The Secretary To Govt. Of Kerala vs. James Varghese
Court:Supreme Court of India
Judge:Hon'ble L. Nageswara Rao
Case Status:Disposed
Order Date:4 Feb 2016
CNR:SCIN010104372014
AI Summary
Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order
Order Issued After Hearing
Purpose:
Case Registered
Listed On:
9 Jul 2014
Original Order Copy
Get a certified copy of this order
Order Text
SECTION XIA IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL Nos. 6264, 9004, 9008, 9213, 9241, 6266, 8995, 8996, 8997, 8998, 8999, 9000, 9001, 9002, 9003, 9006, 9007, 9017, 9018, 9019, 9020, 9022 & 9023, 9212, 9238 & 9210 OF 2014.
| State of Kerala & Anr. Etc. | Appellants |
|---|---|
| Versus | |
| P. Raveendran Nair (D) Thr. Lrs. & Ors. Etc. | Respondents |
The matters above mentioned were listed before the Ld. Registrar on 26th November,
2015, when he was pleased to pass the following Order (Copy of Order dated 26.11.2015 is enclosed herewith).
OFFICE REPORT
| S.No. | Civil Appeal Nos. | No.<br>of<br>Respond<br>ents | Service Position | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | 6264 of 2014 | 4 | Counsel for the parties have not<br>filed statement of case so far. | Complete |
| 2. | 9004 & 9008 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the appellant has not<br>filed<br>the<br>application<br>for<br>substitution in respect of the<br>deceased sole respondent so far.<br>Mr. John Mathew, Advocate has<br>filed vakalatnama/apperance on<br>behalf of the proposed Lrs. of<br>deceased sole respondent in both<br>the appeals. | Complete |
Service position of the matters abovementioned are given below:
| S.No. | Civil Appeal Nos. | No.<br>of<br>Respond<br>ents | Service Position | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3. | 9213 & 9241 of 2014 | Sole | C.A. No. 9213<br>Notice of lodgement of petition of<br>appeal has been issued on<br>10.12.2015 and certificate of<br>service<br>in<br>respect<br>of<br>sole<br>respondent<br>is<br>received<br>with<br>remarks "served".<br>C.A. No. 9241<br>Certificate of service from High<br>Court is received in respcet of sole<br>respondent<br>with<br>remarks<br>"Respondent is lying in an<br>unconscious state due to stroke".<br>A letter has been issued to<br>Advocate on 20.01.2016 to take<br>appropriate action for effecting<br>service upon him. | Service<br>Complete in<br>C.A.<br>No.<br>9213<br>of<br>2014.<br>Service<br>incomplete<br>in C.A. No.<br>9241<br>of<br>2014. |
| 4. | 6266 of 2014 | 3 | Respondent No. 2 has been served<br>through High Court but no<br>appearance. Respondent No. 1 &<br>3 are residing in U.S.A &<br>Australia. The counsel for the<br>Appellant has not complied with<br>the terms of the order dated<br>01.09.2015 and time granted by<br>Ld. Registrar has expired. | Incomplete |
| 5. | 8995 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the parties have not<br>filed statement of case so far. Sole<br>respondent is represented through<br>Mr.<br>Nishi<br>Rajen<br>Shonker,<br>Advocate. | Complete |
| 6. | 8996 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the Appellant has not<br>filed statement of case so far. The<br>sole respondent is served through<br>High Court but no appearance.<br>Service is complete. | Complete |
| 7. | 8997 of 2014 | Sole | Mr. John Mathew, Advocate has<br>filed vakalatnama/appearance on<br>behalf of sole respondent. Counsel<br>for the parties have not filed<br>statement of case so far. | Complete |
| S.No. | Civil Appeal Nos. | No.<br>of<br>Respond<br>ents | Service Position | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8. | 8998 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the parties have not<br>filed statement of case so far. The<br>sole respondent is represented by<br>Mr. Rabin Majumdar, Advocate. | Complete |
| 9. | 8999 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the Appellant has not<br>filed statement of case so far. The<br>sole respondent is served through<br>High Court but no appearance.<br>Service is complete. | Complete |
| 10. | 9000 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the Appellant has not<br>filed statement of case so far. The<br>sole respondent is served through<br>High Court but no appearance.<br>Service is complete. | Complete |
| 11. | 9001 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the Appellant has on<br>18.11.2015 & 19.11.2015 filed<br>fresh address<br>and copy of<br>pleadings<br>respectively.<br>Fresh<br>notice of lodgement through High<br>Court issued on 03.12.2015.<br>Certificate of service is awaited. | Incomplete |
| 12. | 9002 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel<br>has<br>not<br>filed<br>the<br>application for substitution to<br>bring on record the Lrs. of<br>deceased sole Respondent so far. | Incomplete |
| 13. | 9003 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the Appellant has not<br>filed statement of case so far. Sole<br>respondent is represented by Mr.<br>John Mathew, Advocate. | Complete |
| 14. | 9006 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the Appellant has not<br>filed statement of case so far. The<br>sole respondent is served through<br>High Court but no appearance.<br>Service is complete. | Complete |
| 15. | 9007 of 2014 | Sole | Notice of lodgement through High<br>Court issued on 03.12.2015.<br>Certificate of service is awaited. | Incomplete |
| S.No. | Civil Appeal Nos. | No.<br>of<br>Respond<br>ents | Service Position | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16. | 9017 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the parties have not<br>filed statement of case so far. Sole<br>respondent represented by Mr.<br>John Mathew, Advocate. Service<br>is complete. | Complete |
| 17. | 9018 of 2014 | Sole | Notice of lodgement through High<br>Court issued and certificate of<br>service is received from High<br>Court stating that "Respondent is<br>lying in an unconscious state due<br>to stroke". A letter issued on<br>20.01.2016<br>to Advocate for<br>taking<br>appropriate<br>steps<br>for<br>effecting<br>service<br>upon<br>the<br>respondents. | Incomplete |
| 18. | 9019 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the parties have not<br>filed statement of case so far. Sole<br>respondent is represented by Mr.<br>P. I. Jose, Advocate. Service is<br>complete. | Complete |
| 19. | 9020 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the Appellant has not<br>filed statement of case so far. Sole<br>respondent served through High<br>Court but no appearance. Service<br>is complete | Complete |
| 20. | 9022 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the Appellant has on<br>08.12.2015 filed fresh particulars<br>of the sole Respondent. Notice of<br>lodgement of petition of appeal<br>issued on 14.12.2015, certificate<br>of service is awaited. | Incomplete |
| 21. | 9023 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the Appellant has not<br>filed statement of case so far. Sole<br>Respondent served through High<br>Court but no appearance. Service<br>is complete. | Complete |
| S.No. | Civil Appeal Nos. | No.<br>of<br>Respond<br>ents | Service Position | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22. | 9212 of 2014 | 2 | Notice of lodgement through High<br>Court issued on 10.12.2015 and<br>certificate of service is received<br>from High Court in respect of<br>Respondent No. 1 stating that "No<br>such firm in given address". A<br>letter issued on 28.01.2016 to<br>Advocate for taking appropriate<br>steps for effecting service upon<br>the respondents and Respondent<br>No. 2 is served through High<br>Court. | Incomplete |
| 23. | 9238 of 2014 | 3 | Counsel for the Appellant has not<br>filed<br>the<br>application<br>for<br>substitution to bring on record the<br>Lrs. of deceased Respondent Nos.<br>1 & 2 so far and the time granted<br>by the Ld. Registrar vide order<br>dated 26.11.2015 has expired.<br>Respondent No. 3 served but no<br>appearance. | Incomplete |
| 24. | 9210 of 2014 | Sole | Counsel for the appellant has not<br>complied with the terms of the<br>order<br>dated<br>01.09.2015<br>and<br>counsel for the Appellant has<br>neither filed fresh particulars of<br>the sole Respondent nor he has<br>taken fresh steps for service of<br>notice to sole Respondent. | Incomplete |
The matters above mentioned are listed before the Ld. Registrar with this office report.
Dated this the 2nd day of February, 2016.
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
Copy to:
-
- Mr. Jogy Scaria, Adv. (Supreme Court Bar Association)
-
- Mr. P. I Jose, Adv. (120, Old Lawyers Chambers)
-
- Mr. John Mathew, Adv. (Supreme Court Bar Association)
-
- Mr. Rabin Majumdar, Adv. (55, Old Lawyers Chambers)
-
- Mr. Nishe Rajen Shonker, Adv. (Supreme Court Bar Association)
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
d1
Share This Order
Case History of Orders
Similar Case Search
Same Parties
The Secretary To Govt. Of Kerala vs James VargheseThe Secretary To Govt. Of KeralaThe State Of Kerala Chief SecretaryThe State Of Kerala Law Department SecretaryThe State Of Kerala Kallada Irriagation Project The Chief EngineerThe State Of Kerala The Superintending EngineerThe State Of Kerala Kallada Irrigation Project Superintending EngineerJames VargheseAll Kerala Irrigarion Projects Contractors Association (Deleted) President (P. P. Thomas)The State Of Delhi Union Of India Secretary To Govt
Search in District Courts Data
The Secretary To Govt. Of KeralaThe State Of Kerala Chief SecretaryThe State Of Kerala Law Department SecretaryThe State Of Kerala Kallada Irriagation Project The Chief EngineerThe State Of Kerala The Superintending EngineerThe State Of Kerala Kallada Irrigation Project Superintending EngineerJames VargheseAll Kerala Irrigarion Projects Contractors Association (Deleted) President (P. P. Thomas)The State Of Delhi Union Of India Secretary To GovtAdvocate C. K. SasiAdvocate Himinder Lal