No<br>32) | Vansu Raghla<br>Valvi | Agri. | 01-13-00 | 278 |
| 11 | Kharadpada | 240/P (Plot No<br>33/1) | Bablabhai<br>Somji Valvi<br>Pravinbhai<br>Somji Valvi<br>Prakash Somji<br>Valvi | Agri. | 00-20-00 | 2000 |
| 12 | Kharadpada | 240/P (Plot No Bablabhai | Agri. | 00-87-00 | 8182 |
CA 1479/2006
| 33/2) | Somji Valvi<br>Pravinbhai<br>Somji Valvi<br>Prakash Somji<br>Valvi Valvi | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 | Kharadpada | 240/P (Plot No<br>34) | Vestabhai<br>Ramlabhai | Agri. | 01-09-00 | 4612 |
| 78468 |
- 3 NHAI is executing a project of national importance. The Solicitor General stated that there is an urgent requirement for carrying out the remaining work before the monsoons commence. In this backdrop, NHAI is permitted to take over the possession of the above land and to that extent, the earlier orders of status quo passed by this Court shall stand modified.
- 4 The Interlocutory Application is accordingly disposed of.
(CHETAN KUMAR) (ANJU KAPOOR) A.R.-cum-P.S. Court Master
Share This Order
Case History of Orders
Similar Case Search
Same Parties
Mohansinh Laxmamsinh Solanki vs Union Of India Ministry Of Home Affairs SecretaryMohansinh Laxmamsinh SolankiRamubhai Laxmansinh SolankiBabubhai Laxmansinh SolankiMohansinh Ratanji Solanki1 Bhikhubhai Mohansinh SolankiDahiben ChhibabhaiNarsinh Ramabhai Solanki (D) Through Lrs1 Jashodaben (D) Through Lrs1. 1 Vinuben1. 2 Jyotiben R. Solanki1. 3 Manishaben R. Solanki1. 4 Sulochananben R. Solanki1. 5 Harendrasingh Narsinh Solanki1. 6 Miteshkumar H. Solanki1. 7 Hemlataben H. Solanki2 Rameshchanra Narsinh Solanki (Dead) Through Lrs2. 1 Vinuben2. 2 Jyotinen Rameshchanra2. 3 Manishaben Shailendra Sinh Desai2. 4 Sulochandaben3 Harendrasing Narsinh SolankiBalvantsinh BhikhubhaiBalkamlabenBai SurajbenBhikhubhai Virsinh Rathod (Since Deceased Through Lrs. )1 Kamlaben2 Balvantsinh3 Laxmiben4 Bhaniben5 Deviben6 Manjulaben7 ManibenSurendrasinh Chhittusinh ChauhanChandaben Chittusinh ChauhanPratapsingh Vallabhaibhai Desai (Since Deceased Through Lrs. )1 Jitendra Sinh2 Harendrasinh3 Natwarsinh4 Savitaben5 Pushpaben6 PadmabenRamsinh Narsinh DesaiChandanben1 Rajendrasinh2 Virmatiben3 Pratibhaben4 Madhubalaben5 Pravinaben6 Motisinh Narsinh Desai (D) Through Lrs6. 1 Chandniben Motisinh Desai6. 2 Rameshbhai Motisinh Desai6. 3 Ishwarkumar Motisinh DesaiDalpatsinh Kalidas DesaiKalidas Hirabhai Desai1 Devkiben Kalidas2 Babubhai3 Mohansinh4 Mahendrasinh5 Dalpatsinh @ Devendrasinh6 Tejuben7 Savitaben8 Dhanuben9 Sarojben10 Kanchanben11 Mohansinh Kalidas DesaiBai GangaShantaben (Since Deceased Through Lrs)1 Mahendrasinh1. 1 Ishwarsinh1. 2 Hiraben1. 3 Kusumben1. 4 Savitaben1. 5 VasantibenBhagwansinh G. Parmar Since (D) Through Lrs2 Rajendrasinh3 Bhaniben4 GitabenRanchhodbhai Govinbhai Parmar1 Ishwarsinh2 Siremdrasinj3 Jagdishbhai4 Deviben5 Thakorebhai Govanbhai ParmarDalpatbhai Govanbhai ParmarBai DevibenHarisinh Marorsinh Parmar (Since Deceased Through Lrs. )1 Valiben2 Dalpatsinh3 Shardaben4 Mohansinh5 VinubenLaxmansinh Morarbhai ParmarUmedsinh Bhikuhai Parmar 9since Deceased Through Lrs. )1 Babubhai2 NatwarsinhRamsinh Bhikhabhai Parmar1 Nagniben4 Virmatiben5 Nayanaben6 Bhartiben7 KanchanbenBhikhubhai Mohanbhai Parmar (Since Died Through Lrs. )2 Kalpeshkumar3 Kanchanben4 Kushumben5 Nitaben6 RajeshshreebenBhanabhai Danabhai Chauhan (D) Through Lrs1 Chhibubhai3 Arvindsinh4 Natwarsinh5 ShaileshsinhAbhubhai Danabhai Chauhan (D) Through Lrs1 Jaswant Sinh Abhesinh Chauhan2 Fatesinh Abhesinh ChauhanUnion Of India Ministry Of Home Affairs SecretaryThe Adminsitration Of Dadra And Nagar Haveli Administered By Lt. GovernorThe CollectorManiben Gulssinh Parmar Since (D) Through Lrs1 Ishwarsingh Gulabsinh Parmar2 Harendrasingh Gulabsinh3 Laxmiben Narpatsinh4 Harigangaben Indrasinh Vasiya5 Narmadaben Kishorsinh6 Bhadraben Bharatsinh7 Indiraben JagdishsinhBhikhubhai GomansinhBai Saraswatiben ((D) Through Lrs1 Sudhaben2 Nilimaben
Lawyers
Judges
Search in District Courts Data
Mohansinh Laxmamsinh SolankiRamubhai Laxmansinh SolankiBabubhai Laxmansinh SolankiMohansinh Ratanji Solanki1 Bhikhubhai Mohansinh SolankiDahiben ChhibabhaiNarsinh Ramabhai Solanki (D) Through Lrs1 Jashodaben (D) Through Lrs1. 1 Vinuben1. 2 Jyotiben R. Solanki1. 3 Manishaben R. Solanki1. 4 Sulochananben R. Solanki1. 5 Harendrasingh Narsinh Solanki1. 6 Miteshkumar H. Solanki1. 7 Hemlataben H. Solanki2 Rameshchanra Narsinh Solanki (Dead) Through Lrs2. 1 Vinuben2. 2 Jyotinen Rameshchanra2. 3 Manishaben Shailendra Sinh Desai2. 4 Sulochandaben3 Harendrasing Narsinh SolankiBalvantsinh BhikhubhaiBalkamlabenBai SurajbenBhikhubhai Virsinh Rathod (Since Deceased Through Lrs. )1 Kamlaben2 Balvantsinh3 Laxmiben4 Bhaniben5 Deviben6 Manjulaben7 ManibenSurendrasinh Chhittusinh ChauhanChandaben Chittusinh ChauhanPratapsingh Vallabhaibhai Desai (Since Deceased Through Lrs. )1 Jitendra Sinh2 Harendrasinh3 Natwarsinh4 Savitaben5 Pushpaben6 PadmabenRamsinh Narsinh DesaiChandanben1 Rajendrasinh2 Virmatiben3 Pratibhaben4 Madhubalaben5 Pravinaben6 Motisinh Narsinh Desai (D) Through Lrs6. 1 Chandniben Motisinh Desai6. 2 Rameshbhai Motisinh Desai6. 3 Ishwarkumar Motisinh DesaiDalpatsinh Kalidas DesaiKalidas Hirabhai Desai1 Devkiben Kalidas2 Babubhai3 Mohansinh4 Mahendrasinh5 Dalpatsinh @ Devendrasinh6 Tejuben7 Savitaben8 Dhanuben9 Sarojben10 Kanchanben11 Mohansinh Kalidas DesaiBai GangaShantaben (Since Deceased Through Lrs)1 Mahendrasinh1. 1 Ishwarsinh1. 2 Hiraben1. 3 Kusumben1. 4 Savitaben1. 5 VasantibenBhagwansinh G. Parmar Since (D) Through Lrs2 Rajendrasinh3 Bhaniben4 GitabenRanchhodbhai Govinbhai Parmar1 Ishwarsinh2 Siremdrasinj3 Jagdishbhai4 Deviben5 Thakorebhai Govanbhai ParmarDalpatbhai Govanbhai ParmarBai DevibenHarisinh Marorsinh Parmar (Since Deceased Through Lrs. )1 Valiben2 Dalpatsinh3 Shardaben4 Mohansinh5 VinubenLaxmansinh Morarbhai ParmarUmedsinh Bhikuhai Parmar 9since Deceased Through Lrs. )1 Babubhai2 NatwarsinhRamsinh Bhikhabhai Parmar1 Nagniben4 Virmatiben5 Nayanaben6 Bhartiben7 KanchanbenBhikhubhai Mohanbhai Parmar (Since Died Through Lrs. )2 Kalpeshkumar3 Kanchanben4 Kushumben5 Nitaben6 RajeshshreebenBhanabhai Danabhai Chauhan (D) Through Lrs1 Chhibubhai3 Arvindsinh4 Natwarsinh5 ShaileshsinhAbhubhai Danabhai Chauhan (D) Through Lrs1 Jaswant Sinh Abhesinh Chauhan2 Fatesinh Abhesinh ChauhanUnion Of India Ministry Of Home Affairs SecretaryThe Adminsitration Of Dadra And Nagar Haveli Administered By Lt. GovernorThe CollectorManiben Gulssinh Parmar Since (D) Through Lrs1 Ishwarsingh Gulabsinh Parmar2 Harendrasingh Gulabsinh3 Laxmiben Narpatsinh4 Harigangaben Indrasinh Vasiya5 Narmadaben Kishorsinh6 Bhadraben Bharatsinh7 Indiraben JagdishsinhBhikhubhai GomansinhBai Saraswatiben ((D) Through Lrs1 Sudhaben2 NilimabenAdvocate Shivaji M. Jadhav