State Of Tamil Nadu Public Works Department Through The Secretary vs. The State Of Karnataka Government Of Karnataka . By Its Chief Secretary

Court:Supreme Court of India
Judge:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
Case Status:Disposed
Order Date:8 Aug 2014
CNR:SCIN010135692007

AI Summary

Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order

Order Issued After Hearing

Purpose:

Case Registered

Listed On:

7 May 2007

Original Order Copy

Get a certified copy of this order

Download True Copy

Order Text

LISTED ON: 08.08.2014 BEFORE COURT NO: 1 ITEM NO: 2

SECTION : XIV

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION NO. 1 CIVIL APPEAL No. 2453 OF 2007

WITH

INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION Nos.2,4,10,11,14,15,16, 17 & 18

(Applications for directions/modification by Mr.Ajit S. Bhasma, Advocate /Revocation/early hearing and application for taking on record additional documents)

AND

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2456 OF 2007

WITH

INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION NOS. 2,4 AND 6

(Application for directions)

STATE OF KARNATAKA ETC. ETC ...APPELLANT VERSUS

STATE OF T.NADU & ORS ETC. ETC. ...RESPONDENTS

OFFICE REPORT

The appeals above mentioned were listed before the Hon'ble Court on 18/10/11 with an office report dated 17th October, 2011 and copy of the Court's order dated 18/10/11 has been included in common volume of Court's record of proceedings.

CIVIL APPEAL No.2453/07

It is submitted that there are four respondents in this appeal. All the respondents are represented by their respective advocates.

It is further submitted that Mr. V. N. Raghupathy, Advocate has on 21.10.2011 filed counter affidavit in I.A. No. 11 and he has on 03.01.2013 filed an application for taking on record additional documents. Copies of the same have been placed with appeal Paper Books.

It is also submitted that Mr. Ajit S. Bhasma, Advocate has on 4.2.2011 filed an application for recall/modification and restoration of Court's Order dated 18.10.2011 passed in I.A. No. 13/2009 (registered as I.A. No. 14). Copy of the same has been placed with I.A. No. 13 Paper Books.

It is lastly submitted that Mr. V. G. Pragasan, Advocate has on 10.1.2012 filed an application for revocation with affidavit, Mr. B. Balaji, Advocate has on 21.3.2012 filed an application for directions on behalf of State of Tamil Nadu and Mr. V. N. Raghupathy, Advocate has on 23.1.2013 filed an application for urgent directions of early listing of the Civil Appeal. All I.As. have been registered as 15 to 17 and copies of the same have been placed with appeal Paper Books.

CIVIL APPEAL No.2456/07

It is submitted that there are three respondents in this appeal and all are represented by their respective advocates. It is further submitted that Mr. B. Balaji, Advocate has on 17.4.2012 filed application for directions (registered as I.A. No. 4) and the same has been placed with appeal Paper Books.

It is also submitted that I.A. No. 7 filed by Mr. B. Balaji, Advocate on 11.11.2013 was listed before the Hon'ble Court on 03.12.2013 when the Court was pleased to pass the following Order:-

"We do not think that there is any urgency for consideration of the prayers made by the applicant/appellant – State of Tamil Nadu by means of this application.

In our view, the application can wait and may be heard along with the Civil Appeal.

List Interlocutory Application No. 7 of 2013 along with Civil Appeal.

The respondents, State of Karnataka as well as Union of India, may file their response to Interlocutory Application No. 7 of 2013 within four weeks."

Copy of I.A. Nos. 6 & 7 have been placed with appeal paper books.

It is further submitted that Counsel for the Respondent No.1 has on 04.01.2014 filed an affidavit in IA No. 7 and others have not filed reply, so far. Counsel for the appellant has on 06.01.2014 filed list of events. Copies of the same have been placed with appeal paper books.

It is also submitted that Counsel for the appellant has on 25/6/2013 filed Contempt Petition (Civil) alongwith "Annexure A to I" with Vakalatnama and memo of appearance in the matter above mentioned, registered as Contempt Petition(Civil) No.225/2013. Copy of the same has been placed with I.A. paper books for kind perusal of the Hon'ble Court.

It is lastly submitted that the instant appeal has been tagged with Civil Appeal No. 2453 of 2007 (Main matter). Instead of sending Original records in the said appeals, letter dated 22.6.2009 has been received from Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal, Govt. of India, Ministry of Water resources stating therein that Original Record consists of statement of cases, counter affidavits and rejoinders followed by evidence and final arguments which run into thousands of pages. Civil Appeal No. 2454/2007 is related with the Section XII.

The appeals above mentioned are listed before the Hon'ble Court with this office report.

DATED THIS, THE 8th DAY OF January, 2014.

DEPUTY REGISTRAR

Copy to:-

1.Mr. V. N. Raghupathy, Advocate
2.Mr. R. Nedumaran, Advocate
3.Mr. G. Prakash, Advocate
4.Mr. V.G. Pragasam, Advocate
5.Mr. D.S. Mahra, Advocate
6.Mr. Rajesh Mahale, Advocate
7.Mr. Ajit S. Bhasme, Advocate

DEPUTY REGISTRAR

MKR/P-1

Share This Order

Case History of Orders

Order(104) - 5 Dec 2018

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(103) - 3 Apr 2018

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(101) - 16 Feb 2018

Judgement - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(102) - 16 Feb 2018

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(100) - 20 Sept 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(99) - 19 Sept 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(98) - 14 Sept 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(97) - 13 Sept 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(96) - 12 Sept 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(95) - 7 Sept 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(94) - 6 Sept 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(93) - 5 Sept 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(92) - 31 Aug 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(91) - 30 Aug 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(90) - 17 Aug 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(89) - 16 Aug 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(88) - 10 Aug 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(87) - 9 Aug 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(86) - 3 Aug 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(85) - 2 Aug 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(84) - 1 Aug 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(83) - 27 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(82) - 26 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(81) - 25 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(80) - 20 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(79) - 19 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(78) - 18 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(77) - 13 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(76) - 12 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(75) - 11 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(72) - 21 Mar 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(73) - 21 Mar 2017

Office Report - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(74) - 21 Mar 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(68) - 7 Feb 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(69) - 7 Feb 2017

Office Report - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(70) - 7 Feb 2017

Office Report

Click to view

Order(71) - 7 Feb 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(66) - 4 Jan 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(67) - 4 Jan 2017

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(65) - 15 Dec 2016

Office Report - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(63) - 9 Dec 2016

Judgement - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(64) - 9 Dec 2016

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(60) - 19 Oct 2016

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(61) - 19 Oct 2016

Office Report - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(62) - 19 Oct 2016

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(57) - 18 Oct 2016

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(58) - 18 Oct 2016

Office Report - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(59) - 18 Oct 2016

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(54) - 4 Oct 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(55) - 4 Oct 2016

Office Report

Click to view

Order(56) - 4 Oct 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(52) - 3 Oct 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(53) - 3 Oct 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(49) - 30 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(50) - 30 Sept 2016

Office Report

Click to view

Order(51) - 30 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(45) - 27 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(46) - 27 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(47) - 27 Sept 2016

Office Report

Click to view

Order(48) - 27 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(42) - 20 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(43) - 20 Sept 2016

Office Report

Click to view

Order(44) - 20 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(40) - 12 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(41) - 12 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(38) - 6 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(39) - 6 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(35) - 5 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(36) - 5 Sept 2016

Office Report

Click to view

Order(37) - 5 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(32) - 2 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(33) - 2 Sept 2016

Office Report

Click to view

Order(34) - 2 Sept 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(30) - 26 Aug 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(31) - 26 Aug 2016

ROP

Click to view

Order(29) - 29 Jul 2016

Office Report - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(28) - 28 Jul 2016

Office Report - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(26) - 15 Jul 2016

Office Report - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(27) - 15 Jul 2016

Office Report

Click to view

Order(24) - 28 Mar 2016

Office Report - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(25) - 28 Mar 2016

Office Report

Click to view

Order(22) - 8 Aug 2014

Office Report - of Main Case

Viewing

Order(23) - 8 Aug 2014

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(21) - 3 Dec 2013

ROP

Click to view

Order(20) - 27 Nov 2013

ROP

Click to view

Order(19) - 5 Aug 2013

ROP

Click to view

Order(18) - 5 Jul 2013

ROP

Click to view

Order(17) - 1 Jul 2013

ROP

Click to view

Order(16) - 10 May 2013

ROP

Click to view

Order(15) - 7 May 2013

ROP

Click to view

Order(14) - 22 Apr 2013

ROP

Click to view

Order(13) - 8 Apr 2013

ROP

Click to view

Order(12) - 18 Oct 2011

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(11) - 22 Sept 2011

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(10) - 6 May 2010

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(9) - 12 Aug 2009

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(8) - 12 May 2009

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(7) - 28 Jul 2008

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(6) - 28 Apr 2008

ROP

Click to view

Order(4) - 28 Mar 2008

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(5) - 28 Mar 2008

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(3) - 1 Feb 2008

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view

Order(2) - 17 May 2007

ROP

Click to view

Order(1) - 7 May 2007

ROP - of Main Case

Click to view