SECTIONIX IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

PETITIONS FOR SPECIAL LEAVE TO APPEAL (CIVIL) NOS. 11717, 10794, 11721, 11722, 11723, 11724, 11725, 11726, 11727, 11728, 11729, 11730, 3049030491 AND 37678 OF 2013, 17881 AND 22048 OF 2014 AND 6717, 6718, 6719, 6720, 6721, 6722, 6723, 6724, 6725, 6726, 6727, 6728, 6730 of 2016

WITH PRAYER FOR INTERIM RELIEF

WITH

INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION NO. 3

(Application for impleadment filed by Mr. V. R. Anumolu, Advocate in SLP (C) No. 11717 of 2013)

WITH

INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION NO. 4

(Application for permission to file additional documents filed by counsel for the petitioner in SLP (C) No. 11717 of 2013)

WITH

INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION NO. 5

(Application for impleadment filed by Mr. G. B. Sathe, Advocate in SLP (C) No. 11717 of 2013)

STATE OF MAHARASHTRA & ORS. ...PETITIONERS

VERSUS-

CHETAN SURESHRAO BENDE & ANR. ...RESPONDENTS

OFFICE REPORT

The matters abovementioned were listed before the Hon'ble Court on 15th

September, 2014, when the Court was pleased to pass the following Order:

"List these matters for final disposal in the month of November, 2014, on a non-miscellaneous day."

Thereafter the matters was again listed before the Hon'ble Court on 4th March,

2016, when the Court was pleased to pass the following Order:

"Permission to file SLP granted. Delay condoned. Issue notice in CC No. 11340/2013, CC No. 11368/2013, CC No. 11549/2013, CC No. 11584/2013, CC No. 11599/2013, CC No. 11624/2013, CC No. 11671/2013, CC No. 11689/2013, CC No. 11827/2013, CC No. 12001/2013, CC No. 12737/2013, CC No. 12803/2013, CC No. 12807/2013. Service be completed in all the matters within four weeks. Dasti, in addition."

SLP	NUMBER<br>OF<br>RESPONDENTS	SERVED	UNSERVED<br>Respondent<br>No.	REMARKS
11717/2013	2	-	1 and 2	-
10794/ 2013	2	Respondent No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through<br>M/S<br>Lambat<br>&<br>Associates, Adv.	2	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>respondent No. 1.
11721/2013	3	Respondent No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through<br>Mr.<br>Nirnimesh<br>Dube, Adv.	2 and 3	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>respondent No. 1.
11722/2013	3	Respondent No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through Mr. B.<br>K. Mishra, Adv.	2 and 3	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>respondent No. 1
11723/2013	3	Respondnet No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through<br>Mr.<br>Nirnimesh<br>Dube, Adv.	2 and 3	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counsel for R. No. 1
11724/2013	3	V/A filed by<br>Ms. Madhumita<br>Bhattacharjee,<br>Adv. for R.No. 1	2 and 3	Counter<br>affidavit<br>filed<br>by<br>counsel for R. No. 1
11725/2013	4	Respondent No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through<br>Mr.<br>Nirnimesh<br>Dube, Adv.	2 to 4	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counel for R.No. 1
11726/2013	2	Respondent No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through<br>Mr.<br>Nirnimesh<br>Dube, Adv.	2	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counel for R.No. 1
11727/2013	2	Respondent No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through<br>Mr.<br>Birendra Kumar<br>Mishra, Adv.	2	Counter<br>affidavit<br>filed<br>by<br>counsel for R.No. 1
11728/2013	2	Respondent No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through<br>Ms.<br>Madhumita<br>Bhattacharjee,<br>Adv.	2	Counter<br>affidavit<br>filed<br>by<br>counsel for R.No. 1
11729/2013	3	Respondent No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through<br>M/S	2 & 3	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counel for R.No. 1

The detailed service position of the abovementioned SLP's is as follows:

		Lambat<br>&<br>Associates, Adv.
11730/2013	2	Respondent No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through<br>Mr.<br>Birendra Kumar<br>Mishra, Adv.	2	Counter<br>affidavit<br>filed<br>by<br>counsel for R.No. 1
34090-34091<br>/2013	4	R.Nos. 1 and 3<br>represented<br>through<br>Ms.<br>Anagha S. Desai<br>and Mr. Gaurav<br>Agrawal, Advs	2<br>and<br>4<br>(deleted vide<br>Court's order<br>dated<br>01.07.2014)	Counter affidavit filed by Ms.<br>Anagha S. Desai, counsel for R.<br>No. 1<br>Counsel for the petitioner has<br>not deposited Court fee, hence<br>amended cause title could not be<br>taken into record as per Court's<br>order dated 01.07.2014. Service<br>is complete.
37678/2013	1	Sole respondent<br>by Ms. Anagha<br>S. Desai, Adv.	-	Counter<br>affidavit<br>filed<br>by<br>counsel for sole respondent.<br>Service is complete.
6717/16	4	Respondent No.<br>1 is represented<br>through<br>Mr.<br>Rabin<br>Majumdar, Adv.	2 to 4	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counsel for R.No. 1<br>Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6718/16	4		1 to 4	Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6719/16	2	Respondent No.<br>1 is represented<br>through<br>Ms.<br>Madhumita<br>Bhattacharjee,<br>Adv.	2	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counsel for R.No. 1<br>Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6720/16	2	-	1 & 2	Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6721/16	2	Respondent No.<br>1 is represented<br>through<br>Mr.<br>Sudhanshu<br>S.<br>Chaudhary, Adv.	2	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counsel for R.No. 1<br>Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6722/16	3	Respondent No.<br>1<br>represented<br>through Mr. B K<br>Mishra, Adv.	2 & 3	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counsel for R.No. 1<br>Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6723/16	2	Respondent No.<br>1 is represented	2	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counsel for R.No. 1

		throughMs.<br>Anagha<br>S.<br>Desai, Adv		Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6724	3	Respondent No.<br>1 is represented<br>through<br>Mr.<br>Rabin<br>Majumdar, Adv.	2 & 3	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counsel for R.No. 1<br>Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6725/16	2	Respondent No.<br>1 is represented<br>throughMs.<br>Anagha<br>S.<br>Desai, Adv	2	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counsel for R.No. 1<br>Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6726/16	2	-	1 & 2	Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6727/16	3	-	1 to 3	Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6728/16	3	Respondent No.<br>1 is represented<br>through<br>Mr.<br>Rabin<br>Majumdar, Adv.	2 & 3	Counter affidavit not filed by<br>counsel for R.No. 1<br>Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
6730/16	2	-	1 & 2	Notice through usual mode<br>could not be issued as the<br>counsel has not filed spare<br>copies of the petition.
17881/14	1	Respondent No.<br>1 is represented<br>through Mr. C S<br>Ashri, Adv.	-	Counter affidavit filed.
22048/14	2	Both<br>the<br>Respondents<br>are represented<br>through<br>Ms.<br>Anaga S. Desai,<br>Adv.	-	Counter affidavit filed on behalf<br>of Respondent No. 1 only.

It is further submitted that in SLP (C) Nos. 6717 to 6728 and 6730 of 2016 , Dasti notice was given to the counsel for the petitioner but affidavit of dasti service has not been filed by him so far.

The matters abovementioned are listed before the Hon'ble Court with this report.

Dated this the 3rd day of January, 2017.

ASSISTANT REGISTRAR

Copy to :

Mr. Nishant R. Katneshwarkar, Advocate Mr. C. S. Ashri, Advocate Ms. Anagha S. Desai, Advocate Mr. Rabin Mazumdar, Advocate Mr. B. K. Mishra, Advocate Ms. Madhumita Bhattacharjee, Advocate Mr. Nirnimesh Dube, Advocate M/S Lambat & Associates

L ASSISTANT REGISTRAR