eCourtsIndiaBeta

Ministry Of Finance Secretary vs. Bhawani Plastics Its Proprietor Shri Sudeep Agarwal

Court:Supreme Court of India
Judges:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble B.R. Gavai, Hon'ble Surya Kant
Case Type:Civil Appeal
Reg no:1000/2007
Filing no:4061/2007
CNR:SCIN010040612007

Parties & Advocates

Petitioner

1
Ministry Of Finance Secretary

Petitioner Advocate

1
B. Krishna Prasad

Respondents

1
Bhawani Plastics Its Proprietor Shri Sudeep Agarwal
2
State Of Uttaranchal Industries Department, Secretary
3
State Of Uttaranchal The Nodal Agency, State Industrial Development Corporation Of Uttaranchal Managing Director
4
Government Of India Ministry Of Commerce And Industry, Department Of Industrial Poloce And Promotion Secretary

Respondent Advocate

1
Sanjai Kumar Pathak

Case History with Orders

15 Jan 2020

Disposed - 15 Jan 2020

Final Status

15 Jan 2020

Order(25) - 15 Jan 2020

ROP - of Main Case

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble B.R. Gavai, Hon'ble Surya Kant
List In:Judge

Disposed off

14 Jan 2020

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble B.R. Gavai, Hon'ble Surya Kant
List In:Judge

Not taken up/ Not Today

19 Nov 2019

Order(24) - 19 Nov 2019

ROP - of Main Case

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Surya Kant
List In:Judge

List After (Weeks) [2]

16 Oct 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

15 Oct 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

3 Oct 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

1 Oct 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

26 Sept 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

25 Sept 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

24 Sept 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

19 Sept 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

18 Sept 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

17 Sept 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

12 Sept 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

5 Sept 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

4 Sept 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

3 Sept 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

29 Aug 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

28 Aug 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

27 Aug 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

22 Aug 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

21 Aug 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

20 Aug 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

14 Aug 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

8 Aug 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

7 Aug 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

6 Aug 2019

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice, Hon'ble Hon'Ble The Chief Justice
List In:Judge

27 Jul 2017

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:After Week/month/vacation
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble J. Chelameswar, Hon'ble S. Abdul Nazeer
List In:Judge

13 Jul 2017

Order(23) - 13 Jul 2017

ROP - of Main Case

First Hearing

Initial hearing scheduled

Indirect Taxes Matters : Interpretation Of Exemption Notifications Under Central Excise Act

Purpose:Fixed Date By Court
Category:Unknown
Before:Hon'ble J. Chelameswar, Hon'ble S. Abdul Nazeer
List In:Judge

29 Nov 2013

Order(22) - 29 Nov 2013

ROP

Order(21) - 29 Nov 2013

Office Report

1 Nov 2013

Order(20) - 1 Nov 2013

ROP

Order(19) - 1 Nov 2013

Office Report

9 Jan 2013

Order(18) - 9 Jan 2013

ROP

9 Aug 2012

Order(17) - 9 Aug 2012

ROP

5 Jul 2012

Order(16) - 5 Jul 2012

ROP

25 Apr 2012

Order(15) - 25 Apr 2012

ROP

29 Feb 2012

Order(14) - 29 Feb 2012

ROP

18 Jan 2012

Order(13) - 18 Jan 2012

ROP

2 Dec 2011

Order(12) - 2 Dec 2011

ROP - of Main Case

1 Nov 2011

Order(11) - 1 Nov 2011

ROP - of Main Case

14 Sept 2011

Order(10) - 14 Sept 2011

ROP - of Main Case

8 Aug 2011

Order(9) - 8 Aug 2011

ROP - of Main Case

20 Apr 2011

Order(8) - 20 Apr 2011

ROP

30 Nov 2007

Order(7) - 30 Nov 2007

ROP

24 Jul 2007

Order(6) - 24 Jul 2007

ROP - of Main Case

23 Jul 2007

Order(5) - 23 Jul 2007

ROP

18 May 2007

Order(4) - 18 May 2007

ROP

30 Mar 2007

Order(3) - 30 Mar 2007

ROP

8 Mar 2007

Order(2) - 8 Mar 2007

ROP

23 Feb 2007

Order(1) - 23 Feb 2007

ROP - of Main Case

Case Registered

Registration No: 1000/2007

7 Feb 2007

Case Filed

7 Feb 2007 Filing No: 4061/2007

Tagged Matters (17)

4056/2007(23-02-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000999 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007SLP(C) No. 002751 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007 - CA

Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA THROUGH ITS SECRETARY
Respondent: M/S. MOOL CHAND INDUS. ESTATE P.LTD. THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR SHRI MOOL CHAND AGARWAL
Type: M•Status: P•Entry: 22-06-2015

4820/2007(23-02-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 001002 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007SLP(C) No. 003373 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007 - CA

Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA .DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE CENTRAL BOARD OF EXCISE AND CUSTOMS (CDEC) JOINT SECRETARY
Respondent: WHALE STATIONERY PRODUCTS LTD. C.E.O. SHRI MUKESH GUPTA
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

4822/2007(23-02-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 001005 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007SLP(C) No. 003430 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007 - CA

Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE SECRETARY (TRU)
Respondent: M/S. INDIAN RUBBER PRODUCTS THROUGH ITS PARTNER
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

5416/2007(23-02-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 001015 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007SLP(C) No. 003689 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007 - CA

Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE JOINT SECRETARY (TRU)
Respondent: M/S. TITAN INDUSTRIES LTD.
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

5100/2007(23-02-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 001011 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007SLP(C) No. 003498 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007 - CA

Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA THROUGH ITS JOINT SECRETARY (TRU)
Respondent: WHALE GRAPHIC (INDIA) P. LTD. THROUGH ITS CEO SHRI MUKESH GUPTA
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

4061/2007(23-02-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 001000 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007SLP(C) No. 002752 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007 - CA

Petitioner: MINISTRY OF FINANCE SECRETARY
Respondent: M/S BHAWANI PLASTICS ITS PROPRIETOR SHRI SUDEEP AGARWAL
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

4817/2007(23-02-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 001003 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007SLP(C) No. 003402 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007 - CA

Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE JOINT SECRETARY (TRU)
Respondent: INDO GERMAN BRAKES PVT. LTD. DIRECTOR SH. VIPUL DAWAL
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

5441/2007(23-02-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 001013 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007SLP(C) No. 003700 / 2007 Registered on 23-02-2007 - CA

Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE JOINT SECRETARY
Respondent: M/S INDIAN LPG CYLINDERS (A UNIT OF VISHAL EQUITY SERVICES PVT. LTD.) THROUGH GENERAL MANAGER SHRI H
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

5449/2007(08-03-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 001412 / 2007 Registered on 08-03-2007SLP(C) No. 003826 / 2007 Registered on 08-03-2007 - CA

Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA
Respondent: M/S. B.K. WIRE INDUSTRIES LTD.
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

6317/2007(08-03-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 001414 / 2007 Registered on 08-03-2007SLP(C) No. 004354 / 2007 Registered on 08-03-2007 - CA

Petitioner: ASST. COMMNR., CENTRAL EXCISE
Respondent: M/S STEEL POINT SOLE PROPRIETOR SHRI A.K. ARORA
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

6466/2007(30-03-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 002111 / 2007 Registered on 30-03-2007SLP(C) No. 005185 / 2007 Registered on 30-03-2007 - CA

Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF FINANCE THROUGH ITS SECRETARY
Respondent: M/S SHAKTI STEELS .
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

7397/2007(02-04-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000381 / 2020 Registered on 17-01-2020SLP(C) No. 007315 / 2007 Registered on 02-04-2007S.L.P.(C)...CC No. 002975 / 2007 Registered on 02-04-2007 - CA

Petitioner: SECY.,DEPT.OF REVENUE,C.B.E.C.
Respondent: THE STATE OF UTTARAKHAND
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

12885/2007(18-05-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 002823 / 2007 Registered on 18-05-2007SLP(C) No. 009017 / 2007 Registered on 18-05-2007 - CA

Petitioner: JOINT SEC.TO THE GOVT.OF INDIA
Respondent: M/S ZEBRA ZIPPERS PVT LIMITED SHRI RAMESH KUMAR ARORA
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

12565/2007(18-05-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 002824 / 2007 Registered on 18-05-2007SLP(C) No. 009019 / 2007 Registered on 18-05-2007 - CA

Petitioner: UNION OF INDIA DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL POLICY AND PROMOTION MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRIES
Respondent: MAHINDRA MANAGING DIRECTOR
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

12981/2007(18-05-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 002822 / 2007 Registered on 18-05-2007SLP(C) No. 008977 / 2007 Registered on 18-05-2007 - CA

Petitioner: JOINT SECRETARY, MIN.OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRIES
Respondent: M/S. FORBES GOKAK LIMITED
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

16316/2007(23-07-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000382 / 2020 Registered on 17-01-2020SLP(C) No. 013159 / 2007 Registered on 23-07-2007S.L.P.(C)...CC No. 006175 / 2007 Registered on 23-07-2007 - CA

Petitioner: M/S. SANT STEEL AND ALLOYRS PVT. LTD.
Respondent: GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

25812/2007(30-11-2007 12:00 AM)C.A. No. 000383 / 2020 Registered on 17-01-2020SLP(C) No. 023674 / 2007 Registered on 30-11-2007S.L.P.(C)...CC No. 011387 / 2007 Registered on 30-11-2007 - CA

Petitioner: L. V HEAT EXCHANGERS
Respondent: GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
Type: C•Status: P•Entry: 09-03-2019

Earlier Court Details (32)

Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-778-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
Yes
Judgment Type:
Final
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
RA-305-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
MA-807-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-263-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
RA-304-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
MA-809-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-380-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
MA-10996-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-381-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
SA-4255-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-405-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
MA-10997-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-574-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-556-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-542-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-335-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-1188-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
RA-277-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
MA-812-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-624-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
RA-303-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
MA-811-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-552-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
IRA-11767-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-1160-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-266-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-1254-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-553-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-456-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-1012-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-407-2006
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-
Court:
High Court
State:
UTTARAKHAND
Case No:
WP-628-2005
Order Date:
2006-12-19
Judgment Challenged:
No
Judgment Type:
-

Share This Case

Similar Case Search
Case Content Last Updated22 Aug 2025, 11:42 am IST