Commissioner Of Delhi Value Added Tax Department Of Trade And Taxes vs. Munshi Ram Ram Prakash
Court:Supreme Court of India
Judge:Hon'ble Rohinton Fali Nariman
Case Status:Pending
Order Date:20 Feb 2017
CNR:SCIN010045222017
AI Summary
Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order
Original Order Copy
Get a certified copy of this order
Order Text
| Ü-1 | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ITEM NO.33 | COURT NO.2 | SECTION III | |||||||
| S U P R E M E | C O U R T | O F<br>I N D I A | |||||||
| RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS | |||||||||
| Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s). | 5636-5744/2017 | ||||||||
| (Arising out of impugned final judgment and order dated | 19/01/2017 | ||||||||
| in WP No. 10001/2016 19/01/2017 in WP No. 10004/2016 19/01/2017 in | |||||||||
| WP No. 10005/2016 19/01/2017 in WP No. 10007/2016 19/01/2017 in WP | |||||||||
| No. 10009/2016 19/01/2017 in WP No. 10077/2016 19/01/2017 in WP No. | |||||||||
| 10078/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10079/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10080/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10087/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10090/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10091/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10120/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10123/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10125/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10139/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10140/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10142/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10154/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10251/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10256/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10258/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10260/2016<br>10267/2016 | 19/01/2017<br>19/01/2017 | in<br>in | WP<br>WP | No.<br>No. | 10264/2016<br>10268/2016 | 19/01/2017<br>19/01/2017 | in<br>in | WP<br>WP | No.<br>No. |
| 10269/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10270/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10271/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10299/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10308/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10309/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10315/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10320/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10326/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10335/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10336/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10337/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10363/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10415/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10416/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10509/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10511/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10574/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10632/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10807/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10856/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10858/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10859/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 10911/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 10947/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11008/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11009/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11010/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11011/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11012/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11014/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11015/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11017/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11018/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11021/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. | 11030/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. |
| 11031/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. | 11032/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. |
| 11050/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. | 11051/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11063/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. | 11251/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. |
| 11253/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. | 11254/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11260/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11265/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11418/2016<br>11434/2016 | 19/01/2017<br>19/01/2017 | in<br>in | WP<br>WP | No.<br>No. | 11419/2016<br>11567/2016 | 19/01/2017<br>19/01/2017 | in<br>in | WP<br>WP | No.<br>No. |
| 11568/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11570/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11621/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11662/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11683/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11698/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11699/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11701/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11837/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11839/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11840/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11841/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11854/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11855/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 11857/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 11862/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. |
| 2 | |||||||||
| 9730/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. | 9732/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. |
| 9734/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. | 9739/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WPC | No. |
| 9740/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 9778/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 9782/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 9783/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 9784/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 9787/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 9794/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 9916/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 9920/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 9922/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 9923/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. | 9924/2016 | 19/01/2017 | in | WP | No. |
| 9928/2016 passed by the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi) | |||||||||
| COMMISSIONER OF DELHI | |||||||||
| VALUE ADDED TAX, & ANR. ETC.ETC.<br>Petitioner(s) | |||||||||
| VERSUS | |||||||||
| M/S MUNSHI RAM RAM PRAKASH ETC.ETC.<br>Respondent(s) | |||||||||
| (with appln. (s) for exemption from filing c/c of the impugned | |||||||||
| judgment and interim relief and office report) |
Date : 20/02/2017 These petitions were called on for hearing today. CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DIPAK MISRA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A.M. KHANWILKAR HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAN M. SHANTANAGOUDAR For Petitioner(s) Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, AG Ms. Nisha Bagchi, Adv. Mr. Ajay Sharma, Adv. Ms. Diksha Rai, Adv. Mr. B. Krishna Prasad, Adv. For Respondent(s) [ UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following O R D E R Issue notice. In the meantime, there shall be stay of the operation of the impugned judgment. Tag with S.L.P. (C) No.22867 of 2016 and other connected matters. (Ashok Raj Singh) (H.S. Parasher) Court Master Court Master
Share This Order
Case History of Orders
Similar Case Search
Same Parties
Commissioner Of Delhi Value Added Tax Department Of Trade And Taxes vs Munshi Ram Ram PrakashCommissioner Of Delhi Value Added Tax Department Of Trade And TaxesThe Assistant Commissioner Department Of Trade And TaxesCommissioner Trade And TaxesValue Added Tax OfficerThe Asstt. Commissioner Department Of Trade And TaxesAsstt. Commissioner Of DvatAsstt. Commissioner Value Added Tax OfficerAsstt. Commissioner Of Value Added Tax OfficeAssistant Commissioner, Department Of Trade And TaxesAsstt. Commissioner Value Added Tax OfficeCommissioner Of VatCommissioner Value Added TaxAssistant Commissioner Value Added Tax OfficeCommissioner Of Trade And TaxesMunshi Ram Ram PrakashMangla Enterprises Through Mahavir Prasad Mangal, ProprietorDhanjal Engg. Works Through Dalbir Singh ProprietorGoel Oil Company Through Its Managing DirectorArun ElectronicsPower Industries Proprietor Sh. Tarun BansalLudhiana Auto Supply Co. Through Its Managing DirectorHearisons Corporation Through Its Managing DirectorYash SalesSuper Motor Parts Through Manjoor Ali ProprietorAsiatic Electrical And Switchgear Pvt. Ltd. Through Manjit Singh, Manager Finance And AdministrationS. S. TradersCharanjeet Sons Shri Sourabh Grover Authorised RepresentativeSns Enterprises Through Its Managing DirectorSeven Auto Traders Proprietor Sh. Anita BajajJay Packaging Shri Mandan Lal Sachdeva, Authorised RepresentativeTripati Metal Udyog Through Its Proprietor Sh. Ashu GuptaRama Sales Corporation Through Its Karta Sh. Surinder Kumar GuptaChemical CentreS. L. Industries Through Yash Suneja, ProprietorFashion And Style Through Its Partner Sh. Rakesh ChopraKapil Enterprises Proprietor Sh. Kapil GuptaThe Hot Plate Centre Through Its Proprietor Sh. Nishant GargDhruvco Carton Industries Through Its Proprietor Sh. Dhruv BhasinVivek Enterprises Through Its Proprietor Sh. Vivek GoelUnited Surgical Industries Through Shri Krishan Talwar, PartnerAllied Electricals Through Manoj Goyal ProptietorNakoda Print And Arts Through Ramesh Jain ProprietorRmco Auto AccessoriesN. G. Engineering Company Through Its Managing DirectorRaj Kamal Fair Luebe CoSunsara Papers Through Karta Of Proprietor Sh. Rohit JainHimank Packaging Corporation Through Vikas Jain ProprietorYashita Print O Pack Pvt. Ltd. Through Vikas Jain, DirectorRam Pershad Bishan Sarup Through Its Managing DirectorS. A. B. Sai Enterprises Through Nitin Malhotra ProprietorSiska Shoes And Accessories Through Its Proprietor Sh. Meenakshi AroraJai Ambey Furniture Through Atma Ram ProprietorJai Maa Furniture Through Vishwanath Sharma ProprietorVansh Electromechanical Devices P. Ltd. Through Its Director Sh. Avinash GuptaFelder Broad PackHare Krishna Trading Company ProprietorSahni Hardware Through Its Proprietor Sh. Harjeet Singh SahniChanchal Lites Through Its Managing DirectorKundalia Polymers Private LimitedShiva Hardware Store Through Yash Pal Goel PartnerMehnga Ram Gian Chand Through Yash Pal PartnerClassic Polymers Through Its Partner Sh. Sudhir AggarwalDinesh Sanitary Store Through Ramesh Goel PartnerShiv Shakti Metals Pvt. Ltd Through Its Managing DirectorRainbow Industries India Through Its Managing DirectorBhavya Trading CoRoyal Printers Through Ajay Sareen ProprietorK. C. Act Glass Through Manju Aggarwal ProprietorBasant Lal Art Smt. Bhawna Vij ProprietorBasant Lal International Shri Rajesh Vij ProprietorAsian Bearing Co. Through Rajesh Kumar Arora, ProprietorViashnavi Metals Through Sandeep Tekriwal ProprietorCosmic Experts Through Its Managing DirectorSab Enterprises Through Nitin Malhotra ProprietorKunj Bihari Enterprises Through Shobha Jindal ProprietorNirwan Industries Through Pradeep Singh Narwal ProprietorSkt Enterprises Through Its Managing DirectorRrk Trading Corporation Through Its Managing DirectorBajaj International Through Partner Sh. Sat Pal BajajMayank Plastic Through Its Managing DirectorSunrise Overseas Through Its Managing DirectorSwastik Polymers Through Its Proprietor Sh. Vivek BansalS. S. Packaging Industries Through Pradeep Singh PartnerThe Indian Overseas Commercial Co. Through Its Partner Sh. Sat Pal BajajNitin International InclSink Well Drill Co. Pvt. Ltd. Through Ankit Garg DirectorGandhi Store India Through Its Proprietor Sh. Parshottam Lal SachdevaKundan Steel Through Its Proprietor Ms. Sumin GuptaRaj Kamal Fair Lube Co. M/S Raj Kamal Fair Lube Co. Through Its Managing DirectorKurex Electronics Kurex Electronics Through Anju Khanna ProprietorKhanna Electrical IndiaKrishma Cables Through Manik Khanna ProprietorAiro Auto Industries Through Arvinder Singh ProprietorKwality Metal SheetElegant Enterprises Proprietor Sh. Kunal SethSupreme Trading Co. Through Raj Kumar Saini, ProprietorK. E. Plugs
Lawyers
Search in District Courts Data
Commissioner Of Delhi Value Added Tax Department Of Trade And TaxesThe Assistant Commissioner Department Of Trade And TaxesCommissioner Trade And TaxesValue Added Tax OfficerThe Asstt. Commissioner Department Of Trade And TaxesAsstt. Commissioner Of DvatAsstt. Commissioner Value Added Tax OfficerAsstt. Commissioner Of Value Added Tax OfficeAssistant Commissioner, Department Of Trade And TaxesAsstt. Commissioner Value Added Tax OfficeCommissioner Of VatCommissioner Value Added TaxAssistant Commissioner Value Added Tax OfficeCommissioner Of Trade And TaxesMunshi Ram Ram PrakashMangla Enterprises Through Mahavir Prasad Mangal, ProprietorDhanjal Engg. Works Through Dalbir Singh ProprietorGoel Oil Company Through Its Managing DirectorArun ElectronicsPower Industries Proprietor Sh. Tarun BansalLudhiana Auto Supply Co. Through Its Managing DirectorHearisons Corporation Through Its Managing DirectorYash SalesSuper Motor Parts Through Manjoor Ali ProprietorAsiatic Electrical And Switchgear Pvt. Ltd. Through Manjit Singh, Manager Finance And AdministrationS. S. TradersCharanjeet Sons Shri Sourabh Grover Authorised RepresentativeSns Enterprises Through Its Managing DirectorSeven Auto Traders Proprietor Sh. Anita BajajJay Packaging Shri Mandan Lal Sachdeva, Authorised RepresentativeTripati Metal Udyog Through Its Proprietor Sh. Ashu GuptaRama Sales Corporation Through Its Karta Sh. Surinder Kumar GuptaChemical CentreS. L. Industries Through Yash Suneja, ProprietorFashion And Style Through Its Partner Sh. Rakesh ChopraKapil Enterprises Proprietor Sh. Kapil GuptaThe Hot Plate Centre Through Its Proprietor Sh. Nishant GargDhruvco Carton Industries Through Its Proprietor Sh. Dhruv BhasinVivek Enterprises Through Its Proprietor Sh. Vivek GoelUnited Surgical Industries Through Shri Krishan Talwar, PartnerAllied Electricals Through Manoj Goyal ProptietorNakoda Print And Arts Through Ramesh Jain ProprietorRmco Auto AccessoriesN. G. Engineering Company Through Its Managing DirectorRaj Kamal Fair Luebe CoSunsara Papers Through Karta Of Proprietor Sh. Rohit JainHimank Packaging Corporation Through Vikas Jain ProprietorYashita Print O Pack Pvt. Ltd. Through Vikas Jain, DirectorRam Pershad Bishan Sarup Through Its Managing DirectorS. A. B. Sai Enterprises Through Nitin Malhotra ProprietorSiska Shoes And Accessories Through Its Proprietor Sh. Meenakshi AroraJai Ambey Furniture Through Atma Ram ProprietorJai Maa Furniture Through Vishwanath Sharma ProprietorVansh Electromechanical Devices P. Ltd. Through Its Director Sh. Avinash GuptaFelder Broad PackHare Krishna Trading Company ProprietorSahni Hardware Through Its Proprietor Sh. Harjeet Singh SahniChanchal Lites Through Its Managing DirectorKundalia Polymers Private LimitedShiva Hardware Store Through Yash Pal Goel PartnerMehnga Ram Gian Chand Through Yash Pal PartnerClassic Polymers Through Its Partner Sh. Sudhir AggarwalDinesh Sanitary Store Through Ramesh Goel PartnerShiv Shakti Metals Pvt. Ltd Through Its Managing DirectorRainbow Industries India Through Its Managing DirectorBhavya Trading CoRoyal Printers Through Ajay Sareen ProprietorK. C. Act Glass Through Manju Aggarwal ProprietorBasant Lal Art Smt. Bhawna Vij ProprietorBasant Lal International Shri Rajesh Vij ProprietorAsian Bearing Co. Through Rajesh Kumar Arora, ProprietorViashnavi Metals Through Sandeep Tekriwal ProprietorCosmic Experts Through Its Managing DirectorSab Enterprises Through Nitin Malhotra ProprietorKunj Bihari Enterprises Through Shobha Jindal ProprietorNirwan Industries Through Pradeep Singh Narwal ProprietorSkt Enterprises Through Its Managing DirectorRrk Trading Corporation Through Its Managing DirectorBajaj International Through Partner Sh. Sat Pal BajajMayank Plastic Through Its Managing DirectorSunrise Overseas Through Its Managing DirectorSwastik Polymers Through Its Proprietor Sh. Vivek BansalS. S. Packaging Industries Through Pradeep Singh PartnerThe Indian Overseas Commercial Co. Through Its Partner Sh. Sat Pal BajajNitin International InclSink Well Drill Co. Pvt. Ltd. Through Ankit Garg DirectorGandhi Store India Through Its Proprietor Sh. Parshottam Lal SachdevaKundan Steel Through Its Proprietor Ms. Sumin GuptaRaj Kamal Fair Lube Co. M/S Raj Kamal Fair Lube Co. Through Its Managing DirectorKurex Electronics Kurex Electronics Through Anju Khanna ProprietorKhanna Electrical IndiaKrishma Cables Through Manik Khanna ProprietorAiro Auto Industries Through Arvinder Singh ProprietorKwality Metal SheetElegant Enterprises Proprietor Sh. Kunal SethSupreme Trading Co. Through Raj Kumar Saini, ProprietorK. E. PlugsAdvocate Gurmeet Singh MakkerAdvocate V. N. RaghupathyAdvocate Zoheb HossainAdvocate Kedar Nath TripathyAdvocate Avadh Bihari Kaushik