IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 141 OF 2014

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Allflex India Pvt.ltd. ....RESPONDENT

WITH SUITS NO. 3293 OF 2010

Bharat B. Patel ....PLAINTIFF V/S

Shapoorji Pallonji And Co And Anr ....DEFENDANT

WITH SUITS NO. 737 OF 2016

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PLAINTIFF V/S Spinks India Private Limited ....DEFENDANT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 348 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER

V/S

Ms Videojet Technologies India Private Limited....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 360 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S M/s, Sarin Technologies India Private Limited And Anr ....RESPONDENT

WITH COMMERCIAL SUIT NO. 351 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S M/s Laser Imprez And Anr ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 381 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Vision Embesoft Solution ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 394 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel	PETITIONER
V/S
M/s. Ramson Industries And 3 Ors	RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 382 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S M/s. Variety Hallmark ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 379 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER

....DEFENDANT

Ms Skf India Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 423 OF 2017

Page 3/17

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Ms Tata Motors Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL SUIT NO. 411 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Kraftwares (india) Ltd. And 4 Ors. ....RESPONDENT

WITH

Ms Scantech Laser Private Limited And 2 Ors....RESPONDENT

WITH SUITS NO. 501 OF 2016

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PLAINTIFF

WITH COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 424 OF 2017

M/s Sahajanand Laser Technology Limited And

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 416 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S

V/S

V/S

3 Ors

Page 4/17

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S

M/s Mehta Cad Cam Systems Private Limited....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 888 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 892 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S

Micro Laser ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 887 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER

V/S

Mass Transfer Products Industries Pvt Ltd And Anr. ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 29 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Havells India Limited. ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 74 OF 2018

Magic Touch ....RESPONDENT

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Star Laser Technology ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 137 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S

Renassiance Jewellery Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 153 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 171 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Unique Laser Engravers And Ors. ....RESPONDENT

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 177 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S S H Pitkar Orthotools Private Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 297 OF 2018

Raymond Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

WITH

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S

Kristeel Shinwa Industries Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 485 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S

Malhotra Graphics ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 697 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER

V/S

Edicon Mining Equipment Private Limited And 3 Ors. ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 866 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel	PETITIONER
V/S
Mrj Technologies And Anr.	RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 1193 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Secure Seals India Private Limites ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 1439 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Miraclus Orthotech Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 1442 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Nrb Bearings Ltd ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 1421 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Hyundai Motor India Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 1428 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Ortho Max Mfg Co Pvt Ltd ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 1546 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Inor Medical Products Ltd ....RESPONDENT

WITH COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 5 OF 2019

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Sandvik Asia Private Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 36 OF 2019

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER

V/S Carl Zeiss India (bangalore) Private Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 44 OF 2019

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Titan Company Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 583 OF 2019

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Teknic Control ....RESPONDENT

WITH COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 350 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Indian Files Pvt.ltd. And 2 Ors. ....RESPONDENT

WITH COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 380 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S M/s Akshar Laser Marking And 2 Ors ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 1559 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Seco Tools India Pvt Ltd ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 1129 OF 2018

V/S

WITH COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 178 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Bhalaria Metal Crafts Private Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 235 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S M/s. Uma Surgicals ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 318 OF 2019

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER

Marktech Laser Marking ....RESPONDENT

Page 10/17

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Rita Pad Printing Systems Ltd ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 354 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S

M/s. Goldiam International Limited And 4 Ors.....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 358 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S M/s Nokia India Private Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 43 OF 2019

Bharat Bhogilal Patel	PETITIONER
V/S
Quantum Equipment Co Pvt Ltd	RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 487 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Seepz Gem And Jewellery Manufacturers Association Sgjma And 8 Ors. ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 56 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Taegutec India Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 577 OF 2019

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Bell Surgical ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 606 OF 2019

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Rosy Blue (india) Private Limited ....RESPONDENT

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 865 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Sahajanand Technologies Private Limited And 3 ....RESPONDENT

Ors.

WITH COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 95 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Photon Technologies ....RESPONDENT

WITH COMMERCIAL SUIT NO. 316 OF 2018

WITH

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Leitz Tooling Systems India Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 353 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S M/s. Suresh Indu Lasers Private Limited And 4 ....RESPONDENT

Ors

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 48 OF 2019

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Maruti Suzuki India Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 561 OF 2019

Bharat Bhogilal Patel	PETITIONER
V/S
Intex Technologies India Limited	RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 234 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Ip Rings Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 357 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER

V/S

M/s. Samsung India Electronics Private Limited....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 356 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S

M/s Sigma Mechotronics Private Limited And 3 Ors. ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 352 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S M/s. Agile Machineries Pvt.ltd. And 3 Ors. ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 370 OF 2017

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S M/s. L G Electronics India Private Limited ....RESPONDENT

WITH

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 43 OF 2018

Bharat Bhogilal Patel ....PETITIONER V/S Mark Plus ....RESPONDENT

Adv. Priyanka Bhanushali i/b Ketan Parekh and Co. For Plaintiff.

Mr Yatin Khochare, Mr. Minesh Avdharia, Mr. Jay Shah and Mr. Hardik Sampat i/b Krishna and Saurastri for Defendant – NMCD/956/2018, COMIP/137/2018.

Ms. Amruta Thakur and Mr. Aniket Bomble i/b W S Kane and Co for Defendant – COMIP/141/2014.

Sanjana Pandey i/b Krishnamurthy and Co. For Defendant – COMIP/44/2019.

Ms. Tanmayi Rajadhyaksha a/w Adv. Akshay Sawant a/w Adv. Yash Pitroda i/b I. V. Merchant and Co. For Defendant. In COMS 411/2017.

Ms. Tanmayi Rajadhyaksha a/w Adv. Akshay Sawant a/w Adv. Yash Pitroda i/b I. V. Merchant and Co. For Defendant. In COMIP/394/2017

Ms. Amruta Thakur and Mr. Aniket Bomble i/b W. S. Kane and Co. For Defendant in COMIP/1156/2018

Ms. Amruta Thakur and Mr. Aniket Bomble i/b W. S. Kane and Co. For Defendant in COMIP/927/2018

Ms. Amruta Thakur and Mr. Aniket Bomble i/b W. S. Kane and Co. For Defendant in COMIP/359/2017

Dormaan Dalal for the Applicant in NMCD/62/2020 AND NMCD/1572/2018 AND DEF. IN COMIP/355/2017

Markand Kale i/b Pravin Kamble for Def in S/141/2014

Piyush Shah a/w Jay Vora for Def. In comip/356/2017, COMIP/381/2017

and applicant in IAL/10865/23 AND IAL/11153/23.

Rinku Gajria, Raina Gajria i/b Gajria and Co for Defendant. In COMIP/424/2017 a/w IAL/17826/23.

Nooruddin Dhilla i/b AZB and Partners for Defendant in COMIP/1442/2018.

Adv. Mansi Patel a/w Adv. Shrushti Dandu i/b Adv. Mansi Patel for Defendant in COMIP/606/2019

Adv. Siddha Pamecha a/w Adv. Jay Chheda for Def. No. 1 in COMIP/360/2017

Adv. Atmaram patade a/w adv. Shikha, Adv. Pranav Manjrekar and Adv. Suraj Naik i/b Adv. Atmaram Patade for def. in COMIP/141/2014 WITH COMIP/43/2019.

Adv. Mr. Vicky Singh a/w Adv. Mr. Meit Sampat i/b Little and Co for Defendant COMIS/1193/2018.

Adv. Nirav Shah for Def No. 1, 2 and 4 in COMM IP SUIT/354/2017.

Mr. Akshay Kapadia a/w Mahua Roy Chowdhury and Janhavi Singh i/b Royzz and Co. For Def in COMIP/379/2017.

Adv. Vijay Singh i/b Abhijeet Desai for Respondent 1, 2, 3 in .COMIP/424/2017 AND COMIP/416/2017.

Adv. Murlidhar Khadilkar, Aakash Joshi Manish Rai Hiten Wasan i/b MAG LEGAL for Defendant in commp/297/2018.

Adv. Suvarna Joshi for Defendant. In S/234/2017.

Adv. Rutwik Rao for Defendant in COMIP/561/2019.

Adv. Ankit Rajput i/b Law Cell for Defendant in suit/737/2016.

Adv. Shashwat Rai a/w Mr. Shuvam Agarwal i/b Keystone Partners in COMIP/887/2017- Def. 1,2. COMS/316/2018.

Adv. Amey Nargolkar, Janaksinh Jhala and Dhiren Karania i/b Khaitan and Co for Defendant and Counter Claimer in S/501/2016 AND NMS/262/2017

Adv. Amey Nargolkar, Janaksinh Jhala and Dhiren Karania i/b Khaitan and Co for Defendant in COMIP/56/2018.

Adv. Amey Nargolkar, Janaksinh Jhala and Dhiren Karania i/b Khaitan and Co for Defendant and Counter claimer In COMIP/153/2018 and Counter Claim 12/2019.

Deepak Deshmukh, Sujoy Mukherji, Nisha Kaba i/b Anand and Naik for Defendant in COMIP/371/2017 and COMIP/36/2019 AND COMIP/29/2018 AND COMIP/1421/2018 AND COMIP/358/2017 AND COMIP/1559/2018 AND COMIP/5/2019 AND COMIP/370/2017 AND COMIP/36/2019.

Adv. Shikha Ghosh for Teknic Control defendant. In comip/583/2019.

Adv. Shikha Ghosh for MRJ Technologies and Anr. (all def.) IN COMIP/866/2018. (Mentioned)

CORAM :	HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE R. I. CHAGLA J
DATE<br>:	4th July, 2023

P.C. :

S. O. to 25/07/2023 .

( ASSOCIATE )