The Commanding Officer vs. The State Of Ap And 126 Ors.
AI Summary
Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order
Order Issued After Hearing
Purpose:
Disposed
Before:
Hon'ble Honourable Mrs. Justice Susmita Phukan Khaund
Listed On:
16 Dec 2022
Original Order Copy
Get a certified copy of this order
Order Text
GAHC040015172022
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) (ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : IA(C) 248/2022
1:The Commanding Officer 116 RCC (GREF), 116 Road Constr Coy (GREF). PIN 930116, C/O 99 AP.
VERSUS
1:THE STATE OF AP and 126 Ors. Represented through the Chief Secretary, GoAP, Itanagar, AP
2:The Secretary Land Management Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh Itanagar.
3:The Deputy Commissioner Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
4:Topenso Tega S/o Mishe Tega
Resident of Village Abohagam
PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
5:Rapentso Achonyu S/o Lt. K. Achonyu
Permanent Resident of Village Aphomna Chagalagam Dalai Valley
Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
6:Muenso Achonyu S/o Yatong Tega
Resident of Village Aphomna PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
7:Jamtem Achanyu S/o Khayama Taflap
Resident of Village Aphomna PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
8:Nibren Achanyu S/o P. Achanyu
Resident of Village Aphomna PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
9:Katam Flakam W/o Topenso Tega
Resident of Village Tafalagam PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
10:Chokhi Taflap S/o T. Taflap
Resident of Village Taflagam Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
11:Kulelam Apho S/o A. Apho
Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
12:Hacholing Apho S/o S. Apho
Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
13:Jaluso Achunyu S/o P. Achunyu Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
14:Johilee Achunyu S/o M. Achunyu
Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
15:Petin Achunyu S/o T. Achunyu
Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
16:Buglelum Tega S/o Lt. D. Teja
Resident of Village Chaglongam Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
17:Melan Bellai S/o Late Titusa Bellai
Resident of Village Taflagam Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
18:Titusa Bellai S/o Lt. T. Bellai
Resident of Village Taflagam
Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
19:Tiwaiiliary Bellai (Taflap) S/o Domo Taflap
Resident of Village Taflagam Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
20:Mamta Achuyu S/o Shri A. Achumyu
Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
21:Humanglum Achunyu S/o Shri A. Achunyu
Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
22:Aahika Achonya S/o Shri A. Achunyu
Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
23:Baiso Apho S/o Shri C. Apho. Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
24:Badyalom Apho S/o Shri C. Apho
Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
25:Yeteng Flakam S/o Shri Resident of Village Tarampa Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
26:Sohra Apho S/o Shri M. Apho
Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
27:Jageso Apho S/o Shri C. Apho
Resident of Village Aphomla Dalai
PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
28:Manso S/o Shri K. Satam
Resident of Village Chaka Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
29:Niram Tega S/o Shri M. Tega
Resident of Village Tegmla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
30:Bomden Achonyu S/o Shri B. Achonyu
Resident of Village Aphunla Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
31:Ganju Tega S/o Shri Jingling Tega
Village Tegamna Dalai
PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
32:Wechali Ritti S/o Shri S. Ritti
Resident of Village Tegamna Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
33:Alianso Ritti S/o Shri S. Ritti
Resident of Village Rittiliay
Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
34:Samai Flakam S/o Shri B. Flakam
Resident of Village Tarampa Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
35:Surin Flakam S/o Shri Y. Flakam
Resident of Village Tarampa Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
36:Chelelam Flakam S/o Shri S. Flakam
Resident of Village Tarampa Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
37:Babrum Tega S/o Shri S. Flakam
Resident of Village Taflagam Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
38:Disamlu Tayang W/o Topinso Tega
Resident of Village Abohagun
Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
39:Mitinum Masap S/o Shri S. Masap
Resident of Village Khoraling Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
40:Jouinlu Tega S/o Shri M. Tega
Resident of Village Abohagam
Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
41:Sowailum Samba S/o Shri A. Samba
Resident of Village Ziro
Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
42:Ranaso Flakam S/o Shri K. Flakam
Resident of Village Taflagam Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
43:Likhasai Tega W/o Shri Jinraso Tega
Resident of Village Abohagam Dalai PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
44:Hulensai Achenyu S/o K. Achonyu
Resident of Village Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
45:Ruhilu Apho D/o B. Apho
Village Aphumna
PO Khupa PS Hayuliang PO/PS Anjaw DIstrict Arunachal Pradesh.
46:Pikelum Hagare S/o Late B. Hagabre
Village Chakka PO Khupa PS Hayuliang PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
47:Sita Hagabre D/o B. Hagabre
Village Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
48:Sujulu Satam W/o M. Satam
Village Chakka
PO Khupa PS Hayuliang PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
49:Sokhowe Krong S/o Late B. Krong
Village Hayuliang PS Hayuliang PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
50:Peresai Hagabre D/o M. Hagabre
Vill. Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang
51:Renalu Hagabre D/o M. Hagabre
Vill Aphumna
PO Khupa PS Hayuliang.
52:Pakusai Apho M/o B. Apho
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang 53:Achojo Apho H/o K. Apho
Village Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang PO/PS Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
54:Wemamso Kora S/o Tatum Kora
Vill Yealing PS Sunpura PO Lohit Lohit District Arunachal Pradesh.
55:Sunsary Krong S/o B. Krong
Vill. Hayuliang PO/PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
56:Galong Mai S/o S. Mai
Vill Abohagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
57:Turen Apho S/o S. Apho
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh. 58:Romalu Kora D/o D.Kora Vill-Taflagam PO-Khupa PS- Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
59:Tenalum Taflap S/o B. Taflap Vill-Taflagam PO- Khupa PS- Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
60:Egeanlum Taflap S/o B. Taflap
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
61:Reku Apho W/o B. Apho
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
62:Tutum Kora S/o W. Kora
Vill Yealing PS Sunpura PO Lohit.
63:Chosamso Hagabre
S/o S. Hagabre
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
64:Huiman Achonyu S/o H. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang.
65:Uju Mai S/o T. Hagabre
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
66:Ratenso Achonyu S/o Lt. N. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
67:Dujilum Achonyu S/o Lt. N. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
68:Nifeng Achonyu
S/o Lt. N. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
69:Tasiso Achonyu S/o Lt. N. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
70:Diaynso Flakam S/o Lt. M. Flakam. Vill Tarampha PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
71:Anelu Achonyu D/o N. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
72:Kamholum Achonyu D/o N. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh. 73:Sodem Achonyu S/o K. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
74:Sumita Achonyu D/o N. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
75:Biminsai Achonyu D/o N. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
76:Soruso Achonyu S/o Lt. N. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
77:Priyanlu Achonyu D/o R. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh. 78:Akhil Achonyu S/o R. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
79:Jitenso Flakam S/o Y. Flakam
Vill Tarampa PO Khupa PS Hayuliang.
80:Mopenlum Taflap S/o Late G. Taflap
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
81:Damasai Flakam W/o Y. Flakam
Vill Tarampa PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
82:Bojen Flakam D/o S. Flakam
Vill Tarampa PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh. 83:Kamkholum Flakam D/o R. Flakam
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
84:Seselum Bellai S/o S. Bellai
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
85:Pensiliang Achonyu W/o D. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
86:Pinya Apho D/o K. Apho
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
87:Najamlu Bellai D/o S. Bellai
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
88:Nigamso Bellai S/o S. Bellai
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
89:Bapang Mai S/o T. Mai
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
90:Tabaso Bellai S/o Premso Bellai
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
91:Khulisa Bellai D/o T. Bellai
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
92:Nmasthamai Bellai S/o M. Bellai
Vill Taflagam
PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
93:Sipi Flakam D/o M. Flakam
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
94:Premlu Achonyu D/o R. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
95:Biramso Pul S/o B. Pul. Vill Hayuliang PO/PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
96:Ramjo Pul S/o B. Pul
Vil Hayuliang PO/PS Hayuliang
97:Sujenlu Flakam W/o Y. Flakam
Vill Tarampa PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
98:Taklolum Bellai S/o Lt. B. Bellai
Vill Gomin PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
99:Rohimso Ritti S/o G. Ritti
Vill Rittling PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
100:Joshi Ritti S/o G. Ritti
Vill Rittling PO Hayuliang PS Khupoa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
101:Sulensu Ritti D/o G. Ritti
Vill Rittling PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
102:Thaklum Ritti S/o G. Ritti
Vill Rittling PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
103:Dimsailum Taflap S/o K. Taflap
Vill Rittling PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
104:Yeromso Samba S/o S. Samba
Vill Hayuliang PO/PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
105:Kriyalu Achaonya D/o K. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
106:Pailaisai Achonyu D/o R. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
107:Plodung Achonyu S/o C. Achonyu. Vill Aphumna PO Khupa
PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunchal Pradesh.
108:Mafraksai Tega W/o B. Tega
Vill Tegamna PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
109:Badiu Tega S/o K. Tega
Vill Tegamna PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
110:Doli Krong W/o K. Tega
Vill Tegamna PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
111:Jijilum Flakam D/o Lt. M. Flakam
Vill Tegamna PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
112:Debea Achonyu D/o J. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
113:Banimlum Taflap S/o B. Taflap
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
114:Kamliangso Tega S/o N. Tega
Vill Abohagam PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
115:Bamin Taflap S/o C. Taflap
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
116:Palisai Tega W/o B. Tega
Vill Tegamna PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
117:Rahil Achonyu
S/o R. Achonyu
Vill Aphumna PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
118:Enam Bellai S/o D. Bellai
Vill Gomin
PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
119:Galong Mai S/o B. Mai
Vill Abogham PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
120:Bailum Taponyu F/o C. Taponyu
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
121:Dipanso Taflap S/o J. Taflap
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh. 122:Chulum Tapanyu S/o B. Taponyu
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
123:Atelum Taflap S/o C. Taflap
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
124:Sonamso Tega S/o B. Tega
Vill Tegamna PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
125:Aphoya Taflap D/o C. Taflap
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
126:Enamso Flakam S/o Y. Flakam
Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh.
127:Choyin Bellai S/o D. Bellai Vill Taflagam PO Khupa PS Hayuliang Anjaw District Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner : Marto Kato
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP)
BEFORE HONBLE MRS. JUSTICE SUSMITA PHUKAN KHAUND
ORDER
Date : 16-12-2022
Heard Mr. M. Kato, learned DSGI representing the applicant.
Also, heard Mr. S. Mow, learned counsel for respondent 4 to 127 and Mr. D. Kamduk, learned standing counsel for the Land Management representing the respondent No.2 as well as Mr. Y. Riram, learned Government Advocate for respondent No. 1 & 3.
It is submitted that 3(three) more months time is required from the date of receipt of the approved Land Acquisition estimate from the Opposite Party No.2 for making payment of the compensation amount to the tune of Rs. 35,94,01,935/- to the land owners as directed by this Court vide order dated 08.09.2022, passed in WP(C)320(AP)2021. An order was passed to pay the compensation within one month from the date of passing the order.
It is submitted that no Land Acquisition estimate, duly approved by the
Government of Arunachal Pradesh, to concerned department was received, for which, the approval by the Ministry of Defence, cannot be processed and the applicant has written a letter to the Opposite Party No.2, vide letter dated 23.09.2022, 06.10.2022 & 25.10.2022 for furnishing of L.A Estimate to the same to the Deputy Commissioner, Anjaw, for further compliance. The Opposite Party No.2 has not yet furnished the copy of the Land Acquisition duly approved by the State Government neither to the applicant nor to the Opposite Party No.3 till date.
It is submitted that unless duly approved L.A estimate of the aforesaid land compensation is furnished to the applicant for onward process of approval and sanction by the Higher Authorities and same is released to the applicant, the aforesaid compensation amount cannot be deposited in the account of the Opposite Party No.3.
It is submitted that the acquiring authority is the Ministry of Defence, Government of India, through the Directorate of Border Road Organization (DGBR) and the land compensation has to be paid by the aforesaid Ministry. Certain procedure has to be followed for which a reasonable time is required for obtaining sanction and approval from the Higher Authorities.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent No.4 to 127 has raised objection stating that already the respondents are suffering immensely as they are now landless and that too without compensation.
I have given my anxious consideration to the submissions at the bar. Petition is disposed of granting 2(two) months time to the applicant to commensurate the process of funds and thereby depositing the same in the account of opposite party No.3. The Deputy Commissioner, Anjaw District is to furnish a copy of duly approved land estimate compensation to the tune of Rs.35,94,01,935/- within a period of 2 (two) days from today and thereafter, the applicant to expedite the payment of compensation without further delay. Once the compensation is received by the Opposite party No. 3, the money to be released to the beneficiary, forthwith, within a period of 15 (fifteen) days from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
With the above observation, this I.A. stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant