Pragya Traders Through Its Proprietor Hari Mohan Agrawal vs. State Of U. P. Through Its Principal Secretary
AI Summary
Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order
Original Order Copy
Get a certified copy of this order
Order Text
\222ITEM NO.827 COURT NO.1 SECTION III S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s). 29549/2016 (Arising out of impugned final judgment and order dated 12/09/2016 in WT No. 654/2016 passed by the High Court Of Judicature at Allahabad) M/S GRASIM INDUSTRIES LTD., CHEMICAL DIVISION, RENUKOOT Petitioner(s) VERSUS STATE OF UP & ORS. Respondent(s) (With interim relief and office report) Date : 21/10/2016 This matter was mentioned today. CORAM : HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE D.Y. CHANDRACHUD HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE L. NAGESWARA RAO For Petitioner(s) Mr. Pankaj Bhatia, Adv. Ms. Bharti Tyagi, Adv. For Respondent(s) UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following O R D E R Post this matter in the next week before an appropriate Bench. (Ashok Raj Singh) (Veena Khera) Court Master Court Master
Share This Order
Order(477) - 15 Sept 2017
Judgement - of Main Case
Order(478) - 15 Sept 2017
ROP - of Main Case
Order(476) - 3 Aug 2017
ROP - of Main Case
Order(475) - 2 Aug 2017
ROP - of Main Case
Order(474) - 1 Aug 2017
ROP - of Main Case
Order(473) - 27 Jul 2017
ROP - of Main Case
Order(472) - 26 Jul 2017
ROP - of Main Case
Order(471) - 25 Jul 2017
ROP - of Main Case
Order(470) - 3 Jul 2017
ROP - of Main Case
Order(467) - 4 May 2017
ROP
Order(468) - 4 May 2017
Office Report
Order(469) - 4 May 2017
ROP
Order(464) - 10 Apr 2017
ROP
Order(465) - 10 Apr 2017
Office Report
Order(466) - 10 Apr 2017
ROP
Order(461) - 27 Mar 2017
ROP
Order(462) - 27 Mar 2017
Office Report
Order(463) - 27 Mar 2017
ROP
Order(458) - 24 Mar 2017
ROP
Order(459) - 24 Mar 2017
Office Report
Order(460) - 24 Mar 2017
ROP
Order(456) - 22 Feb 2017
ROP
Order(457) - 22 Feb 2017
ROP
Order(453) - 9 Feb 2017
ROP
Order(454) - 9 Feb 2017
Office Report
Order(455) - 9 Feb 2017
ROP
Order(444) - 5 Dec 2016
ROP
Order(445) - 5 Dec 2016
ROP
Order(446) - 5 Dec 2016
ROP
Order(447) - 5 Dec 2016
Office Report
Order(448) - 5 Dec 2016
Office Report
Order(449) - 5 Dec 2016
Office Report
Order(450) - 5 Dec 2016
ROP
Order(451) - 5 Dec 2016
ROP
Order(452) - 5 Dec 2016
ROP
Order(442) - 30 Nov 2016
ROP
Order(443) - 30 Nov 2016
ROP
Order(439) - 28 Nov 2016
ROP
Order(440) - 28 Nov 2016
Office Report
Order(441) - 28 Nov 2016
ROP
Order(436) - 15 Nov 2016
ROP
Order(437) - 15 Nov 2016
Office Report
Order(438) - 15 Nov 2016
ROP
Order(434) - 28 Oct 2016
ROP
Order(435) - 28 Oct 2016
ROP
Order(432) - 21 Oct 2016
ROP
Order(433) - 21 Oct 2016
ROP
Order(429) - 3 Oct 2016
ROP
Order(430) - 3 Oct 2016
Office Report
Order(431) - 3 Oct 2016
ROP
Order(427) - 20 Sept 2016
ROP - of Main Case
Order(428) - 20 Sept 2016
ROP - of Main Case
Order(425) - 9 Aug 2016
ROP
Order(426) - 9 Aug 2016
ROP
Order(423) - 26 Apr 2016
ROP - of Main Case
Order(424) - 26 Apr 2016
ROP - of Main Case
Order(420) - 7 Apr 2016
ROP
Order(421) - 7 Apr 2016
Office Report
Order(422) - 7 Apr 2016
ROP
Order(416) - 10 Feb 2016
ROP
Order(417) - 10 Feb 2016
ROP - of Main Case
Order(418) - 10 Feb 2016
ROP
Order(419) - 10 Feb 2016
ROP - of Main Case
Order(412) - 9 Feb 2016
ROP - of Main Case
Order(413) - 9 Feb 2016
ROP - of Main Case
Order(414) - 9 Feb 2016
ROP - of Main Case
Order(415) - 9 Feb 2016
ROP - of Main Case
Order(407) - 29 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(408) - 29 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(409) - 29 Jan 2016
Office Report
Order(410) - 29 Jan 2016
Office Report
Order(411) - 29 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(404) - 21 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(405) - 21 Jan 2016
Office Report
Order(406) - 21 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(401) - 8 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(402) - 8 Jan 2016
Office Report
Order(403) - 8 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(398) - 11 Dec 2015
ROP
Order(399) - 11 Dec 2015
Office Report
Order(400) - 11 Dec 2015
ROP
Order(395) - 4 Nov 2015
ROP
Order(396) - 4 Nov 2015
Office Report
Order(397) - 4 Nov 2015
ROP
Order(394) - 19 Aug 2015
ROP
Order(391) - 18 Aug 2015
ROP
Order(392) - 18 Aug 2015
Office Report
Order(393) - 18 Aug 2015
ROP
Order(389) - 17 Aug 2015
ROP
Order(390) - 17 Aug 2015
ROP
Order(388) - 1 May 2015
ROP
Order(386) - 27 Feb 2015
ROP
Order(387) - 27 Feb 2015
ROP
Order(384) - 25 Feb 2015
ROP - of Main Case
Order(385) - 25 Feb 2015
ROP - of Main Case
Order(382) - 19 Feb 2015
ROP - of Main Case
Order(383) - 19 Feb 2015
ROP - of Main Case
Order(380) - 5 Dec 2014
ROP
Order(381) - 5 Dec 2014
ROP
Order(377) - 4 Dec 2014
ROP
Order(378) - 4 Dec 2014
Office Report
Order(379) - 4 Dec 2014
ROP
Order(375) - 10 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(376) - 10 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(374) - 19 Sept 2014
Office Report
Order(371) - 17 Sept 2014
ROP
Order(372) - 17 Sept 2014
Office Report
Order(373) - 17 Sept 2014
ROP
Order(370) - 22 Aug 2014
Office Report
Order(369) - 21 Jul 2014
ROP
Order(368) - 14 Jul 2014
ROP
Order(367) - 7 Jul 2014
ROP
Order(366) - 9 May 2014
ROP
Order(365) - 7 May 2014
ROP
Order(364) - 29 Apr 2014
ROP
Order(363) - 28 Apr 2014
ROP
Order(362) - 25 Apr 2014
ROP
Order(361) - 15 Apr 2014
ROP
Order(360) - 31 Mar 2014
ROP
Order(358) - 28 Mar 2014
ROP
Order(359) - 28 Mar 2014
ROP
Order(357) - 26 Feb 2014
ROP
Order(356) - 4 Feb 2014
ROP
Order(355) - 3 Feb 2014
ROP
Order(353) - 27 Jan 2014
ROP
Order(354) - 27 Jan 2014
ROP
Order(352) - 13 Jan 2014
ROP
Order(351) - 17 Dec 2013
ROP
Order(350) - 9 Dec 2013
ROP
Order(349) - 19 Nov 2013
ROP
Order(348) - 18 Nov 2013
ROP
Order(346) - 12 Nov 2013
ROP
Order(347) - 12 Nov 2013
ROP - of Main Case
Order(345) - 31 Oct 2013
ROP
Order(344) - 4 Oct 2013
ROP
Order(343) - 1 Oct 2013
ROP
Order(342) - 30 Sept 2013
ROP
Order(340) - 23 Sept 2013
Office Report
Order(341) - 23 Sept 2013
ROP
Order(339) - 12 Sept 2013
ROP
Order(338) - 6 Sept 2013
ROP
Order(336) - 5 Sept 2013
Office Report
Order(337) - 5 Sept 2013
ROP
Order(335) - 29 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(333) - 26 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(334) - 26 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(331) - 23 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(332) - 23 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(329) - 22 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(330) - 22 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(328) - 21 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(326) - 16 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(327) - 16 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(325) - 13 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(318) - 12 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(319) - 12 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(320) - 12 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(321) - 12 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(322) - 12 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(323) - 12 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(324) - 12 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(313) - 8 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(314) - 8 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(315) - 8 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(316) - 8 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(317) - 8 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(312) - 2 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(311) - 30 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(309) - 29 Jul 2013
Office Report
Order(310) - 29 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(308) - 17 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(307) - 15 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(306) - 5 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(305) - 4 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(304) - 3 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(302) - 2 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(303) - 2 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(299) - 9 May 2013
ROP
Order(300) - 9 May 2013
ROP
Order(301) - 9 May 2013
ROP
Order(298) - 7 May 2013
ROP
Order(297) - 6 May 2013
ROP
Order(296) - 3 May 2013
ROP
Order(295) - 2 May 2013
ROP
Order(294) - 30 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(293) - 25 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(292) - 23 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(291) - 22 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(290) - 18 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(288) - 16 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(289) - 16 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(287) - 12 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(286) - 8 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(284) - 1 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(285) - 1 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(283) - 19 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(281) - 18 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(282) - 18 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(280) - 15 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(279) - 14 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(276) - 12 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(277) - 12 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(278) - 12 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(274) - 11 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(275) - 11 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(273) - 8 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(272) - 1 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(270) - 19 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(271) - 19 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(268) - 13 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(269) - 13 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(267) - 12 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(265) - 8 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(266) - 8 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(264) - 4 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(263) - 24 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(260) - 23 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(261) - 23 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(262) - 23 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(259) - 21 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(258) - 18 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(256) - 15 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(257) - 15 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(253) - 4 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(254) - 4 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(255) - 4 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(252) - 14 Dec 2012
ROP
Order(251) - 10 Dec 2012
ROP
Order(249) - 3 Dec 2012
ROP
Order(250) - 3 Dec 2012
ROP
Order(248) - 27 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(246) - 20 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(247) - 20 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(245) - 19 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(242) - 7 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(243) - 7 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(244) - 7 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(241) - 6 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(239) - 5 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(240) - 5 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(238) - 2 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(236) - 30 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(237) - 30 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(233) - 19 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(234) - 19 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(235) - 19 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(231) - 15 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(232) - 15 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(230) - 12 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(229) - 11 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(228) - 10 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(226) - 1 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(227) - 1 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(225) - 17 Sept 2012
ROP
Order(224) - 13 Sept 2012
ROP
Order(222) - 10 Sept 2012
ROP
Order(223) - 10 Sept 2012
ROP
Order(220) - 7 Sept 2012
ROP
Order(221) - 7 Sept 2012
ROP
Order(219) - 4 Sept 2012
ROP
Order(218) - 31 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(216) - 24 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(217) - 24 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(215) - 21 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(214) - 17 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(213) - 13 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(211) - 6 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(212) - 6 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(210) - 3 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(208) - 30 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(209) - 30 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(206) - 20 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(207) - 20 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(205) - 16 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(204) - 13 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(203) - 6 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(202) - 4 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(201) - 3 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(199) - 2 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(200) - 2 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(197) - 10 May 2012
ROP
Order(198) - 10 May 2012
ROP
Order(196) - 7 May 2012
ROP
Order(195) - 4 May 2012
ROP
Order(194) - 1 May 2012
ROP
Order(191) - 30 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(192) - 30 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(193) - 30 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(189) - 27 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(190) - 27 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(188) - 23 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(187) - 20 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(186) - 16 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(185) - 13 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(184) - 11 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(183) - 4 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(182) - 2 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(181) - 30 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(180) - 27 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(178) - 26 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(179) - 26 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(177) - 23 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(176) - 22 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(170) - 19 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(171) - 19 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(172) - 19 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(173) - 19 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(174) - 19 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(175) - 19 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(169) - 13 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(167) - 2 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(168) - 2 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(166) - 1 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(165) - 22 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(163) - 17 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(164) - 17 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(162) - 15 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(161) - 10 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(159) - 3 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(160) - 3 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(158) - 30 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(157) - 24 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(154) - 20 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(155) - 20 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(156) - 20 Jan 2012
ROP - of Main Case
Order(153) - 18 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(152) - 16 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(151) - 13 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(150) - 5 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(149) - 16 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(148) - 15 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(147) - 5 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(146) - 2 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(145) - 29 Nov 2011
ROP
Order(144) - 21 Nov 2011
ROP
Order(143) - 15 Nov 2011
ROP
Order(142) - 9 Nov 2011
ROP
Order(140) - 17 Oct 2011
ROP
Order(141) - 17 Oct 2011
ROP
Order(139) - 29 Sept 2011
ROP
Order(138) - 19 Sept 2011
ROP
Order(137) - 8 Sept 2011
ROP
Order(136) - 6 Sept 2011
ROP
Order(135) - 2 Sept 2011
ROP
Order(134) - 12 Aug 2011
ROP
Order(133) - 5 Aug 2011
ROP
Order(132) - 1 Aug 2011
ROP
Order(131) - 15 Jul 2011
ROP
Order(130) - 11 Jul 2011
ROP
Order(128) - 8 Jul 2011
ROP
Order(129) - 8 Jul 2011
ROP
Order(127) - 25 Apr 2011
ROP
Order(126) - 20 Apr 2011
ROP
Order(125) - 13 Apr 2011
ROP
Order(124) - 10 Mar 2011
ROP
Order(123) - 7 Mar 2011
ROP
Order(122) - 18 Feb 2011
ROP
Order(121) - 11 Jan 2011
ROP
Order(120) - 10 Jan 2011
ROP
Order(119) - 6 Jan 2011
ROP
Order(118) - 13 Dec 2010
ROP
Order(117) - 22 Nov 2010
ROP
Order(116) - 19 Nov 2010
ROP
Order(115) - 21 Sept 2010
ROP
Order(114) - 20 Aug 2010
ROP
Order(113) - 4 Aug 2010
ROP
Order(112) - 2 Aug 2010
ROP
Order(111) - 30 Jul 2010
ROP
Order(110) - 23 Jul 2010
ROP
Order(109) - 12 Jul 2010
ROP
Order(107) - 13 May 2010
ROP
Order(108) - 13 May 2010
ROP
Order(106) - 7 May 2010
ROP
Order(105) - 12 Apr 2010
ROP
Order(104) - 9 Apr 2010
ROP
Order(103) - 8 Apr 2010
ROP
Order(102) - 6 Apr 2010
ROP
Order(101) - 29 Mar 2010
ROP
Order(100) - 11 Mar 2010
ROP
Order(99) - 4 Feb 2010
ROP
Order(98) - 28 Jan 2010
ROP
Order(97) - 25 Jan 2010
ROP
Order(96) - 17 Dec 2009
ROP
Order(95) - 15 Dec 2009
ROP
Order(94) - 8 Dec 2009
ROP
Order(93) - 7 Dec 2009
ROP
Order(92) - 26 Nov 2009
ROP
Order(91) - 24 Nov 2009
ROP
Order(90) - 10 Nov 2009
ROP
Order(89) - 6 Nov 2009
ROP
Order(88) - 7 Oct 2009
ROP
Order(87) - 16 Sept 2009
ROP
Order(86) - 2 Sept 2009
ROP
Order(85) - 24 Aug 2009
ROP
Order(84) - 11 Aug 2009
ROP
Order(83) - 10 Aug 2009
ROP
Order(81) - 3 Aug 2009
ROP
Order(82) - 3 Aug 2009
ROP
Order(80) - 20 Jul 2009
ROP
Order(79) - 15 Jul 2009
ROP
Order(75) - 15 May 2009
ROP
Order(76) - 15 May 2009
ROP
Order(77) - 15 May 2009
ROP
Order(78) - 15 May 2009
ROP
Order(74) - 14 May 2009
ROP
Order(73) - 4 May 2009
ROP
Order(72) - 1 May 2009
ROP
Order(71) - 24 Apr 2009
ROP
Order(70) - 10 Dec 2008
ROP
Order(69) - 5 Nov 2008
ROP
Order(68) - 21 Oct 2008
ROP
Order(67) - 19 Sept 2008
ROP
Order(66) - 11 Sept 2008
ROP
Order(65) - 8 Sept 2008
ROP
Order(63) - 5 Sept 2008
ROP
Order(64) - 5 Sept 2008
ROP
Order(62) - 1 Sept 2008
ROP
Order(61) - 27 Aug 2008
ROP
Order(60) - 8 Aug 2008
ROP
Order(59) - 1 Aug 2008
ROP
Order(58) - 16 May 2008
ROP
Order(57) - 14 May 2008
ROP
Order(56) - 5 May 2008
ROP
Order(55) - 2 May 2008
ROP
Order(53) - 16 Apr 2008
ROP
Order(54) - 16 Apr 2008
ROP
Order(51) - 11 Apr 2008
ROP
Order(52) - 11 Apr 2008
ROP
Order(50) - 8 Apr 2008
ROP
Order(49) - 7 Apr 2008
ROP
Order(48) - 4 Apr 2008
ROP
Order(46) - 28 Mar 2008
ROP
Order(47) - 28 Mar 2008
ROP
Order(45) - 7 Mar 2008
ROP
Order(44) - 3 Mar 2008
ROP
Order(43) - 19 Feb 2008
ROP
Order(42) - 8 Feb 2008
ROP
Order(41) - 1 Feb 2008
ROP
Order(40) - 30 Jan 2008
ROP
Order(39) - 11 Jan 2008
ROP
Order(38) - 10 Dec 2007
ROP
Order(36) - 4 Dec 2007
ROP
Order(37) - 4 Dec 2007
ROP
Order(35) - 23 Nov 2007
ROP
Order(34) - 22 Nov 2007
ROP
Order(33) - 19 Nov 2007
ROP
Order(32) - 14 Nov 2007
ROP
Order(31) - 5 Oct 2007
ROP
Order(30) - 25 Sept 2007
ROP
Order(29) - 20 Aug 2007
ROP
Order(27) - 17 May 2007
ROP
Order(28) - 17 May 2007
ROP
Order(26) - 25 Apr 2007
ROP
Order(25) - 10 Apr 2007
ROP
Order(24) - 29 Mar 2007
ROP - of Main Case
Order(23) - 23 Feb 2007
ROP
Order(22) - 7 Feb 2007
ROP - of Main Case
Order(21) - 11 Jan 2007
ROP
Order(20) - 15 Nov 2006
ROP
Order(19) - 10 Oct 2006
ROP
Order(18) - 25 Aug 2006
ROP
Order(17) - 21 Aug 2006
ROP
Order(16) - 25 Jul 2006
ROP
Order(15) - 21 Jul 2006
ROP
Order(14) - 4 May 2006
ROP
Order(13) - 3 May 2006
ROP
Order(12) - 2 Jan 2006
ROP
Order(11) - 2 Dec 2005
ROP
Order(10) - 21 Nov 2005
ROP - of Main Case
Order(9) - 14 Nov 2005
ROP
Order(8) - 18 Oct 2005
ROP
Order(7) - 30 Sept 2005
ROP
Order(6) - 12 Sept 2005
ROP
Order(5) - 14 Jul 2005
ROP
Order(4) - 11 Jul 2005
ROP
Order(3) - 11 May 2005
ROP
Order(2) - 15 Apr 2005
ROP - of Main Case
Order(1) - 29 Nov 2004
ROP