St Thomas College Of Education vs. The State Of Andhra Pradesh
AI Summary
Get an AI-powered analysis of this court order
Order Issued After Hearing
Purpose:
Final Hearing
Before:
Hon'ble Gannamaneni Ramakrishna Prasad
Listed On:
29 Mar 2023
Original Order Copy
Get a certified copy of this order
Order Text
HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATHI
| WP/2094/2023 | WP/1924/2023 | WP/1954/2023 | WP/1957/2023 | WP/1963/2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WP/1964/2023 | WP/1965/2023 | WP/1966/2023 | WP/1974/2023 | WP/2096/2023 |
| WP/2097/2023 | WP/2098/2023 | WP/2101/2023 | WP/2105/2023 | WP/2108/2023 |
| WP/2109/2023 | WP/2110/2023 | WP/2111/2023 | WP/2112/2023 | WP/2113/2023 |
| WP/2114/2023 | WP/2115/2023 | WP/2116/2023 | WP/2117/2023 | WP/2120/2023 |
| WP/2126/2023 | WP/2130/2023 | WP/2132/2023 | WP/2133/2023 | WP/2134/2023 |
| WP/2279/2023 | WP/2616/2023 | WP/2640/2023 | WP/2727/2023 | WP/2728/2023 |
| WP/2734/2023 | WP/2752/2023 | WP/3032/2023 | WP/3034/2023 | WP/3036/2023 |
| WP/3053/2023 | WP/3056/2023 | WP/3093/2023 | WP/3099/2023 | WP/3100/2023 |
| WP/3918/2023 | WP/3919/2023 | WP/3942/2023 | WP/3944/2023 | WP/4147/2023 |
| WP/4157/2023 | WP/4169/2023 | WP/4178/2023 | WP/4193/2023 | WP/4199/2023 |
| WP/4379/2023 | WP/4398/2023 | WP/4406/2023 | WP/4408/2023 | WP/4413/2023 |
| WP/4437/2023 | WP/4450/2023 | WP/6658/2023 | WP/35193/2022 | WP/35195/2022 |
| WP/35197/2022 WP/35198/2022 | WP/35199/2022 | WP/37939/2022 | WP/42469/2022 | |
PROCEEDING SHEET
| S1. | ORDER | Office | |
|---|---|---|---|
| No | DATE | Note | |
| 29.03.2023 | GRKP, J | ||
| Heard in part. | |||
| Learned Counsel for APSCHE has<br>$2.$ | |||
| submitted a tentative schedule. Learned | |||
| Counsel for the Writ Petitioners have also | |||
| received the Schedule. | |||
| $3.$<br>Sri V. Hemanth Kumar, Learned | |||
| Counsel representing NCTE submitted that, the | |||
| discussions and deliberations, which took place | |||
| between the APSCHE and the Universities, were | |||
| neither made known to the NCTE nor was the | |||
| NCTE called-upon to participate in the | |||
| deliberations. He submits that NCTE ought to | |||
| have been called-upon to participate in these | |||
| deliberations so that the NCTE would also |
indicate its concerns during the process of discussion. It so transpired that the NCTE would hold independent inspection which is different from the inspections being held by the respective Universities. This Court has suggested that a Joint Inspection be made consisting members of NCTE as well as the respective Universities in order to prevent duplication or repetition of inspections, which are not enduring to the benefit of either of the Colleges or the Students.
-
The paramount consideration of this Court being that the Students shall have seamless educational course in the respective Colleges, the Court has suggested that the existing system of inspections, reports, recommendations and penalties will have to be rationalized to see that, there shall be one initial inspection, which will be a Joint Inspection by the members of NCTE as well as the members of the respective Universities, and there shall be one Report reflecting the opinion/reflections of the NCTE as well as the Universities either jointly or individually. Even if the concerns of these bodies are independent, it shall be so stated in the Report, but there shall be one Report reflecting the opinion/reflections of both the expert bodies.
-
Sri V. Hemanth Kumar, Learned
2
| Counsel appearing for NCTE,<br>has sought time to |
|---|
| put forth the schedule submitted by the APSCHE |
| to the NCTE for further consideration.<br>The |
| NCTE, APSCHE and the Universities shall make |
| an<br>endeavour<br>to<br>constitute<br>one<br>Inspection |
| Committee (Fact Finding Committee) jointly and |
| submit a Report as indicated above. |
| 6.<br>List as Part-Heard on 12.04.2023 for |
| further consideration. |
| 7.<br>NCTE<br>may<br>also<br>file<br>an<br>Affidavit |
| expressing its<br>concerns<br>before the next date. |
| 8.<br>Appearance of JNTU, Kakinada and |
| Ananthapur, is dispensed with. |
| 9. Registry is directed to print the name of |
| V. Hemanth Kumar, Learned Counsel,<br>who is |
| Respondent No.4,<br>in all the cases. |
| 10.<br>De-tag WP.No.17825 of 2022. |
| ________________ |
| GRKP, J |
| KPV |