Wockhardt Hospitals Ltd. vs. Union Of India Ministry Of Law And Justice Through The Joint Secretary
AI Summary
Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order
Order Issued After Hearing
Purpose:
Next Week / Week Commencing / C.O.Week
Before:
Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, Hon'ble R. Banumathi
Stage:
Indirect Taxes Matters : Service Tax
Remarks:
Adjourned [after the judgment as per r/p]
Listed On:
4 May 2018
In:
Judge
Category:
UNKNOWN
Original Order Copy
Get a certified copy of this order
Order Text
ITEM NO.12 COURT NO.4 SECTION XVII
S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
CIVIL APPEAL Diary No(s). 21577/2019
(Arising out of impugned final judgment and order dated 26-09-2018 in APP No. 42463/2015 passed by the Customs Excise And Service Tax Apellate Tribunal, South Zonal Bench, Chennai)
COMMISSIONER OF GST AND C.E. Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
M/S ASWINI APARTMENTS Respondent(s)
(FOR ADMISSION and IA No.123967/2019-STAY APPLICATION and IA No.123963/2019-CONDONATION OF DELAY IN FILING APPEAL and IA No.123966/2019-CONDONATION OF DELAY IN REFILING )
Date : 26-08-2019 This petition was called on for hearing today.
CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN MISHRA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.R. SHAH
For Petitioner(s) Mr. A. N. S. Nadkarni, ASG Mr. Debashish Bharuka, Adv. Mr. Shekhar Vyas, Adv. Ms. Nitya Rao, Adv. Ms. Nisha Bagchi, Adv. Mr. B. Krishna Prasad, AOR
For Respondent(s)
UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following O R D E R
Delay condoned. Issue notice.
It is submitted that on the second issue raised in the matter, another civil appeal, being C. A. No. 11109 of 2016 is pending. Replying upon the said statement, the instant matter is tagged with the above civil appeal.
All the points are kept open, to be urged at the time of hearing. Digitally signed by JAYANT KUMAR ARORA Date: 2019.08.29 12:40:59 IST Reason: Signature Not Verified
(JAYANT KUMAR ARORA) (JAGDISH CHANDER) COURT MASTER BRANCH OFFICER
Share This Order
Order(390) - 4 Apr 2025
ROP - of Main Case
Order(389) - 6 Mar 2025
ROP - of Main Case
Order(388) - 15 Jan 2025
ROP - of Main Case
Order(387) - 3 Jan 2025
ROP - of Main Case
Order(386) - 18 Dec 2024
ROP - of Main Case
Order(385) - 13 Sept 2024
ROP - of Main Case
Order(384) - 27 Aug 2024
ROP - of Main Case
Order(383) - 29 Jul 2024
ROP - of Main Case
Order(382) - 10 Jul 2024
ROP - of Main Case
Order(381) - 6 May 2024
ROP - of Main Case
Order(380) - 6 Mar 2024
ROP - of Main Case
Order(379) - 16 Jan 2024
ROP - of Main Case
Order(378) - 20 Oct 2023
ROP - of Main Case
Order(377) - 13 Oct 2023
ROP - of Main Case
Order(376) - 7 Aug 2023
ROP - of Main Case
Order(375) - 18 Apr 2023
ROP
Order(374) - 10 Apr 2023
ROP - of Main Case
Order(373) - 3 Mar 2023
ROP - of Main Case
Order(372) - 24 Jan 2023
ROP - of Main Case
Order(371) - 27 Jul 2022
ROP
Order(370) - 19 May 2022
ROP
Order(369) - 4 May 2022
ROP
Order(368) - 13 Apr 2022
ROP
Order(367) - 10 Feb 2022
ROP - of Main Case
Order(366) - 8 Feb 2022
ROP - of Main Case
Order(365) - 3 Dec 2021
ROP - of Main Case
Order(364) - 12 Nov 2021
ROP - of Main Case
Order(363) - 2 Sept 2021
ROP - of Main Case
Order(362) - 27 Aug 2021
ROP
Order(361) - 26 Aug 2021
ROP - of Main Case
Order(360) - 5 Apr 2021
ROP
Order(359) - 18 Jan 2021
ROP - of Main Case
Order(358) - 4 Jan 2021
ROP - of Main Case
Order(357) - 25 Nov 2020
ROP
Order(356) - 9 Oct 2020
ROP - of Main Case
Order(355) - 24 Sept 2020
ROP - of Main Case
Order(354) - 25 Aug 2020
ROP - of Main Case
Order(353) - 5 Aug 2020
ROP - of Main Case
Order(352) - 28 Feb 2020
ROP - of Main Case
Order(351) - 5 Feb 2020
ROP
Order(350) - 24 Jan 2020
ROP - of Main Case
Order(349) - 16 Oct 2019
ROP - of Main Case
Order(348) - 16 Sept 2019
ROP
Order(347) - 2 Sept 2019
ROP
Order(346) - 26 Aug 2019
ROP
Order(345) - 16 Aug 2019
ROP
Order(344) - 5 Aug 2019
ROP
Order(343) - 10 Jul 2019
ROP - of Main Case
Order(342) - 5 Jul 2019
ROP
Order(341) - 6 May 2019
ROP
Order(340) - 4 Feb 2019
ROP
Order(339) - 14 Jan 2019
ROP
Order(338) - 29 Aug 2018
ROP - of Main Case
Order(337) - 5 Apr 2018
ROP - of Main Case
Order(336) - 4 Apr 2018
ROP - of Main Case
Order(335) - 8 Jan 2018
ROP
Order(334) - 20 Sept 2017
ROP
Order(333) - 25 Jul 2017
ROP
Order(330) - 3 May 2017
ROP
Order(331) - 3 May 2017
Office Report
Order(332) - 3 May 2017
ROP
Order(327) - 19 Apr 2017
ROP
Order(328) - 19 Apr 2017
Office Report
Order(329) - 19 Apr 2017
ROP
Order(324) - 21 Mar 2017
ROP
Order(325) - 21 Mar 2017
Office Report
Order(326) - 21 Mar 2017
ROP
Order(321) - 17 Feb 2017
ROP
Order(322) - 17 Feb 2017
Office Report
Order(323) - 17 Feb 2017
ROP
Order(318) - 14 Feb 2017
ROP
Order(319) - 14 Feb 2017
Office Report
Order(320) - 14 Feb 2017
ROP
Order(315) - 30 Jan 2017
ROP
Order(316) - 30 Jan 2017
Office Report
Order(317) - 30 Jan 2017
ROP
Order(312) - 3 Jan 2017
ROP
Order(313) - 3 Jan 2017
Office Report
Order(314) - 3 Jan 2017
ROP
Order(308) - 16 Dec 2016
ROP
Order(309) - 16 Dec 2016
ROP
Order(310) - 16 Dec 2016
ROP
Order(311) - 16 Dec 2016
ROP
Order(305) - 15 Nov 2016
ROP
Order(306) - 15 Nov 2016
Office Report
Order(307) - 15 Nov 2016
ROP
Order(302) - 28 Oct 2016
ROP
Order(303) - 28 Oct 2016
Office Report
Order(304) - 28 Oct 2016
ROP
Order(299) - 18 Oct 2016
ROP
Order(300) - 18 Oct 2016
Office Report
Order(301) - 18 Oct 2016
ROP
Order(296) - 29 Sept 2016
ROP
Order(297) - 29 Sept 2016
Office Report
Order(298) - 29 Sept 2016
ROP
Order(294) - 28 Sept 2016
ROP
Order(295) - 28 Sept 2016
ROP
Order(291) - 20 Sept 2016
ROP
Order(292) - 20 Sept 2016
Office Report
Order(293) - 20 Sept 2016
ROP
Order(288) - 31 Aug 2016
ROP
Order(289) - 31 Aug 2016
Office Report
Order(290) - 31 Aug 2016
ROP
Order(285) - 22 Aug 2016
ROP
Order(286) - 22 Aug 2016
Office Report
Order(287) - 22 Aug 2016
ROP
Order(282) - 11 Aug 2016
ROP
Order(283) - 11 Aug 2016
Office Report
Order(284) - 11 Aug 2016
ROP
Order(279) - 3 Aug 2016
ROP
Order(280) - 3 Aug 2016
Office Report
Order(281) - 3 Aug 2016
ROP
Order(276) - 5 Jul 2016
ROP
Order(277) - 5 Jul 2016
Office Report
Order(278) - 5 Jul 2016
ROP
Order(274) - 28 Apr 2016
ROP
Order(275) - 28 Apr 2016
ROP
Order(271) - 29 Mar 2016
ROP
Order(272) - 29 Mar 2016
Office Report
Order(273) - 29 Mar 2016
ROP
Order(268) - 10 Mar 2016
ROP
Order(269) - 10 Mar 2016
Office Report
Order(270) - 10 Mar 2016
ROP
Order(266) - 8 Feb 2016
ROP
Order(267) - 8 Feb 2016
ROP
Order(264) - 21 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(265) - 21 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(261) - 12 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(262) - 12 Jan 2016
Office Report
Order(263) - 12 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(259) - 11 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(260) - 11 Jan 2016
ROP
Order(257) - 4 Dec 2015
ROP
Order(258) - 4 Dec 2015
ROP
Order(255) - 2 Dec 2015
ROP
Order(256) - 2 Dec 2015
ROP
Order(252) - 23 Nov 2015
ROP
Order(253) - 23 Nov 2015
Office Report
Order(254) - 23 Nov 2015
ROP
Order(250) - 28 Oct 2015
ROP
Order(251) - 28 Oct 2015
ROP
Order(242) - 23 Sept 2015
ROP
Order(243) - 23 Sept 2015
ROP
Order(244) - 23 Sept 2015
Office Report
Order(245) - 23 Sept 2015
Office Report
Order(246) - 23 Sept 2015
Office Report
Order(247) - 23 Sept 2015
Office Report
Order(248) - 23 Sept 2015
ROP
Order(249) - 23 Sept 2015
ROP
Order(240) - 25 Aug 2015
Office Report
Order(241) - 25 Aug 2015
ROP
Order(238) - 20 Aug 2015
Office Report
Order(239) - 20 Aug 2015
ROP
Order(235) - 15 May 2015
ROP
Order(236) - 15 May 2015
Office Report
Order(237) - 15 May 2015
ROP
Order(233) - 17 Apr 2015
ROP
Order(234) - 17 Apr 2015
ROP
Order(231) - 1 Apr 2015
ROP
Order(232) - 1 Apr 2015
ROP
Order(229) - 25 Feb 2015
ROP
Order(230) - 25 Feb 2015
ROP
Order(227) - 23 Feb 2015
ROP
Order(228) - 23 Feb 2015
ROP
Order(225) - 27 Jan 2015
ROP
Order(226) - 27 Jan 2015
ROP
Order(223) - 19 Jan 2015
ROP
Order(224) - 19 Jan 2015
ROP
Order(221) - 9 Jan 2015
ROP
Order(222) - 9 Jan 2015
ROP
Order(220) - 11 Dec 2014
ROP
Order(218) - 8 Dec 2014
ROP
Order(219) - 8 Dec 2014
ROP
Order(216) - 4 Dec 2014
ROP
Order(217) - 4 Dec 2014
ROP
Order(214) - 26 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(215) - 26 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(212) - 24 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(213) - 24 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(208) - 20 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(209) - 20 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(210) - 20 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(211) - 20 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(207) - 15 Nov 2014
Office Report
Order(205) - 13 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(206) - 13 Nov 2014
ROP
Order(204) - 30 Oct 2014
ROP
Order(201) - 18 Sept 2014
ROP
Order(202) - 18 Sept 2014
Office Report
Order(203) - 18 Sept 2014
ROP
Order(200) - 16 Sept 2014
ROP
Order(199) - 9 Sept 2014
ROP
Order(197) - 29 Aug 2014
ROP
Order(198) - 29 Aug 2014
Office Report
Order(195) - 27 Aug 2014
ROP
Order(196) - 27 Aug 2014
ROP
Order(194) - 11 Jul 2014
ROP
Order(193) - 8 Jul 2014
ROP
Order(192) - 7 Jul 2014
ROP
Order(190) - 9 May 2014
ROP
Order(191) - 9 May 2014
ROP
Order(189) - 8 May 2014
ROP
Order(188) - 2 May 2014
ROP
Order(187) - 30 Apr 2014
ROP
Order(186) - 28 Apr 2014
ROP
Order(185) - 2 Apr 2014
ROP
Order(184) - 25 Mar 2014
ROP
Order(182) - 12 Mar 2014
ROP
Order(183) - 12 Mar 2014
ROP
Order(181) - 4 Mar 2014
ROP
Order(180) - 3 Mar 2014
ROP
Order(179) - 28 Feb 2014
ROP
Order(178) - 18 Feb 2014
ROP
Order(176) - 17 Feb 2014
ROP
Order(177) - 17 Feb 2014
ROP
Order(175) - 7 Feb 2014
ROP
Order(174) - 13 Jan 2014
ROP
Order(173) - 13 Dec 2013
ROP
Order(172) - 22 Nov 2013
ROP
Order(170) - 31 Oct 2013
ROP
Order(171) - 31 Oct 2013
ROP
Order(168) - 28 Oct 2013
ROP
Order(169) - 28 Oct 2013
ROP
Order(167) - 21 Oct 2013
ROP
Order(166) - 8 Oct 2013
ROP
Order(165) - 1 Oct 2013
ROP
Order(164) - 26 Sept 2013
ROP
Order(163) - 25 Sept 2013
ROP
Order(162) - 12 Sept 2013
ROP
Order(158) - 2 Sept 2013
Office Report
Order(159) - 2 Sept 2013
Office Report
Order(160) - 2 Sept 2013
ROP
Order(161) - 2 Sept 2013
ROP
Order(156) - 30 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(157) - 30 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(155) - 27 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(153) - 23 Aug 2013
Office Report
Order(154) - 23 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(152) - 12 Aug 2013
ROP
Order(151) - 23 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(150) - 22 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(148) - 4 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(149) - 4 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(147) - 3 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(145) - 1 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(146) - 1 Jul 2013
ROP
Order(144) - 10 May 2013
ROP
Order(143) - 7 May 2013
ROP
Order(142) - 6 May 2013
ROP
Order(141) - 18 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(140) - 17 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(139) - 15 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(138) - 9 Apr 2013
ROP
Order(137) - 19 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(136) - 18 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(135) - 12 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(134) - 11 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(133) - 8 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(131) - 6 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(132) - 6 Mar 2013
ROP
Order(130) - 27 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(129) - 18 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(128) - 15 Feb 2013
ROP - of Main Case
Order(127) - 8 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(126) - 7 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(125) - 6 Feb 2013
ROP
Order(124) - 28 Jan 2013
ROP - of Main Case
Order(123) - 23 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(122) - 14 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(121) - 11 Jan 2013
ROP
Order(120) - 11 Dec 2012
ROP
Order(118) - 10 Dec 2012
ROP
Order(119) - 10 Dec 2012
ROP
Order(116) - 19 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(117) - 19 Nov 2012
ROP
Order(113) - 29 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(114) - 29 Oct 2012
ROP - of Main Case
Order(115) - 29 Oct 2012
ROP
Order(112) - 24 Sept 2012
ROP
Order(111) - 23 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(110) - 16 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(109) - 9 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(108) - 8 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(107) - 6 Aug 2012
ROP
Order(106) - 30 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(105) - 16 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(104) - 13 Jul 2012
ROP
Order(103) - 4 May 2012
ROP
Order(102) - 16 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(101) - 13 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(100) - 2 Apr 2012
ROP
Order(97) - 30 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(98) - 30 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(99) - 30 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(96) - 26 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(94) - 23 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(95) - 23 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(93) - 12 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(90) - 2 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(91) - 2 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(92) - 2 Mar 2012
ROP
Order(89) - 27 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(87) - 24 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(88) - 24 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(86) - 21 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(84) - 17 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(85) - 17 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(83) - 13 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(80) - 10 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(81) - 10 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(82) - 10 Feb 2012
ROP
Order(77) - 30 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(78) - 30 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(79) - 30 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(76) - 27 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(74) - 23 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(75) - 23 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(73) - 20 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(72) - 16 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(70) - 13 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(71) - 13 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(69) - 6 Jan 2012
ROP
Order(68) - 16 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(67) - 15 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(66) - 12 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(65) - 9 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(64) - 7 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(63) - 2 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(62) - 1 Dec 2011
ROP
Order(61) - 25 Nov 2011
ROP
Order(60) - 11 Nov 2011
ROP
Order(59) - 4 Nov 2011
ROP
Order(58) - 21 Oct 2011
ROP
Order(57) - 14 Oct 2011
ROP
Order(56) - 30 Sept 2011
ROP
Order(55) - 29 Sept 2011
ROP
Order(54) - 28 Sept 2011
ROP
Order(53) - 26 Sept 2011
ROP
Order(52) - 19 Jul 2011
ROP
Order(51) - 18 Jul 2011
ROP
Order(50) - 13 May 2011
ROP
Order(49) - 6 May 2011
ROP
Order(48) - 29 Apr 2011
ROP
Order(47) - 25 Apr 2011
ROP
Order(46) - 7 Apr 2011
ROP
Order(44) - 4 Mar 2011
ROP
Order(45) - 4 Mar 2011
ROP
Order(43) - 25 Feb 2011
ROP
Order(42) - 4 Feb 2011
ROP
Order(41) - 28 Jan 2011
ROP
Order(39) - 24 Jan 2011
ROP
Order(40) - 24 Jan 2011
ROP
Order(38) - 14 Jan 2011
ROP
Order(37) - 13 Dec 2010
ROP
Order(36) - 26 Nov 2010
ROP
Order(35) - 18 Nov 2010
ROP
Order(34) - 29 Oct 2010
ROP
Order(33) - 26 Oct 2010
ROP
Order(32) - 8 Oct 2010
ROP
Order(31) - 20 Sept 2010
ROP
Order(30) - 7 Sept 2010
ROP
Order(29) - 6 Sept 2010
ROP
Order(28) - 1 Sept 2010
ROP
Order(27) - 22 Jul 2010
ROP
Order(26) - 13 Jul 2010
ROP
Order(25) - 12 May 2010
ROP
Order(24) - 7 May 2010
ROP
Order(23) - 27 Apr 2010
ROP
Order(22) - 12 Apr 2010
ROP
Order(21) - 26 Mar 2010
ROP
Order(20) - 12 Mar 2010
ROP
Order(19) - 24 Feb 2010
ROP
Order(18) - 8 Feb 2010
ROP
Order(17) - 1 Feb 2010
ROP
Order(16) - 22 Jan 2010
ROP
Order(15) - 12 Jan 2010
ROP
Order(14) - 8 Jan 2010
ROP
Order(13) - 17 Dec 2009
ROP
Order(12) - 16 Dec 2009
ROP
Order(11) - 27 Nov 2009
ROP
Order(10) - 3 Nov 2009
ROP
Order(9) - 21 Oct 2009
ROP
Order(8) - 29 Sept 2009
ROP
Order(7) - 2 Sept 2009
ROP
Order(6) - 21 Aug 2009
ROP
Order(5) - 28 Jul 2009
ROP
Order(4) - 2 Jun 2009
ROP
Order(3) - 14 May 2009
ROP
Order(2) - 13 Apr 2009
ROP
Order(1) - 27 Feb 2009
ROP